← Whispers in the Vineyard

The Neighbor's Gate

Chapter 5 of 18 · 4861 words

The morning came up hot and clear, the light so white on the stone that it seemed to have a sound, a high thin ringing like a glass rubbed at the rim. Camille had been awake since five, lying in her grandmother's bed under the slope of the ceiling, listening to the cicadas start up one by one until the whole hillside was sawing with them. The letter from the mason's guild lay on the nightstand, and beside it the boundary map she had found in the desk drawer, and beside that the photocopy of the 1923 cadastral survey with its disputed strip of hillside shaded in a pencil so old it had gone the color of dried blood.

She had read the survey eleven times. She had walked the boundary twice, once at dusk and once in the dark with a flashlight, and both times she had come to the same line of stones on the ridge above the lavender, the old borne marking the corner, and both times she had stood there looking down at the Morel land, at the neat rows of their vines and the tile roof of their bastide glowing in the last light, and had not gone any farther.

Today she would go farther.

She dressed in the clothes she had bought in the village two days before—cotton shirt, canvas trousers, boots that were not city boots—and she made coffee in the little pot on the two-ring stove, and she drank it standing at the door of the house looking out over her own vines, which were not dead, which were in fact putting out leaves in a green so tender it hurt to look at, and she thought: it is not a trespass to knock on a neighbor's door. It is not a declaration of war to ask a question. Whatever the old people did to each other, the land does not care, and the wine does not care, and I am not my grandmother and he is not his.

She believed about half of that. She took the map and the survey copy and put them in the passenger seat of the little Renault, and she drove.

The road to the Morel estate went up around the far side of the ridge, past the shrine with its plaster Madonna gone green at the shoulders, past a field of sunflowers already bowing their heads under the weight of their own seed, and then down into a shallow bowl of land where the vines ran in long clean lines to a house of pale stone with blue shutters and a row of plane trees that threw a shade you could feel from the road. The gate was iron, and open. She drove through it and felt her stomach turn over once, slow and deliberate, like a stone rolling in a stream.

The yard was swept. That was the first thing. The yard was swept and the gravel was raked and the lavender along the walk was cut back hard and neat, and there were roses climbing the wall by the door, and under the plane trees a long table with a checked cloth and a jug of water and a bowl of apricots, as if someone had just stood up from it. The whole place had the quality of a thing being cared for, continuously and without fuss, by hands that knew what they were doing. It made her angry in a way she did not expect and could not have explained.

She got out of the car. The air smelled of hot stone and cut grass and, underneath, the sweetish mineral breath of a cellar working somewhere out of sight. A dog barked twice from behind the house and then stopped. A man came around the corner of the building carrying two empty crates stacked on his shoulder, and he saw her and stopped.

He was sun-browned the way only people who work outside are sun-brown, to the throat and the forearms, and his hair was dark and too long and pushed back off his forehead with the flat of a hand that had not been washed since morning. He wore a shirt with the sleeves torn off at the shoulder, and his boots were gray with dust, and there was a smear of something on his jaw that might have been grease or might have been the juice of the fruit. He looked at her for a long moment. Then he set the crates down, one on top of the other, and he said, in a voice that was careful and flat:

"Mademoiselle Roux."

"Monsieur Morel."

They stood there in the swept yard under the noise of the cicadas. She had rehearsed this. She had rehearsed it in the car, and in the shower, and in the dark at four in the morning, and every rehearsal had begun with her being gracious and ended with her being in the right. But the rehearsals had not accounted for the way he would look at her—not hostile, exactly, not even cold, but closed, like a door that has been fitted too well to its frame and does not rattle no matter how you pull at it.

"You found the road all right," he said.

"It's not difficult to find."

"No." He wiped his hands on his trousers, which did not help. "No, it isn't. Would you like something? Water? It's going to be a hot one."

"Thank you. No." She heard her own voice and hated it, the Paris in it, the clippedness. "I've come about the boundary. The strip above the lavender—the old borne, the line of stones. I found the 1923 survey in my grandmother's desk. There's a discrepancy. Your land and mine, the way the survey draws it, the line runs about eleven meters west of where the stones are now."

