First Pruning
The pruning shears arrived on a Tuesday, in a cardboard box so battered it looked as though it had been kicked from Marseille. Camille found it on the doorstep of the *mas* when she came down for her coffee, and she stood in the cold blue light of early morning turning it over in her hands before she understood what it was. There was no note. There was never any note. The box had been taped shut with packing tape gone brittle and yellow, and inside, nested in old newspaper that smelled of someone else's cellar, lay a pair of *sécateurs*—the heavy, curved kind, with wooden handles rubbed smooth by decades of palms and a blade that still held a faint, lovely gleam.
She did not know, then, that Lucas had sent them. She would not know for weeks. But she held them up to the light, and something in her chest turned over like a stone in a river, and she thought: *I am going to have to use these. On the vines. Which means I am going to have to learn how.*
The vines did not wait for her to learn how.
January in Provence was a knife of a month—bright and cold and mercilessly clear, the sky a hard enamel blue, the mistral coming down the Rhône valley to strip the last leaves from the plane trees and scour the limestone white. The vineyard lay dormant, but dormant was not dead, and every day she walked the rows and saw the same thing: the canes shooting up wild and unpruned, last year's growth gone woody and chaotic, the whole of it a tangled scribble against the sky. The vines needed cutting back. They needed a hand that knew where to cut, and how much, and why. Left alone another season, they would exhaust themselves into a thicket of useless wood and give no fruit at all.
She had asked around the village. She had asked at the *coopérative*, and at the hardware store, and at the bistro, where Solène had listened with her chin in her hand and then said, slowly, "There is one man. But you won't like him."
"Why won't I like him?"
"Because he's old, and he's rude, and he worked for your grandmother for thirty years, and he has opinions about Parisians."
"I'm not a Parisian. I'm a Roux."
"*Chérie,*" Solène said, "to Baptiste, anyone who has ever taken the TGV is a Parisian."
His full name was Baptiste Aubert, and he lived in a stone cottage at the far edge of the village where the houses gave up and the scrub began, and when Camille knocked on his door on a Wednesday morning he opened it, looked at her from under a pair of eyebrows like two grey caterpillars, and said, "No."
"I haven't said anything yet."
"You're the granddaughter. I know. You want me to prune your vines. No."
He started to close the door. She put her hand flat against it—a city gesture, presumptuous, and she saw his eyes narrow at the impertinence of it—and said, "I'm not asking you to work for me. I'm asking you to teach me."
That stopped him. He stood in the doorway with his hand on the frame and looked at her for a long moment, and she looked back, and the mistral came around the corner of the cottage and lifted the hair off her neck and set the bare branches of his fig tree rattling.
"Teach you," he said, flat.
"So I can do it myself."
"You'll ruin your hands."
"They're already ruined. I've been clearing the cellar for a month."
He looked at her hands. She had not thought about them in years—they were a sommelier's hands, or had been, pale and quick and used to the cool curve of a glass; now they were cracked at the knuckles and stained with the rust of old iron and there was a healing cut across the base of her thumb from a broken demijohn. Baptiste looked at them the way a horseman looks at a horse's legs.
"*Bon,*" he said at last, and something in his face shifted, not warmth exactly, but the grudging acknowledgement of a fact. "Be here at seven tomorrow. Bring gloves. Not those." He nodded at her hands. "Real ones. Leather. And bring a thermos. It's cold in the vines and I don't stop for the cold."
He shut the door. She stood on the step a moment, the wind working at her collar, and then she laughed—a short, surprised sound, alone in the empty street—and walked back through the village with her hands shoved in her pockets and her heart, for no reason she could name, absurdly light.
---
Seven o'clock in January in Provence was not yet dawn. The sky was a deep slate grey going pale at the edges, and the frost lay in the furrows of the vineyard like spilled sugar, and the vines themselves stood in their rows in the half-light looking, Camille thought, like nothing so much as a company of old men in grey coats, bent and patient and waiting.
Baptiste was already there. Of course he was already there. He stood at the head of the first row with his bicycle propped against a stone wall and a canvas bag at his feet, and he watched her come down the track with the flat, appraising patience of a man who has seen a great many people be late and has drawn his conclusions. She was not late. She checked her watch. She was, in fact, four minutes early.
