Sheriff Coats
The school was called Greythorn Elementary, though there was nothing elementary about the way it sat at the edge of town like a held breath. It was a long, low building of red brick and tall windows, built in 1928 according to the plaque by the door, and it had the particular smell of every school Sarah had ever been inside—floor wax and chalk dust and the faint, sweetish ghost of cafeteria food. She had walked through these doors herself, twenty-five years ago, with a lunchbox in her hand and a knot in her stomach. The knot was different now, but it was still there.
She had spent the morning in her classroom, unpacking. Room 6. Third grade. The same room where she had learned her multiplication tables, where she had once been sent to the hallway for talking during silent reading. The desks were new—blue plastic and metal, the kind that stacked—but the blackboard was the same slate slab, and someone had written *WELCOME BACK* on it in chalk, in careful, looping letters. Probably the principal. Probably a nice gesture. It made Sarah feel like a substitute teacher, like someone who might be asked to leave at any moment.
Lily was in Room 9, two doors down, with Mrs. Abernathy, who had taught Sarah's fourth-grade class and who was now sixty-two and had not changed in any way Sarah could detect except that her hair had gone from gray to white. Mrs. Abernathy had hugged Sarah at the door and said *your mother would be so proud*, which had been exactly the wrong thing to say, and Sarah had smiled and said thank you and had gone into her own classroom and closed the door and stood there for a moment with her hand on the knob, breathing.
She was arranging the books on the shelf—the old hardcovers with their cracked spines, the picture books with their torn pages, the dictionaries that smelled like mold—when she heard the footsteps in the hallway. Heavy footsteps. Boots. The kind of footsteps that didn't belong in an elementary school, that made her think of maintenance men and men who came to fix the furnace, and then the footsteps stopped in her doorway and she looked up.
He was standing there in a sheriff's uniform, hat in his hands, and he looked like he'd been carved out of something that had been left in the rain too long. Tall, but stooped, as if the top of him had given up on the idea of being tall. Gray stubble on a gray face. Eyes that were the pale blue of old ice, and tired—God, he was tired, tired in a way that had nothing to do with sleep. He held his hat against his chest with both hands, the way a man does when he's trying to look harmless, and he smiled, and the smile didn't reach his eyes.
"Miss Grey," he said. "Sarah Grey."
"Mrs. Grey," Sarah said. She had kept the *Mrs.* after the divorce, partly because it was easier than explaining, partly because it was the name she had chosen for herself and she saw no reason to give it back. "Can I help you?"
"I'm Sheriff Coats. Dan Coats." He stepped into the room, and his boots made a sound on the linoleum that seemed too loud, too deliberate. "I was a friend of your mother's. Went to church with her. She was a good woman."
"Thank you," Sarah said. She had heard this a dozen times in the three weeks since she'd come back. *Your mother was a good woman.* It had stopped meaning anything. "Was there something you needed?"
"Just wanted to introduce myself. Welcome you back." He looked around the classroom, at the desks, at the windows. The windows looked out onto the playground, and beyond the playground, the trees. "You're teaching third grade."
"That's right."
"Lily's in fourth."
"Yes."
"Mrs. Abernathy's class." He nodded. "Good teacher. Good woman. She's been here longer than the building, I think."
Sarah waited. She had learned, from years of dealing with administrators and ex-husbands and the various men who seemed to believe they had a right to her time, that silence was sometimes the best question. Coats shifted his weight. He put his hat on the desk, then picked it up again, as if he couldn't decide what to do with his hands.
"Miss Grey," he said. "I need to tell you something, and I need you to hear it the right way. This isn't me being nosy. This isn't me trying to tell you how to raise your daughter."
"I'm listening."
"Keep her out of the woods."
Sarah blinked. "I'm sorry?"
"The Hollow. The forest. You know where it is." He said it flatly, without inflection, the way you might say *the post office is on Main Street* or *the speed limit is twenty-five*. "Keep her out of there. Especially after dark. Especially alone."
