← The Hollow

The Edge of the Trees

Chapter 4 of 17 · 4538 words

The box was heavier than it looked.

Sarah had packed it in a hurry, which meant she had packed it badly—the grade book wedged against a corner, the mug wrapped in a dish towel that had come from her mother's kitchen, the framed photograph sliding loose against the side. She carried it up the walk with her arms burning and her breath fogging in the cold, and she thought, not for the first time, that coming back to Greythorn had been a decision made by a version of herself she no longer entirely recognized. That woman had stood in a cramped apartment in Burlington, had looked at the stack of bills and the letter from the lawyer and the way Lily had started sleeping with the light on, and had thought: *we could go home.*

The house was not home. Not yet. It was her mother's house, the house Sarah had grown up in, and it still smelled like her mother's hand cream and the lavender sachets she hung in the closets, and every room was a small ambush of memory. But it was a house with a yard and a roof that didn't leak and a mortgage that was already paid, and it was three blocks from the school where Sarah had a job, and it was—she had told herself, in the car, on the long drive up through the mountains—it was a place to start.

Lily had been quiet for most of the drive. That was one of the things Sarah had noticed about her daughter lately, the way the quiet had changed. Lily had always been a quiet child, but it had been a *full* quiet, the quiet of a kid listening to everything, thinking about everything, saving it up. Now the quiet felt different. Empty in a way that made Sarah want to fill it.

"Come on, bug," she said, pushing the door open with her shoulder. "Let's get the rest of the boxes."

The house opened up around her, dim and dust-smelling. The morning light came in through the front windows and made long parallelograms on the floor. Somewhere in the kitchen, the refrigerator hummed. Sarah had turned it on the night before, when they'd arrived, and the sound of it was oddly reassuring—a machine doing its job, a house waking up.

She set the box down on the dining table—her mother's dining table, oak, scarred from decades of homework and hot dishes and one memorable Thanksgiving when Sarah's uncle had dropped the turkey—and went back out to the car.

Lily was still in the back seat.

She had her seatbelt on and her hands folded in her lap and her eyes fixed on the window, and she was looking at something. Sarah followed her gaze. Out past the driveway, past the low stone wall that marked the edge of the property, there was the field—the long, sloping field that had once been her father's vegetable garden and had gone fallow years ago—and beyond the field, there was the forest.

The Hollow.

Sarah had grown up with that forest. She had walked its trails as a girl, had picked blackberries along its edges, had never once—she was almost sure—gone in past the first line of trees. It was just a forest. Dark, dense, old, but a forest. The stories were stories. Her mother had told them the way mothers told all stories, to keep children from wandering off, and Sarah had understood that even as a child. *Don't go past the fence line. Don't go into the woods at night. The Hollow doesn't like to be disturbed.* The same stories every kid in Greythorn heard. The same stories she had never believed.

But Lily was looking at it.

"Bug," Sarah said. "Come help me with the boxes."

Lily didn't move. Her hands were still folded in her lap, and her head was tilted slightly, and her lips were moving.

"Lily."

She turned. Her eyes were her father's eyes—that was the thing that undid Sarah sometimes, the way her ex-husband's blue looked out from her daughter's face—and for a moment there was something in them that Sarah didn't recognize. Then it was gone, and Lily was just Lily, eight years old, unbuckling her seatbelt and opening the door.

"Sorry, Mama," she said. "I was listening."

"Listening to what?"

Lily climbed out of the car and stood beside her, and she looked back at the forest. "The trees," she said, like it was obvious. "They're quiet today."

Sarah looked at the forest. It was quiet. It was always quiet—that was one of the things people said about the Hollow, that the birds didn't sing there, that you could walk a mile in and not hear anything but your own footsteps. Sarah had always assumed that was a myth, the kind of thing people made up to make the woods seem scarier than they were. Now she stood in her mother's driveway and listened, and she heard nothing. The wind moved through the high grass of the field, and somewhere a car went by, and the trees at the edge of the forest stood perfectly still.

"Come on," Sarah said, and took Lily's hand. "Boxes."

---

The unpacking took all morning.