"You're early," he said, which was not a compliment. "Early means you're nervous. Nervous means you'll be careless. Come."
He led her into the row. The frost crunched underfoot. He stopped at the first vine—an old one, a Grenache, its trunk thick and gnarled and twisted like a fist of dark wood, its arms splayed out along the wire in a shape that had been trained into it over twenty years and more—and he put his hand on it the way a man puts his hand on the shoulder of an old friend.
"This is your grandmother's vine," he said. "This one. The first of the row. She planted the row, and this was the first, and she called it *la patronne.*" He glanced at Camille. "You didn't know that."
"No."
"No. Well." He turned back to the vine. "Now. Look at it. Look properly. Don't look at the whole thing, that's nothing but a mess of wood. Look at the wood. Find the trunk. Find the arms. Find last year's growth—that's the pale stuff, the whippy stuff, the stuff that grew in the summer and went to sleep in the autumn. See it?"
She saw it. Once he said it, she could not unsee it: the two kinds of wood, the old dark permanent skeleton and the young pale canes that shot off it, long and thin and tangled.
"*Bien.* Now here is the thing you must understand before you make a single cut." He held up one finger. "The vine is not a tree. A tree you can leave alone and it will make more tree. A vine you cannot leave alone, because the vine does not want to make grapes. The vine wants to make wood. Grapes are a by-product. Grapes are what the vine does with its surplus, when it has one, and if you let it make all the wood it likes it will make no surplus and no grapes and it will become a bush, and a bush is good for nothing but burning. So." He held up the shears—his own, older even than the ones on her doorstep, the handles black with a lifetime of grease and grip. "You cut. You cut most of it away. Three-quarters, four. You leave the good canes—two, three, the ones that grew in the right place and the right direction and have the right thickness—and you cut everything else back to the arm. And you do it every year. Every year you cut and every year it grows and every year you cut. That's the whole of it. That's the whole of everything." He shrugged. "The rest is just knowing which canes are the good ones. That takes forty years. You have a week."
He made the first cut to show her. The blade went through the cane with a sound like a small bone breaking—a clean, sharp, final sound—and the severed piece dropped into the frost, and the vine, which had been a tangle, became suddenly and obviously a shape. He made three more cuts in as many minutes, and by the end of them the vine stood pruned and pared and bare, its two chosen canes tied down along the wire with a twist of raffia, and it looked, Camille thought, like a dancer at the barre: reduced, disciplined, ready.
"Now you," he said, and handed her the shears.
Her hands, in the new leather gloves, were clumsy. The shears were heavier than she expected—the weight all forward, in the blade—and the first cane she tried to cut she botched, crushing it instead of severing it, so that the wood splintered and tore and Baptiste made a sound in his throat like a man watching someone step on a cat.
"No. *Non.* You don't chew it. You don't gnaw at it like a rat. You put the blade here, flat against the arm, and the hook here, and you *squeeze*—" He mimed it with his hands. "One motion. Clean. The vine must not know it has been cut until it is already healing. A ragged cut is a wound. A clean cut is a door."
She tried again. The second cane went better. The third went clean—she felt it go, felt the blade bite and pass through and the cane drop free—and she made a small sound of triumph before she could stop herself.
"*Voilà,*" Baptiste said, without enthusiasm. "You have cut one cane. There are four thousand vines in this parcel and perhaps twelve canes on each. You do the arithmetic. I will not do it for you."
She did the arithmetic. She wished she had not.
---
The frost did not lift until nearly ten, and by then her fingers had gone numb inside the gloves and her nose was running and her lower back had begun the long slow complaint that would, by afternoon, become a steady scream. They worked down the row, the two of them, Baptiste moving ahead of her with the quick economy of a man who had done this every winter for fifty years, Camille following with her shears and her thermos and her growing, humbling awareness of how much she did not know.
He did not talk much. When he did, it was to correct her, or to tell her a thing about the vine, or—once, unexpectedly—to tell her a story.