Sarah looked at him for a moment. She had grown up here. She knew the stories. Every child in Greythorn knew the stories. The Hollow is deep. The Hollow is old. Don't go in after dark. Don't whistle in the woods. Don't follow the voices. The stories were the kind of thing you told at sleepovers, with a flashlight under your chin, and then you laughed and ate your popcorn and forgot about them. She had forgotten about them. She had spent twenty years in Burlington, and in twenty years she had not thought once about the Hollow, and now she was standing in her childhood classroom with a sheriff in front of her, and he was telling her to keep her daughter out of the woods.
"Sheriff," she said, "the playground backs up to the forest. There's a path. The children play there."
"Not after three-thirty they don't. Not anymore."
"What does that mean?"
"It means the recess monitor calls them back at three-fifteen now. It means the school board voted on it in August, and it wasn't unanimous, but it passed." He looked at the window again. The trees were very still out there. The morning had gone gray, the clouds low and heavy, and the trees were dark against the sky. "It means I'm not the only one who's worried."
Sarah set down the book she was holding. *The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe*, a battered paperback with a water stain on the cover. She had loved this book as a child. She had loved the idea of a door in the back of a wardrobe, a door to somewhere else. She wondered, briefly, what it said about her that she had grown up to distrust doors.
"I grew up here," she said. "I know the stories. I know people like to tell them."
"People like to tell them," Coats agreed. "But that's not what I'm doing."
"Then what are you doing?"
He was quiet for a long moment. The refrigerator in the teachers' lounge hummed through the wall. Somewhere down the hall, a child laughed—high and clear, the sound of it carrying through the cinderblock like a bell. Coats flinched. It was a small thing, a tightening around his eyes, but Sarah saw it.
"I'm doing my job," he said finally. "I'm keeping people safe. That's all."
"From what?"
"From the woods."
"Sheriff—"
"I know how it sounds." He cut her off, not unkindly. "I know you think I'm some old fool with a badge and a bottle. And maybe I am. But I've lived here my whole life, and I've seen things, and I'm telling you—I'm asking you—keep her out of the woods. After dark. Even before dark, if you can. It's not a place for children."
Sarah felt a flare of something hot in her chest. It was not fear. It was the thing that had been building in her for weeks, the thing that had started when the lawyer had called and had grown when she'd packed the car and had hardened when she'd walked into her mother's house and smelled the hand cream. It was the feeling of being managed. Of being told, by men, what was best for her and her daughter.
"I appreciate your concern," she said, and she heard her own voice go flat and polite, the voice she used with parents who complained about grades. "But Lily is my daughter, and I'll decide what's best for her. If you'll excuse me, I have a classroom to set up."
Coats looked at her. He didn't look angry. He looked, if anything, sad. He put his hat on his head, adjusted the brim, and nodded.
"All right," he said. "I've said my piece. But do me a favor—just one. If you hear anything. If she says anything. If she comes home with something that doesn't make sense. You call me. Day or night." He reached into his pocket and pulled out a card, a plain white card with his name and a phone number on it. He set it on the desk. "That's my cell. It's always on."
"I'll keep it in mind."
"That's all I ask."
He turned to go, and then he stopped in the doorway and looked back at her, and for a moment his face was open in a way that it hadn't been before, and Sarah saw something there—something raw and old, something that looked like grief, or guilt, or both.
"Your mother," he said. "She knew. She knew more than most. She was one of the ones who—" He stopped himself. Shook his head. "Never mind. I'm sorry for your loss. Truly."
And then he was gone, his boots echoing down the hallway, and Sarah stood alone in her classroom with the card on the desk and the trees in the window and a feeling in her chest that she couldn't name.
---
She didn't tell Lily about the conversation. She told herself it was because it was nonsense, because there was no reason to frighten a child with an old man's superstitions, because Lily had enough to worry about—a new school, a new house, a father who called on Sundays and sometimes forgot. But the truth was simpler and less flattering: she didn't tell Lily because she didn't want to think about it. She wanted to put the sheriff's warning in a box and close the lid and put the box on a shelf and forget about it. She had done this before, with other things. She was good at it.