It was the kind of work that went faster in your head than in your hands—you thought, I'll just put the kitchen things away, and then you were standing in the kitchen with a box of mismatched spatulas and the memory of your mother standing at the stove in a blue apron, and an hour had gone by. Sarah had known it would be like this. She had braced for it. She had told herself that the first day would be the worst, that she would get through it, that she would cry if she needed to and then she would keep going.

She cried once, in the hallway, holding a box of her mother's books. It wasn't the books themselves. It was the way they smelled. Her mother had kept them in a bookcase by the window, and the pages had absorbed forty years of sun and dust and the faint sweetness of the lilac bush outside the window, and when Sarah opened one of them—a dog-eared paperback of *Middlemarch* with her mother's name written inside the cover in her careful cursive—she had to put it down and walk away and stand in the bathroom with the door closed and her hands pressed against her eyes.

Lily, meanwhile, was a small efficient machine. She had claimed the bedroom at the top of the stairs—the one that had been Sarah's, with the sloped ceiling and the window that looked out over the backyard—and she was unpacking her own things there, her books and her stuffed animals and the box of rocks she had collected from every place they had ever lived. She had a system. She had always had a system. Sarah could hear her up there, moving around, talking to herself in the low voice she used when she was playing.

It was a good sound. It was the sound of a house becoming a home.

By noon, Sarah had the kitchen mostly finished and the living room half done and the dining table buried under a landslide of empty boxes. She stood in the doorway between the kitchen and the hall and felt the day stretching out in front of her, and she thought: *lunch.*

"Lily!" she called up the stairs. "Lunch! Sandwiches!"

There was no answer. The sound of moving around had stopped.

"Lily?"

Nothing. Sarah went to the bottom of the stairs and looked up. The door to Lily's room was open, and through it she could see the corner of the bed, the new quilt Sarah had bought her at the store in town, the stuffed rabbit propped against the pillow. The room was empty.

"Lily, this isn't funny. Where are you?"

She checked the bathroom. She checked her mother's room, which was still full of boxes, and the spare room, which was full of more boxes, and the hall closet, and the downstairs bathroom. She checked twice. Her heart was starting to beat in a way she didn't like, and she was telling herself to calm down, that Lily was eight, that she couldn't have gone far, that she was probably playing hide-and-seek.

But Lily didn't play hide-and-seek. Lily had never liked it. Lily had once told Sarah, when she was six, that she didn't like hiding because when you were hiding you couldn't see what was coming.

Sarah went to the back door. It was open. Not wide open—just unlatched, a crack of an inch, the way it would be if someone had gone out and not quite pulled it shut. Sarah pushed it open and stepped out onto the back porch, and the cold air hit her face, and she looked out across the backyard.

The backyard was a long rectangle of brown grass, fenced on three sides. Her mother had kept a garden here once, roses along the fence and tomatoes in the far corner, and the beds were still there, gone to weeds. Beyond the fence, the field sloped down to the edge of the trees.

Lily was standing at the edge of the trees.

She was a small figure in a red sweater, and she was standing perfectly still, her back to Sarah, facing the forest. Her arms were at her sides. Her feet were in the tall grass. She was not moving at all.

Sarah felt her stomach drop. She was down the porch steps and across the yard before she had time to think about it, calling Lily's name, her voice sharp in the cold air. She climbed the fence—it was low, it had always been low, she had climbed it a thousand times as a girl—and she ran through the field, and the grass whipped at her legs, and she was saying Lily's name over and over, and Lily did not turn around.

She didn't turn around until Sarah grabbed her shoulder.

And then she turned, and she looked up at Sarah with her father's blue eyes, and she said, "Hi, Mama."

"Lily." Sarah crouched down in front of her, her hands on Lily's arms. "What are you doing? You can't just—you didn't tell me where you were going. You can't just wander off. Do you understand me?"

"I'm sorry," Lily said. She didn't sound sorry. She sounded calm, and distant, and a little puzzled, like Sarah was the one who had done something strange.

"You were standing at the edge of the woods. You know you're not supposed to go near the woods." Sarah heard her mother's voice in her own, and she didn't care. "You know that."

"I didn't go in," Lily said.

"That's not the point. You—" Sarah stopped. She was breathing hard, and her hands were shaking, and she made herself take a breath. "Lily. Look at me. Why were you standing there?"