"Your grandmother," he said, not looking at her, working at a vine three down from hers, "she pruned her own vines until she was seventy. After that she stood at the end of the row and told me what to cut. She had the eye. Better than mine. She could look at a vine and see what it would be in three years—which cane would fruit and which would fail and which would make wood that would fruit the year after. She would stand there with her stick and say, *not that one, Baptiste, that one is lazy,* and she was always right. Always. I never once knew her wrong."
Camille's shears paused in the air. "You worked with her for thirty years."
"Thirty-four."
"Did you—" She did not know how to ask it. "Did you know about the Morels? The feud?"
The shears in his hand went still. He was quiet a moment, and the mistral came down the row and shook the bare wires and set the vines creaking.
"Everyone knows about the Morels," he said at last. "It is the village's favorite story. Two families, one hill, a hundred years of spite. They tell it in the bistro when the wine is good and they tell it badly." He looked at her then, sidelong, with those grey caterpillar eyebrows. "But I will tell you a thing, since you are here and your hands are bleeding and you have not once complained about the cold. The story they tell in the bistro is not the story. The story they tell is about land. The story I remember is not about land at all."
"What is it about?"
He turned back to his vine. "Ask your grandmother," he said. "She left you letters, didn't she? She told me she would. She said, *Baptiste, when I am gone, the girl will come, and she will not understand, and she will need to understand, and I will not be there to tell her, so I will write it down.*" He made a cut. The cane dropped. "She wrote it down. Whether you have read it is your business. But do not ask me to tell you what is in her letters. That is not my place. My place is the vines."
And that was all he would say, and he would not be drawn further, and Camille worked the rest of the morning with her grandmother's name going around and around in her head like a stone in a jar.
---
By noon her hands had begun to bleed.
She had not noticed at first—the cold had numbed everything, and the gloves were thick, and she was concentrating so hard on the cuts that she had stopped paying attention to her palms. But when she stopped to drink from her thermos and pulled off the right glove with her teeth, she saw it: the leather inside was dark and stiff, and her palm was a mess of broken blisters, three of them, one already open and weeping, the raw pink skin beneath shining in the cold light. The base of her thumb had split where the shears had rubbed it. There was blood in the creases of her fingers, dried to a brown crust, and a fresh bead welling at the edge of the split.
She stared at her hand. She had not had a blister since she was a child. She had spent fifteen years handling wine glasses and decanters and the cool smooth necks of bottles, and her hands had been soft and quick and elegant, and now they were—she turned the other one over—now they were the hands of a stranger. Cracked. Swollen. Bleeding.
"*Bon,*" Baptiste said, coming up the row. "Now you are a vintner."
"I'm a sommelier."
"You *were* a sommelier. Now you are a woman with a split thumb standing in a frozen field at noon. That is a different thing." He took her hand—surprisingly gently, for all his gruffness—and turned it over and looked at it. "The blisters will heal and become callus. The split will heal and become a scar. In ten years your hands will be like mine and you will not be able to feel the difference between a warm glass and a cold one, and you will not care, because you will have learned to feel it with your eyes." He let her go. "Eat something. Then we go again."
They ate sitting on the stone wall at the head of the row, bread and cheese and a sausage he produced from his canvas bag, and the sun came out from behind a cloud and lay along the vines like a hand, and Camille ate with her sore hands and looked out over the vineyard and felt, for the first time since she had come, that she was not a visitor in it.
"Baptiste," she said, with her mouth full. "Why did you say yes? When I asked you to teach me. You said no first. Then you said yes. Why?"
He chewed. He looked out over the vines. He was quiet so long she thought he would not answer.
"Because you asked me to teach you," he said at last. "Not to do it for you. In fifty years, I have had three people ask me to teach them. Your grandmother was the first. A boy from the village was the second, and he went to Lyon to work in a bank, which was sensible of him. And now you." He wiped his mouth with the back of his wrist. "The rest of them—the ones who come from the cities with their money and their ideas—they ask me to do it, or they ask me to tell them how, and then they do not listen. You asked me to teach you. And then you listened. And then you bled. That is three things, and three things are enough."
He stood and brushed the crumbs from his trousers. "Come. The light is going. We have four hundred vines to do before the frost comes back."