The first week of school passed. Lily came home each afternoon with paint on her fingers and a new fact about Mrs. Abernathy's cat, a fat orange thing named Marmalade who slept in the classroom sink. She ate her dinner. She did her homework. She went to bed at eight-thirty and slept with the light on, and Sarah didn't ask why.
On Thursday, Lily brought home a drawing.
It was a forest scene—trees in brown and green crayon, their branches reaching up to a strip of blue sky. There was a path winding through the middle of it, and a house at the end of the path, and a small figure standing in front of the house. A girl. The girl had yellow hair, like Lily's, and a red dress, and she was holding hands with someone. Sarah looked closer. The someone was taller, and dark, and had no face. Just a smudge of black crayon where the face should have been.
"That's lovely, bug," Sarah said, keeping her voice light. "Who's the girl?"
"Me," Lily said. She was eating a string cheese, pulling it apart in long white threads. "That's our house. And that's the friend."
"What friend?"
"The one in the woods." Lily said it matter-of-factly, the way she might say *the one at the grocery store* or *the one in my class*. "She sings. I hear her sometimes. She wants me to come play."
Sarah's hands went cold. She set the drawing down on the kitchen table and looked at her daughter. Lily was eight years old. She had a smudge of cheese on her chin and a loose tooth that she kept wiggling with her tongue, and she was looking at Sarah with the mild, patient expression of a child who is waiting for an adult to catch up.
"Lily," Sarah said. "What do you mean, you hear her?"
"At night. When I'm in bed. She sings a song. It's not a real song, it's just—" Lily hummed a few notes, a simple, rising melody that Sarah didn't recognize. "Like that. She sings it and I can hear her through the window."
"The window's closed."
"I know. But I can still hear her." Lily shrugged, as if this were the least remarkable thing in the world. "She says her name is Anna."
Sarah's mouth was dry. She thought of the sheriff's card, still sitting on her desk in the classroom, and she thought of the way Coats had flinched at the sound of a child's laugh. She thought of the trees out the window, dark against a gray sky, and the path that led from the playground into the woods, and she thought: *this is how it starts.*
"Lily," she said carefully. "I don't want you to talk to anyone you don't know. Even if they're nice. Even if they sing. Okay?"
"Okay," Lily said. She didn't seem upset. She didn't seem anything. She took another bite of her string cheese and went back to her drawing, and Sarah stood in the kitchen with her heart pounding and her hands cold and the smell of her mother's hand cream in the air, and she thought: *I should call him. I should call him right now.*
She didn't call. She told herself it was because Lily was fine, because children had imaginary friends, because there was nothing to be afraid of in a drawing. She told herself it was because she wasn't the kind of woman who panicked over nothing. She told herself a lot of things. That night, she lay awake in her mother's bed and listened to the silence of the house, and the silence was not empty. It was the kind of silence that has a shape, a weight, a presence. It was the kind of silence that waits for you to fall asleep.
At some point, she must have drifted off, because she woke to the sound of Lily's voice in the hallway.
"—coming," Lily was saying. "I'm coming."
Sarah was out of bed before she was fully awake, her feet cold on the hardwood, her heart already racing. She found Lily in the hallway, standing in her pajamas, her hand on the front door.
"Lily!" Sarah grabbed her daughter's shoulder and pulled her back. "What are you doing?"
Lily blinked up at her. In the dim light from the bedroom, her eyes looked dark and flat, like still water. "She called me," she said. "She said it was time to play."
"Who? Who called you?"
"Anna." Lily yawned, and the yawn seemed to bring her back to herself. She looked around the hallway as if she had never seen it before. "Mommy? Why am I out of bed?"
"You were sleepwalking," Sarah said. Her voice was shaking. "You were—you were walking to the door. Come on. Let's get you back to bed."
She led Lily back to her room and tucked her in, and Lily fell asleep almost immediately, her face slack and peaceful on the pillow. Sarah sat on the edge of the bed and watched her breathe. The window was closed. The curtains were drawn. Outside, the trees were very dark and very still.
She didn't sleep again that night. She sat in the kitchen with a cup of coffee and the sheriff's card in her hand, and she turned the card over and over, and she didn't call. She didn't call because she didn't know what to say. She didn't call because she was afraid of what he would tell her. She didn't call because she was Sarah Grey, and she had spent her whole life being the reasonable one, the sensible one, the one who didn't believe in monsters.