He did not move. The dog barked again, once, from behind the house, and was silent.

"I know what the survey says," he said.

"Then you know there's a question."

"There's no question." He picked up the crates again and shifted them to his hip, and she saw the muscles in his forearm stand out with the weight, and she was aware of herself noticing it and was annoyed. "The stones are where the stones have always been. My grandfather walked that line with the syndic in 1954. It's settled."

"It's settled because no one has contested it in seventy years. That isn't the same as being right."

Something changed in his face. It was very slight, a tightening around the eyes, and it was gone almost before she saw it, but she had seen it. He set the crates down again, more slowly this time, and he came a few steps toward her, and he stopped at a distance that was still polite and was no longer friendly.

"Mademoiselle Roux," he said. "Your grandmother and my grandfather did not speak for fifty years. Do you know why?"

"Because of the land. Because of 1923."

"Because of the land," he agreed, "and because of everything that came after. And I will tell you what I have been told my whole life, which is that it isn't mine to reopen and it isn't yours either. The dead made this quarrel. Let them keep it." He looked at the map in her hand, and then at her face. "You've come a long way to pick at a scab. I'd advise you to leave it alone."

"I'm not picking at anything. I'm trying to understand what I've inherited. There's a difference."

"Is there." He said it without heat, which was somehow worse than heat. "You've been here—how long? Three weeks? Four? You came from Paris to bury your grandmother and you found a vineyard that hasn't turned a profit since the nineties and a set of books that don't balance and a neighbor you've been told to hate. And now you've found a piece of paper that says eleven meters of my hillside might be yours, and you've driven over to tell me so. I understand what you've inherited, mademoiselle. I'm asking you to consider whether you want to inherit the quarrel along with the land."

The cicadas sawed. The sun moved a fraction of an inch across the yard. She felt the heat of it on the back of her neck and the slow hot rise of her own temper, and she held it, because she had not come to shout, and because some part of her—the sommelier's part, the part that had learned to taste and not to judge—recognized that he was not being cruel. He was being tired. He was being a man who had been handed a quarrel he did not want and had carried it anyway, out of loyalty, for thirty-four years, and who had just been asked by a stranger in city boots to carry it a little longer.

"I didn't come to reopen it," she said, and was surprised to find that it was true, or true enough. "I came because I found a document I don't understand and a cellar I can't read and vines that are half dead from neglect, and because I don't know a single person in this valley who will tell me the truth about any of it. Your name came up. That's all. Your name came up, and I thought—" She stopped. She had been about to say, I thought you might be the one person who would tell me the truth, and she was glad she had stopped, because it would have been too much, and too soon, and too close to something she did not want to look at.

He waited. When she did not go on, he said, quietly, "What did you think?"

"I thought a neighbor might answer a question," she said. "I was wrong."

She turned to go. She had her hand on the car door when he spoke again.

"Wait."

She turned back. He was standing with his hands on his hips, looking at the ground, and then he looked up at her, and the closedness in his face had opened a little, the way a shutter opens when the wind gets under it.

"Have you eaten?" he said.

"What?"

"It's nearly noon and you drove up here angry and you haven't eaten. Sit down. I'll get you some water. I won't talk about the survey, and I won't talk about 1923, and I won't talk about your grandmother or my grandfather, and you won't either, and we'll eat apricots and you can tell me what's wrong with your vines. That I'll talk about. That's not the quarrel. That's just farming."

She should have said no. She knew she should have said no. But the anger had gone out of her all at once, leaving a hollow that was very like hunger, and the shade under the plane trees looked cool and the apricots in the bowl were the color of the late sun, and she heard herself say, "All right. Thank you."

He brought a second chair and a second glass and a stone jug of water beaded with cold, and he set them on the table and pulled out her chair and then sat down across from her and poured. The water tasted of the well, of limestone and cold and something faintly green. She drank half the glass before she remembered to be embarrassed.

"Now," he said. "The vines."