---
The afternoon was the hard part. The sun crossed over and the shadow of the hill came down the rows, and the cold came back into the ground, and Camille's hands, which had begun to swell, would no longer close properly around the shears. She had to use both hands to work the handles, and every cut sent a bright flare of pain up through her palm, and she began to count the vines out loud under her breath—*deux cent un, deux cent deux, deux cent trois*—because counting was the only thing that kept her from stopping.
And then, somewhere around vine two hundred and forty, something happened.
She was working on a vine that had gone neglected for two seasons, its canes a thicket, its shape lost, and she was tired and cold and her hands hurt and she was cutting on autopilot, and then she stopped. She did not know why she stopped. She stood with the shears open and looked at the vine, and she saw it—really saw it, the way Baptiste had told her to see it—saw the trunk and the arms and the old wood and the new, saw the canes that had grown in the right place and the right direction, saw which ones were strong and which were lazy, saw, in a way she could not have explained, what the vine was trying to do and what it would do if she helped it, and what it would fail to do if she did not.
She made the cuts. Four of them, quickly, cleanly, the blade biting and passing and the canes dropping to the frost. She tied down the two she had chosen. And when she stepped back, the vine stood pruned and pared and bare, shaped and disciplined and ready, and she felt—she did not know how to name it—she felt as though she had been let in on a secret.
"*Bien,*" Baptiste said, from behind her, and she had not heard him come up. He was standing with his hands in his pockets, looking at the vine, and his face had something in it she had not seen before. "You have the eye. Like her. I wondered."
"I don't know what I did."
"No. That is how you know it is real. The ones who know what they are doing are the ones who have not learned yet. You did it because you stopped thinking and started looking. That is the whole of it. That is the whole—" He stopped. He looked at the vine. "Your grandmother used to say the same. She said, *Baptiste, the vine will tell you what it needs if you stop telling it what you want.*" He cleared his throat. "Come. It is getting dark. We finish this row and then we go home."
They finished the row. The sun went down behind the hill and the sky turned the color of a peach and then of a bruise, and the mistral dropped, and the vineyard went very still. And in the stillness Camille stood at the end of the row with her bleeding hands and looked back at the work she had done—the long line of vines, each one cut and shaped and tied, each one reduced to its essential self—and she thought about what Baptiste had said.
*The vine will tell you what it needs if you stop telling it what you want.*
She had spent her whole life telling things what she wanted. In Paris, in the restaurant, she had told wine what she wanted—she had learned to taste it and judge it and name its faults, to hold it up to the light and find the flaw. She had been very good at it. She had been proud of it. And now she stood in a frozen field with her hands bleeding and she understood, in a way she could not have explained to anyone in Paris, that she had been doing it backward her whole life. The wine had been telling her what it needed. She had just been too busy telling it what she wanted to listen.
---
Baptiste came to the door of the *mas* that evening with a tin of salve.
"Your grandmother's recipe," he said, when she opened the door. "Lavender and beeswax and something else she never told me. Put it on before you sleep or your hands will stiffen and you will not be able to hold the shears tomorrow." He looked past her into the house, at the kitchen with its one lamp and its cold hearth, and something in his face softened. "You have not lit the fire."
"I didn't know how."
"*Bon Dieu.*" He came in without being asked—the way old men do in villages, as though doors were a formality and houses were common property—and knelt at the hearth and had the fire going in three minutes, the kindling catching and the logs taking and the flames leaping up and throwing their light across the room. He stood and dusted his hands. "There. Now you will be warm. And tomorrow you will come at seven and we will do the next parcel, and the day after that the next, and in a month the pruning will be done and you will have hands like a farmer and a back like a question mark and you will have learned the first thing there is to learn about this place, which is that it does not care whether you love it. It only cares whether you show up." He went to the door. "Seven o'clock. Bring the salve. And bring more bread. You ate all of mine."
He was gone before she could thank him. She stood in the doorway with the tin in her hands and watched him wheel his bicycle down the track into the dark, and the cold came in around her ankles, and she closed the door and sat down by the fire and opened the tin.