Lily looked at her. Then she looked past her, at the trees, and her face did something that Sarah didn't understand. It was not fear. It was not curiosity. It was something quieter than either of those, something almost like recognition.

"I was listening," she said.

"Listening to what?"

"The song."

Sarah's skin went cold. "What song?"

Lily hummed a few notes. It was a simple melody, four or five notes, and it was familiar in a way that made Sarah's teeth ache—the way a word is familiar when you've forgotten what it means. It was not a song Sarah knew. It was not a song she had ever heard. But it sounded like something she had known once, a long time ago, in a place she couldn't remember.

"Where did you learn that?" Sarah said.

Lily shrugged. "I don't know," she said. "I just know it."

---

Sarah took her back to the house.

She made sandwiches. She made Lily sit at the kitchen table and eat, and she sat across from her and watched her, and she tried to make her voice light. "So," she said. "The song. Did you hear it on the radio? In the car?"

Lily shook her head. She had a bite of sandwich in her cheek, and she chewed and swallowed before she answered, which was a thing Sarah had taught her. "No," she said. "I heard it here."

"Here? In the house?"

"Outside." Lily gestured vaguely with her sandwich. "Out there."

"Out there where? At the edge of the woods?"

Lily nodded.

Sarah set down her own sandwich. She wasn't hungry anymore. "Lily," she said carefully, "did you hear someone singing? A person?"

"No," Lily said. "Just the song."

"What does that mean, bug? 'Just the song'?"

Lily thought about it. She had a way of thinking about things that was almost adult, a way of going still and looking at something Sarah couldn't see. "It's like when you're in a room and someone was just there," she said finally. "And you can tell they were there, even though they're gone. It's like that. The song was there."

Sarah sat with that for a moment. The refrigerator hummed. Outside the window, the field sloped down to the trees, and the trees stood still.

"Okay," Sarah said. "Okay. New rule. You don't go past the fence. Not without me. Not ever. Do you understand?"

"Yes, Mama."

"I mean it, Lily. Not even a little bit. Not even to the edge."

"Yes, Mama."

Sarah looked at her daughter, and her daughter looked back at her, and Sarah wanted to believe her. She wanted to believe that this was just a strange morning in a strange new house, that Lily was a kid with an imagination, that the song was something she had heard at school or on a video or in a dream. She wanted to believe that the cold feeling in her chest was just the cold feeling of a mother who had lost her daughter for five minutes in a new place.

But she had grown up in Greythorn. She had heard the stories. And she knew—she had always known, in the part of her that she kept closed and locked—that the stories were not just stories.

She just hadn't believed them.

She still didn't believe them. She told herself that. She told herself it as she washed the lunch dishes, as she put Lily down for a rest, as she went back to the boxes in the living room. She told herself that she was a reasonable woman, a schoolteacher, a person who dealt in facts. She told herself that there was a logical explanation for everything.

But she kept looking out the window at the trees.

---

The afternoon passed slowly.

Sarah worked through the living room boxes, and the light through the windows shifted from white to gold to a thin gray, and the house settled around her with its old-house sounds, the creak of the stairs, the tick of the radiator. Lily came down from her rest and read on the couch, and Sarah let her, and the two of them were quiet together in a way that felt almost normal.

At four o'clock, there was a knock at the door.

Sarah answered it, and found a woman standing on the porch with a covered dish in her hands. She was in her seventies, maybe, with white hair pinned up and a coat that was too heavy for the weather, and she had the look of someone who had been standing there for a moment before she knocked, deciding whether to.

"Mrs. Thorne," Sarah said, and the name came out of her before she had time to think about it. Of course it was Mrs. Thorne. Old Mrs. Thorne, who had lived down the road for as long as Sarah could remember, who had been old when Sarah was a girl, who had taught Sunday school at the church before the church had stopped having Sunday school.

"Sarah Grey," Mrs. Thorne said. Her voice was thin but steady. "I heard you'd come back. I brought you a casserole. It's not much. It's tuna."

"Thank you." Sarah took the dish. It was warm through the towel. "Do you want to come in?"