She told him. She had not meant to tell him so much, but once she began it came out of her in a rush, the way water comes out of a cracked pipe. The parcels she had inherited, eleven of them, scattered across the hillside in the old patchwork way; the ones that were still good, the old grenache on the north slope and the syrah on the terraces, and the ones that were not, the mourvèdre gone woody and the cinsault eaten back by the rot, the rows she had walked and counted and catalogued with a city woman's need to put things in order. The irrigation that had not been serviced in a decade. The tractor that would not start. The cellar full of barrels she was afraid to open because she did not know what she would find, or worse, because she did know.

He listened. He did not interrupt. He ate an apricot, and then another, and he turned the pit of the second one over and over in his fingers while she talked, and when she was done he said:

"The mourvèdre. The old block, the one that runs down toward the stream."

"Yes."

"That block was your grandmother's best. In '89 and '90 it made a wine that—" He stopped, and looked at the pit in his fingers, and set it down on the cloth. "It made a very good wine. If it's gone woody, it's because it hasn't been pruned properly in six or seven years. Mourvèdre will sulk if you let it. It wants to be told what to do." He looked up at her. "You can bring it back. Not this year. Not next. But you can bring it back."

"How?"

He stood up. "Come on. I'll show you."

She followed him out of the shade and across the yard and down a track between the vines, and the heat came down on them like a hand. The rows on either side of the track were his own, and they were beautiful, and she could not help seeing it. The leaves were a deep healthy green and the fruit was setting in tight hard clusters, and the ground between the rows was worked and clean, and the wires were taut and the posts were straight, and every so often there was a rosebush at the end of a row, and every so often a little box of wood and wire that she did not recognize.

"What are those?"

"Bat boxes. And the roses—they tell you if there's mildew before the vines do. Roses are more delicate. If the roses are clean, the vines are clean." He glanced at her. "It's not new. My grandfather did it. His father did it. It's just farming, mademoiselle. It's only ever been farming."

They came to the far end of the rows, where the land dropped away toward the stream, and he stopped and pointed.

"Look at the difference," he said. "Your block is over there, across the stream. Look at the leaves. See how they curl at the edges? See how the green is going yellow between the veins? That's not the rot. That's the water. The roots are drowning or they're starving, one or the other, and you can't tell which without digging. Dig first. Dig before you do anything else. Take a spade and dig down a meter in three places and look at the roots and smell the soil. If it smells of rotten eggs, it's drowning. If it smells of nothing at all, it's starving. Then you'll know what to do."

She looked across the stream at her own block, her grandmother's block, and she saw what he saw: the curling leaves, the yellow between the veins, the canes gone thin and gray. And she felt, suddenly and without warning, a grief so sharp and specific that it took her breath. Not for her grandmother, who had died in her sleep at eighty-nine and had been ready. For the vines. For the years of neglect, the seasons that had come and gone while no one pruned and no one dug and no one told the mourvèdre what to do. The land had been waiting. The land had been patient. And the land had been dying, quietly, while the family that owned it looked the other way.

"Thank you," she said, and her voice was not quite steady.

He heard it. She saw him hear it. And he did the kindest thing he could have done, which was to look away, out over the stream, and say nothing at all for a moment, and then to say, in a completely ordinary voice, "Would you like to taste?"

"Taste what?"

"The wine. You're a sommelier, aren't you? That's what they tell me." He said it without mockery. "I have some in the cellar. It's not a tasting room. It's just a cellar. But you've come a long way."

She should have said no. She had already said yes once when she should have said no, and she knew, in the way you know the shape of a hill before you climb it, that this was the second yes and that the second yes was the one that mattered. But the sun was hot and the grief was in her throat and she wanted, more than she had wanted anything in a long time, to taste something that someone had made with care.

"Yes," she said. "I'd like that."

The cellar was older than the house. She knew it the moment they came down the steps into the cool dark, the air changing around her from the hot dry breath of the yard to the wet mineral breath of the underground, and she stopped on the last step and breathed it in. Limestone. Oak. The sweet-sour ghost of fermentation. And under it all, faint and clean, the smell of the wine itself, of a cellar that is working and healthy and alive.