By morning, the fear had faded to something manageable. Lily ate her cereal and complained about a boy in her class named Marcus who pulled hair. She drew another picture—a cat, this time, a fat orange thing that was clearly Marmalade. She seemed entirely herself. The night before felt like a dream.
But Sarah kept the card. She put it in her wallet, behind her driver's license, and she didn't throw it away.
---
The sheriff came back on Friday.
Sarah was in her classroom after school, grading papers, when she heard the boots in the hallway. She looked up as Coats appeared in the doorway, and this time he wasn't wearing his hat. His hair was thin and gray and standing up in tufts, and he looked like he hadn't slept either.
"Miss Grey," he said. "You didn't call."
"I didn't have anything to call about."
"Your daughter's teacher says she's been quiet in class. Quieter than usual. Mrs. Abernathy's been teaching for forty years, and she knows quiet." Coats stepped into the room and closed the door behind him. "She says Lily draws the same thing every day. A forest. A house. A girl."
Sarah set down her pen. "She's an artist. She likes to draw."
"She draws the same thing every day," Coats repeated. "And she hums. Mrs. Abernathy says she hums a song she doesn't recognize. A song that makes the other children go quiet."
Sarah's hands were cold again. She put them in her lap and looked at the sheriff, and she saw that he was not trying to frighten her. He was frightened himself. The fear was in the way he stood, in the way he kept glancing at the window, in the way his hands kept moving—touching his belt, his collar, his hair—as if he were checking to make sure he was still there.
"I heard her humming," Sarah said. "At home. She said it was a song from the woods."
Coats closed his eyes. For a moment, he looked like a man who had been carrying something heavy for a very long time and had just been told he would have to carry it a little longer.
"Miss Grey," he said. "I need to tell you about the pact."
"The pact."
"That's what we call it. That's what my grandmother called it. That's what your mother called it, I'd guess, though she never said the word to me." He pulled a chair out from one of the desks and sat down, heavily, as if his legs had given out. "There's a—there's a thing in the woods. I don't know what it is. I don't know if it's a thing at all. It's just—there. It's been there as long as anyone can remember. Longer. And it takes things."
"Takes things."
"Memories. Mostly. People who go in after dark come out with holes in their heads. They don't remember the walk. They don't remember what they saw. Sometimes they don't remember the week before. Sometimes they don't come out at all." He looked at her. "And sometimes they come out wrong. Different. Like something else is wearing them."
Sarah wanted to laugh. She wanted to say *this is ridiculous*, to stand up and walk out and go home and forget this conversation had ever happened. But she thought of Lily in the hallway, her hand on the door, her eyes flat and dark. She thought of the drawing, the faceless figure, the yellow-haired girl in the red dress.
*She says her name is Anna.*
"Why are you telling me this?" she asked.
"Because the pact is breaking." Coats leaned forward, his elbows on his knees. "It's been breaking for a while now. Twenty years, maybe. Since the old ones started dying. Your mother was one of the last. She knew the words. She knew the rituals. She kept the thing in the woods from getting too close, and she did it without anyone knowing, and now she's gone." He paused. "And the thing in the woods knows it."
Sarah thought of her mother. Her mother, who had hung lavender sachets in the closets and made applesauce in the fall. Her mother, who had read her bedtime stories and taught her to knit and never once mentioned a pact or a thing in the woods. Her mother, who had died in a hospital in Burlington with a smile on her face and a hand on Sarah's hand, and who had said, at the end, *I'm sorry, sweetheart. I'm so sorry.*
*I'm sorry.*
"Was she—" Sarah's voice cracked. "Was she part of this? Was she—"
"She was one of the ones who kept it bound. Her and Mrs. Thorne and a few others. They took turns. They made the offerings. They walked the line." Coats's voice was gentle. "She never told you because she didn't want you to know. She wanted you to have a normal life. She wanted you to leave."
"But I came back."
"Yes. You came back." He looked at her, and his eyes were very tired. "And the thing in the woods knows that too."