Mrs. Thorne looked past her, into the house. Her eyes were pale and sharp, and they moved over the hallway, the stairs, the door to the kitchen, the way a person counted the exits in a room.

"I shouldn't stay long," she said. "But I'll sit for a minute."

Sarah led her into the kitchen and put the kettle on. Mrs. Thorne sat at the table with her coat still on, her hands folded in front of her, and she looked around the kitchen like she was seeing it for the first time, though she must have been in it a hundred times when Sarah's mother was alive.

"I was sorry to hear about your mother," she said. "She was a good woman. She kept to herself, but she was good."

"Thank you," Sarah said. She got down two mugs. "It's been hard. But it's good to be back."

"Is it?"

Sarah turned. Mrs. Thorne was watching her, and her eyes were not the eyes of a woman whose mind was fading. They were sharp and clear and a little afraid.

"I don't know yet," Sarah said honestly. "It's strange. Being back. Everything's the same, but I'm not."

Mrs. Thorne nodded slowly. "That's the way of it," she said. "The town doesn't change. That's the whole trouble with the town. It doesn't change, and it doesn't let you change either." She paused. "Your girl. Lily. She's eight?"

"Yes."

"She'll be wanting to play outside. Kids do." Mrs. Thorne's hands tightened on the edge of the table. "You'll want to keep her close."

Sarah felt the cold again, the same cold she had felt in the field. "I know about the woods," she said. "I grew up here. I know the stories."

Mrs. Thorne looked at her for a long moment. Then she said, quietly, "The stories aren't stories."

The kettle began to whistle. Sarah took it off the heat and poured the water, and her hands were steady, and she was proud of that. "I don't believe in that," she said. "I'm sorry. I know people around here do. But I don't."

"No," Mrs. Thorne said. "You wouldn't. You're your mother's daughter." She said it like it was a sad thing. "Your mother didn't believe either. Not until the end."

Sarah set the mug down in front of her. "What happened at the end?"

Mrs. Thorne didn't answer. She looked down at her tea, and her hands were shaking, and she was suddenly very old. "I shouldn't have come," she said. "I'm sorry. I shouldn't have come. I just wanted to see you. To see the girl." She looked up. "Where is she?"

"She's in the living room. Reading."

"Keep her close," Mrs. Thorne said again. She stood up, and she didn't touch her tea. "Keep her close, Sarah. And if she starts to sing—" She stopped.

"If she starts to sing what?"

Mrs. Thorne looked at her. Her eyes were wet. "Don't let her finish the song," she said. "That's all. Don't let her finish the song."

She was out the door before Sarah could say anything else, her heavy coat disappearing down the walk, and Sarah stood in the kitchen doorway and watched her go, and the cold feeling in her chest had spread to her arms and her legs and her hands.

---

That night, after Lily was in bed, Sarah sat at the kitchen table with a glass of wine and her mother's address book.

She didn't know why she had gotten it out. She had been unpacking the last of the kitchen boxes, and there it was, at the bottom, a little leather book with gold letters on the cover that had worn away. Inside, her mother's handwriting, the same careful cursive, names and numbers and addresses, some of them crossed out, some of them with little notes in the margins.

She turned the pages slowly. She wasn't looking for anything in particular. She was just looking at her mother's handwriting, the way it slanted, the way the ink was darker where she had pressed hard. It was a way of being with her, a way of keeping her close.

And then she found the page.

It was near the back, past the plumbers and the electricians and the cousins she never saw. It was a page of names she didn't recognize, written in a different hand—not her mother's careful cursive but a cramped, angular script, the ink faded to brown. There were a dozen names, and next to each one a date, and next to some of the dates a single word.

*Taken.*

Sarah turned the page. More names. More dates. The dates went back—she turned back—and back—and back, into years she didn't recognize, into a century she didn't know. The earliest date was 1847.

She closed the book.

She sat there for a long time, and the wine went warm in her glass, and the house was silent around her. Then she got up and went to the window over the sink and looked out at the backyard.

The moon was up. It was nearly full, and it laid a pale light over the field, and the field went down to the edge of the trees, and the trees stood there in the moonlight, black and still.

And at the edge of the trees, where the field met the forest, there was a shape.