The salve smelled of lavender and beeswax and something else—something green and faintly resinous, rosemary perhaps, or the resin of the pines that grew on the hill above the vineyard. It was the smell of her grandmother's hands. Camille remembered it suddenly and completely: sitting on her grandmother's lap as a child, the old woman's hands on hers, that smell. She had not thought of it in twenty years. She had not known she remembered it until this moment, and now it came back all at once, and she sat by the fire with the tin open in her lap and cried—not hard, not for long, but the way you cry when something you thought was lost turns out to have been in your pocket all along.
Then she put the salve on her hands, and it stung, and she wrapped them in the clean cloth Baptiste had left, and she sat by the fire and watched the flames and thought about the vine.
*The vine is not a tree. The vine wants to make wood. Grapes are what the vine does with its surplus.*
She thought about her grandmother standing at the end of a row with her stick, saying *not that one, Baptiste, that one is lazy.* She thought about the letters in the drawer of the desk upstairs, the ones she had not yet had the courage to read, the ones that were supposed to tell her about the Morels. She thought about the box on the doorstep with no note, and the shears with the wooden handles rubbed smooth, and the fact that she still did not know who had sent them, though a suspicion had begun to form in her, down deep, like a bubble rising through wine.
And she thought about the work. The cut, the clean cut, the door not the wound. The vine reduced to its essential self so that in the spring it could do what it was made to do. *Every year you cut and every year it grows and every year you cut. That's the whole of it. That's the whole of everything.*
She had come to Provence to sell a vineyard. She had come with her city hands and her city plans and her certainty that the land was a thing you owned and disposed of. And now she sat by a fire she had not known how to light, in a house that smelled of her grandmother, with hands that bled and a back that ached and a row of vines outside that she had cut and shaped and tied with her own two hands, and she understood—dimly, the way you understand a thing before you have the words for it—that she was not going to sell it. That the vineyard had got into her the way the smell of the salve had got into her memory, without asking, without permission, and that it was not going to let go.
She slept that night with her bandaged hands folded on her chest and the fire burning down to embers, and she dreamed of vines—of the long rows going on and on into the dark, each one cut and shaped and waiting, and of a hand that was not her own moving along the wire, tying down the canes, and of a voice she almost recognized saying, *not that one. That one is lazy. That one is for the future.*
---
In the morning her hands were so stiff she could barely close them around the thermos. She stood in the kitchen and worked them open and shut, open and shut, the salve still greasy on the splits, and she looked out the window at the vineyard going pale in the dawn and she thought: *I could stop. I could go back to Paris. No one would blame me. The notary would sell it to the Morels and I would be free.*
And then she thought: *The vine will tell you what it needs if you stop telling it what you want.*
She put on her coat. She put the tin of salve in her pocket and the bread in her bag and she walked out into the cold with her stiff hands shoved in her pockets, and Baptiste was already there, of course he was already there, standing at the head of the next parcel with his bicycle against the wall, and he looked at her hands and he looked at her face and he said nothing at all.
"*Bon,*" he said at last. "You came back."
"I came back."
"Then we work." He handed her the shears—her shears, the ones from the box, and she took them and felt the wooden handles warm in her palm, and she understood, suddenly, that they had been warm when she found them, that whoever had sent them had held them first. "This parcel is different. These are the old vines. Fifty years, some of them. They need a lighter hand. You do not cut an old vine the way you cut a young one. An old vine has less to give and it gives it more carefully, and if you cut it back too hard it will sulk for a year and give you nothing. So you look. You look longer. You cut less. You let the old vine tell you what it can afford." He glanced at her. "Like people."
She followed him into the row. The frost crunched. The sky went from slate to pearl to a pale, thin gold, and the mistral had dropped in the night and the air was still and cold and clear, and somewhere down in the village a dog barked and a church bell rang the hour, and Camille Roux stood at the head of a row of fifty-year-old vines with a pair of shears in her blistered hands and felt, for the first time in her life, that she was exactly where she was supposed to be.
She made the first cut. The blade bit and passed and the cane dropped, and the vine, which had been a tangle, became a shape.
"*Bien,*" Baptiste said, behind her. "Again."
And she cut again. And again. And the morning went on, and the sun came up over the hill and lay along the rows like a hand, and the vineyard, which had been dormant, which had been waiting, began—she could feel it, in the wood, in the cold ground under her boots, in the pale gold light—to wake.