Sarah sat very still. She could hear the clock on the wall ticking. She could hear the wind in the trees outside. She could hear her own heart, beating hard and fast and scared.
"What do I do?" she asked.
Coats reached into his pocket and pulled out a small book. It was old, the leather cover cracked and faded, the pages yellow at the edges. He set it on the desk between them.
"This was your mother's," he said. "I found it in her house, after. I was going to give it to you sooner, but I didn't know how to explain. I still don't." He pushed it toward her. "It's got the history. The rituals. The names. She wrote it all down. I can't read most of it—it's in her handwriting, and her handwriting was never good—but you can. You're her daughter."
Sarah picked up the book. It was warm in her hand, as if it had been sitting in the sun, though the sun had not been out all day. She opened it to the first page. Her mother's handwriting, small and slanted, filled the page.
*For Sarah, if she ever needs it. If she ever comes back.*
"I don't believe in this," Sarah said. Her voice was steady. She was surprised by how steady it was. "I don't believe in monsters in the woods. I don't believe in pacts. I don't believe in any of this."
"I know," Coats said. "I didn't either. Not for a long time." He stood up and put his hands in his pockets. "But I believe in what I've seen. I believe in the people who've gone missing. I believe in the ones who came back wrong. And I believe in your mother, and she believed in this." He nodded at the book. "Read it. That's all I ask. Read it, and then decide what you believe."
He walked to the door and opened it, and then he stopped and looked back at her.
"One more thing," he said. "The girl. Anna. That's not a name I know. It's not one of the old names. It's not one of the ones from the book." He paused. "Which means it's new. Which means the thing in the woods is trying something it hasn't tried before. It's not just taking memories anymore. It's making friends."
He left. The door swung shut behind him, and Sarah sat alone in her classroom with her mother's book in her hands and the trees dark against the window, and she thought: *I should have stayed in Burlington.*
But she knew, even as she thought it, that it wouldn't have mattered. She knew, even then, that the thing in the woods had been waiting for her. That it had been waiting for Lily. That it had been waiting for a long, long time.
She opened the book and began to read.
---
That night, she sat at her mother's kitchen table with a cup of tea that went cold beside her, and she read. The handwriting was difficult—her mother's letters leaned and looped, and some words were crossed out and rewritten, and some pages were stained with something dark that might have been tea or might have been blood. But she read. She read about the first settlers, who had come to Greythorn in 1783 and found the forest already old, already knowing. She read about the winter of 1812, when three children had gone into the woods and only one had come out, and that one had never spoken again. She read about the pact, the agreement that the town had made with the thing in the woods: leave it alone, and it would leave them alone. Offer it what it needed, and it would not take what it wanted.
She read about the keepers—the women who had maintained the pact, generation after generation, who walked the line at the edge of the woods and spoke the words and made the offerings. Her mother's name was there, and her grandmother's name, and her great-grandmother's name, a long line of women stretching back into the dark.
And she read about the breaking.
*The thing in the woods is changing,* her mother had written, in a hand that was shakier than the rest. *It is no longer content with what we give it. It wants more. It has begun to reach into the town, into the houses, into the children. It has begun to sing.*
*I am old. I am tired. I have done what I can. But I am afraid that when I am gone, there will be no one left to keep the line. I am afraid that it will come for my granddaughter. I am afraid that it will wear my daughter's face.*
Sarah closed the book. Her hands were shaking. The tea had gone cold, and the house was very quiet, and outside the window the trees were very still.
She thought of her mother, in the hospital, at the end. *I'm sorry, sweetheart. I'm so sorry.* She had thought it was about the divorce, about the distance, about all the years Sarah had stayed away. Now she wondered.
She thought of Lily, asleep in her bed with the light on. She thought of the drawing, the faceless figure, the girl in the red dress. She thought of the humming, the song that Sarah didn't recognize but that somehow felt familiar, like something she had heard a long time ago and forgotten.
She thought: *I don't believe in this.*
And then she thought: *But I believe in my daughter.*
She picked up the phone and called the sheriff.