Sarah's breath caught. She stood perfectly still, her hands on the edge of the sink, and she looked at the shape, and the shape was small, and it was the size of a child.

It was Lily.

Sarah was out the back door before she had time to think. She didn't call out—some part of her was afraid to call out, afraid of what her voice would do in the silence—and she ran across the yard in her bare feet, and the grass was cold and wet, and she climbed the fence and ran through the field.

Lily was standing at the edge of the trees. She was facing the forest. Her arms were at her sides, and her feet were in the tall grass, and she was perfectly still.

"Lily," Sarah said. Her voice came out a whisper. "Lily, what are you doing?"

Lily didn't turn. She was humming. The same four notes, over and over, soft and low, and Sarah grabbed her shoulder and spun her around.

Lily's eyes were open. They were her father's blue, and they were looking at Sarah, and they were not seeing her. They were seeing something else, something past her, something in the trees.

"Lily." Sarah shook her, gently at first, then harder. "Lily. Lily, wake up."

Lily blinked. Her eyes focused. She looked at Sarah, and her face crumpled, and she started to cry.

"Mama," she said. "Mama, I was dreaming."

"You were sleepwalking," Sarah said. She pulled her close, and Lily's small body was cold through her pajamas. "You were sleepwalking. You were standing at the edge of the woods."

"I was dreaming," Lily said again. "I was dreaming about the song. It was so pretty, Mama. It was so pretty, and I wanted to hear the end of it."

Sarah held her. She held her in the cold field, at the edge of the trees, and she looked over her daughter's head at the forest.

The forest looked back.

She couldn't have said what she saw. There was nothing to see—just trees, just dark trunks and darker spaces between them. But the trees were not still anymore. They were listening. She could feel it, the way you feel someone watching you from a window, the way you feel a room go quiet when you walk into it. The forest was aware of her. It was aware of Lily. It had been aware of them all day.

"Come on," Sarah said. Her voice was shaking. "Come on, bug. Let's go inside."

She carried Lily back across the field. She didn't run. She walked, and she kept her eyes on the house, and she did not look back at the trees.

But she felt them. All the way to the fence, all the way across the yard, all the way to the door. She felt them watching her go, and she felt something else too, something she couldn't name.

She felt them smile.

---

She put Lily back to bed. She sat with her until she fell asleep, and then she sat with her a while longer, watching the rise and fall of her chest, the way her hand curled on the pillow.

Then she went downstairs and she called the sheriff.

The phone rang four times before it picked up. "Coats."

"Sheriff? This is Sarah Grey. I'm—I just moved back. My mother was—"

"I know who you are." His voice was rough, tired. "What's the problem?"

Sarah stood in the kitchen with the phone against her ear and the address book on the table in front of her, and she didn't know how to say it. "My daughter," she said. "She's been—she's been wandering. Toward the woods. She's been standing at the edge of the trees. She says she hears a song."

There was a long silence on the other end of the line. She could hear the sheriff breathing.

"Sheriff?"

"I heard you." Another pause. "How far in did she go?"

"She didn't go in. She just stood at the edge."

"Did she say anything else? Anything about what she saw?"

"She said she was dreaming. She said she wanted to hear the end of the song."

The sheriff was quiet for a long time. Then he said, "Keep her inside after dark. Keep the doors locked. Don't let her near the trees."

"I know. I told her that."

"Tell her again." His voice was hard. "Tell her every night. And Miss Grey—"

"Yes?"

"Don't let her finish the song."

The line went dead.

Sarah stood there with the phone in her hand, and the kitchen was silent around her, and outside the window the moon was high and the field was pale and the trees were black.

She thought about the address book. She thought about the names, and the dates, and the word written next to some of them.

*Taken.*

She thought about her mother, who had not believed either. Not until the end.

And she thought about Lily, asleep upstairs, humming a song she had never learned, a song that was not finished.

She locked the back door. She checked the windows. She went upstairs and stood in the doorway of Lily's room and watched her daughter sleep, and she did not go to bed herself until the sky outside the window had begun to turn gray.

And all night, the forest stood at the edge of the field, and it was quiet, and it was waiting, and it did not move.

But it was there.