He clicked on a light. The cellar ran back into the hill, a long low vault of stone, and the barrels stood along both walls in double rows, and there were more of them than she had expected, many more, and they were not dusty. They were clean. The hoops were bright. The chalk marks were fresh. And at the far end, where the vault went dark, there were bottles in racks, hundreds of them, lying on their sides and sleeping.

"Which one?" she said.

"You tell me." He was watching her, his arms folded, and there was something in his face now that had not been there in the yard. Not warmth, exactly. But interest. The interest of a man watching a craftsman at work. "You're the sommelier. I'll pour and you'll tell me what you taste. That's the game, isn't it?"

"That's not a game. That's my job."

"Then do your job."

He took a glass from a shelf, and a thief from a hook, and he went to a barrel in the middle of the left-hand row and drew a little wine into the glass and handed it to her. It was very dark, almost black at the center, and it smelled of the cellar and of something else, something that came up out of the glass as she swirled it—blackberry, and the wet stone of the place, and a note of something savory, of thyme and hot dust and the resin of the pines that grew along the ridge. She put her nose down into the glass and breathed, and then she tasted.

The wine was extraordinary.

She had tasted extraordinary wines all her life. She had tasted them in Paris in rooms where the stems were crystal and the spittoons were silver and the bottles cost more than her rent, and she had learned to be unmoved by them, to hold them at a distance, to score them and set them down. But this was not that. This was a wine that tasted of a place she had just walked across, of the hot stone and the clean worked rows and the shade of the plane trees, and there was a balance in it, a quietness, a rightness, that she had not tasted in anything since—she could not remember since when. It was not trying to be anything. It was being what it was.

She held it in her mouth a long time. She swallowed. She set the glass down on the barrel and looked at him.

"It's very good," she said.

He laughed. It was a short laugh, surprised out of him, and it changed his whole face. "Very good. That's what you say?"

"What do you want me to say?"

"The truth. You're a sommelier. You don't have to be polite."

She picked up the glass again. She looked at it, and then at him, and she made a decision she would think about later, in the dark, in her grandmother's bed, and be unable to explain to herself.

"The truth," she said, "is that I have tasted wines from the best addresses in France and some of them cost more than this whole cellar is worth, and none of them in the last five years have made me want to stop working and drink the bottle. This does. It tastes of the place. It tastes of the limestone and the sun and the pines on the ridge, and it has a—a quietness to it, a kind of restraint, that I don't find very often. It's not trying to impress me. It's just being itself. That's the rarest thing there is." She set the glass down again. "There. That's the truth. Is that what you wanted?"

He did not answer for a moment. He was looking at the glass on the barrel, and then at her, and the closedness in his face had opened all the way now, the shutter swung wide, and behind it there was something she had not expected: a kind of relief, as if she had lifted a weight off him that he had been carrying so long he had forgotten it was there.

"Yes," he said. "That's what I wanted."

They stood there in the cool of the cellar, and the light from the single bulb fell yellow on the barrels and the dust and the two of them, and she was aware of the smell of the wine and the wet stone and the faint animal warmth of him standing a meter away, and she was aware of the silence, and of the cicadas faintly audible even down here, a thin sawing at the edge of the world.

Then he said, "I'll tell you something about the boundary. Not the quarrel. The land."

"All right."

"The strip above the lavender—the eleven meters. It doesn't matter. Not for the vines. The soil is the same on both sides of the stones. It's the same slope, the same drainage, the same exposure. Whatever the survey says, whatever the syndic said in 1954, the wine from those eleven meters would taste the same whether it went into your barrels or mine. The land doesn't care. It never cared. That's what I've never been able to make anyone understand." He looked at her. "The old people made a quarrel out of eleven meters of hillside that God himself could not tell apart from the rest. And the wine has been paying for it for a hundred years."

She thought of the cellar she had opened three days before, the dust and the empty barrels and the bottles in the alcove still waiting to be counted, and she thought of the vines curling their leaves across the stream, and she felt the grief come up in her again, and with it something else, something that was almost like hope.