---
Coats arrived in twenty minutes. He was out of uniform now—jeans and a flannel shirt, his hair still standing up in tufts—and he looked like a different man, smaller and older and more tired. He sat at the kitchen table and Sarah poured him a cup of coffee, and he wrapped his hands around it and didn't drink.
"You read it," he said.
"I read it."
"And?"
Sarah sat down across from him. The book was on the table between them, open to a page near the end. "I don't understand all of it," she said. "The rituals. The words. Some of it's in a language I don't know. But I understand enough." She looked at him. "My mother was one of the keepers. She was supposed to protect the town. And she died, and now the thing in the woods is—"
"Reaching," Coats said. "Yes."
"And my daughter is—"
"Being called. Yes." He set down his coffee cup. "It's happened before. Children are its favorite. They're easier to reach. Their memories are softer. Their minds are more open." He paused. "And they're more willing to follow."
Sarah's throat was tight. "What do we do?"
"We keep her away from the woods. We keep her inside after dark. We don't let her go near the windows at night, and we don't let her listen to the singing." Coats's voice was steady. "And we find someone who can take up the line. Someone who knows the words. Someone who can make the pact hold again."
"Mrs. Thorne," Sarah said. "My mother mentioned her. She said she was one of the last."
"She is. But her mind is—" Coats hesitated. "She's ninety. She's not what she was. Some days she knows everything. Some days she doesn't know her own name." He looked at Sarah. "I went to see her last week. She told me to leave. She told me I was bringing the woods with me. She wouldn't let me in the door."
"Then what do we do?"
Coats was quiet for a long moment. The clock on the wall ticked. The refrigerator hummed. Outside, the wind moved through the trees, and the sound of it was almost like a voice, almost like a song.
"We do what we can," he said finally. "We watch. We wait. We keep her safe." He looked at Sarah, and his eyes were old and tired and kind. "And we hope your mother taught you enough."
Sarah looked at the book on the table. Her mother's handwriting, small and slanted, filling the pages. *For Sarah, if she ever needs it. If she ever comes back.*
She had come back. She had come back, and she had brought her daughter, and the thing in the woods had been waiting.
"I don't know if I can do this," she said. Her voice was barely a whisper. "I don't know if I believe in any of this."
"You don't have to believe," Coats said. "You just have to keep her safe. That's all any of us can do."
He stood up and put on his coat, and Sarah walked him to the door. The night was dark and cold, and the trees at the edge of the yard were very still, and somewhere in the distance, so faint that she almost missed it, Sarah heard a sound.
A song. A simple, rising melody. The same melody Lily had hummed.
She closed the door and locked it, and she went to Lily's room and sat on the edge of the bed and watched her daughter sleep. Lily's face was soft and peaceful. Her hair was spread out on the pillow like a halo. She was breathing slow and even, and her hands were curled into fists, the way they had been when she was a baby.
And on the nightstand, next to the lamp, there was a new drawing.
Sarah hadn't seen it before. It must have been done that evening, after dinner, before bed. It showed the forest, and the path, and the house. And standing in front of the house, holding hands, there were two figures. One was Lily, in her red dress. The other was taller, and dark, and this time it had a face.
It was Sarah's face.
Sarah sat very still. The drawing was crude, the way all of Lily's drawings were crude, but the face was unmistakable. The shape of the eyes. The curve of the mouth. The hair, drawn in long yellow strokes, the same yellow as Lily's hair.
*It has begun to reach into the town, into the houses, into the children. It has begun to sing.*
*I am afraid that it will wear my daughter's face.*
Sarah picked up the drawing and held it in her hands, and she looked at the faceless thing that was not faceless anymore, the thing that was wearing her face, and she thought: *No.*
*No, you don't. Not her. Not my daughter.*
She folded the drawing in half and then in half again, and she put it in her pocket, and she sat on the edge of Lily's bed until the sun came up. She didn't sleep. She didn't read. She just sat there, watching her daughter breathe, and listening to the silence, and waiting for the song to come again.
It didn't come that night. But Sarah knew it would. She knew it was only a matter of time.
And she knew, with a certainty that settled into her bones like cold water, that she was going to have to do something about it.