"Then why don't you end it?" she said. "You're the one who says it doesn't matter. You're the one who says the land doesn't care. So why not walk down the hill and say so?"

"Because it isn't mine to end," he said, and there was the tiredness again, the old worn tiredness. "My father is alive. My grandfather is alive. They would not forgive me. And because—" He stopped.

"Because what?"

"Because your grandmother is dead," he said, "and mine is dead, and the two of them took the whole truth into the ground with them, and I don't know what I would be ending. I don't know what the quarrel is. I only know that it isn't what they told us it was. My grandfather would not speak of it, ever, not once, not even at the end. He would go quiet. He would leave the room. A man does not leave the room over a boundary stone." He looked at her. "A man leaves the room over something he cannot say."

The cellar held its breath. Somewhere above them, in the hot white light, the cicadas went on sawing, and the stream went on running under the stones, and the vines on both sides of the boundary went on putting out leaves in a green so tender it hurt to look at.

"There are letters," Camille said. She had not meant to say it. She said it before she knew she was going to. "In the alcove, in my grandmother's cellar. There's a rack of bottles and a wooden box, and the box is full of letters. I found them the day before yesterday. I haven't read them. I opened the box and saw the handwriting and I closed it again." She looked at him. "I don't know what they say. But I think—I think they might say what your grandfather could not."

He did not move. The yellow light lay on his face and she could see him thinking, could see the old loyalty and the new curiosity pulling against each other in him, could see the quarrel he had carried since before he could remember and the thing she was offering him, which was not the end of it but the beginning of an understanding.

"Read them," he said at last. "And then—" He stopped, and started again. "And then come back. If you want to. If there's something in them that should be known. Come back and tell me, and we'll decide together what to do with it. Not the old people's way. Not the syndic and the survey and the fifty years of silence. Our way." He picked up the glass, and held it out to her, the extraordinary wine still dark at the bottom of it. "Finish your glass, mademoiselle. It's a shame to waste it."

She took the glass from him. Their fingers touched on the stem, briefly, and she felt it go up her arm like the cold of the cellar and the heat of the sun at the top of the steps, both at once, and she did not look away and neither did he.

"Camille," she said. "If we're to decide things together, you should call me Camille."

"Camille," he said. He said it slowly, as if he were tasting it, and then he nodded, once, and stepped back, and the moment closed, and he was the winemaker again, courteous and guarded and sun-browned, and the door that had opened was not shut but it was no longer wide.

"Lucas," he said. "Come on. I'll walk you up."

They went up the steps into the white heat of the afternoon, and across the swept yard, and past the table under the plane trees where the apricots sat in their bowl, and he opened the gate for her and stood aside, and she got into the little Renault and rolled down the window.

"Dig first," he said. "Three places. A meter down. Smell the soil."

"I will."

"And read the letters."

"I will."

He nodded. He stepped back from the car. And then, as she turned the key and the engine caught, he said, in a voice that was almost lost under the noise of it, "Camille. The wine you tasted—it's from the block above the stream. My side of the stones. Eleven meters from your line." He looked at her. "I thought you should know. Whatever it means. Whatever the old people would have made of it. I thought you should know."

She held his eyes for a moment through the open window. The cicadas sawed. The sun beat down on the swept yard and the blue shutters and the row of plane trees, and the dust of the road hung gold in the air behind her, and she thought of the wine in her mouth, the quietness of it, the wet stone and the pines and the hot dust, and she thought: it tastes of the boundary. It tastes of the eleven meters. It tastes of the quarrel, and the land that never cared about it, and the two of us standing on either side of a line of stones that God himself could not tell apart from the rest.

"Thank you for telling me," she said.

"Drive carefully," he said. "The road down is bad at the corner."

She drove down, and around the corner where the road was bad, and past the shrine with its green-shouldered Madonna, and past the sunflowers bowing their heavy heads, and all the way back to the Roux vineyard she did not turn on the radio, and the wine stayed in her mouth, and the letters in their wooden box in the alcove behind the press waited in the dark for her to come and read them.