What the Town Knows
The footsteps stopped somewhere near her door, and Sarah stood very still with a picture book in her hand—*Blueberries for Sal*, the cover soft as felt from decades of children's hands—and waited for the knock. It didn't come. The footsteps resumed after a moment, heavier, moving away toward the main office, and she let out a breath she hadn't known she was holding and set the book on the shelf.
She worked through the rest of the morning. Room 6 had good light in the early hours, the sun coming in through the tall windows and lying in warm oblongs across the floor, and she found that if she kept her hands moving she could keep the rest of herself quiet. She sorted the desks into rows. She wrote her name on the blackboard in her own careful hand—*Miss Grey*—and then, after a moment's hesitation, wiped it out and wrote *Ms. Grey* instead, because she was not a girl anymore, because she had not been a girl in this room in a very long time, and there was no point pretending otherwise.
By eleven the sun had moved and the room had gone gray and cool, and she needed things for the first day: paper, pencils, a box of chalk, the small human things that made a classroom a classroom. Mrs. Abernathy had told her the general store was still there on Main Street, that it was run now by the Kessler boy—though he wasn't a boy anymore, Mrs. Abernathy had said, none of us are. The store, Sarah knew, was where the town kept itself. It was where you went when you needed a thing and also when you needed to know a thing, and she had not been inside it in twenty-five years.
She found Lily between classes and told her she'd be back in an hour. Lily was fine. Lily was better than fine; she had already found a friend, a thin dark-haired girl named June whose mother Sarah vaguely remembered as a girl in her own class, and the two of them were sitting on the floor outside Room 9 trading stickers with the fierce concentration of diplomats. Lily waved her off without looking up. Sarah walked out the front doors of Greythorn Elementary and into the flat gray afternoon.
The town had not changed, which was the strange thing. The town had changed not at all. Main Street still ran its one short mile from the white church on the hill down to the covered bridge and the river, and the buildings were the same buildings, clapboard and brick, with the same names painted over the doors in gold letters that had been touched up but never changed. The pharmacy. The diner with its chrome rail and red vinyl stools. The feed and seed. The library, small as a chapel, with its stone steps worn into shallow bowls by a hundred years of feet. It was the kind of town that held its shape the way a photograph holds a shape—perfectly, and without warmth.
The Kessler store was at the corner of Main and Elm, a long low building with a porch and a hand-painted sign out front that said *GREYTHORN GENERAL — EST. 1891 — PROVISIONS & HARDWARE*. Sarah climbed the porch steps and the boards sounded under her boots and she pushed open the door.
A bell rang above her head. The smell hit her first—coffee and sawdust and apples, and underneath it something older, kerosene and pipe smoke and the dry ghost of burlap—and she stood just inside the door for a moment and let it come back to her, the way a smell could undo a quarter century in a single breath. The store was narrow and deep, with high shelves on either side and a worn wooden floor, and it was almost empty at midday. Two old men sat on crates near the potbelly stove at the back, the stove unlit in the warm weather but the crates still there, still occupied, the way they had been when Sarah was a child and the same two men—or men who looked exactly like them, men who might have been their fathers—had sat there and talked about the weather and the price of feed and the things that had always been talked about in that place.
She moved down the aisle. Canned goods, flour, a rack of work gloves, a case of pocketknives. The store had everything and nothing, the way general stores did. She found the school supplies—notebooks and pencils and a box of chalk—and the box of chalk was the same brand her mother had bought, the same blue box, and she picked it up and held it and looked at it for a moment longer than she needed to.
She was reaching for a second box when she heard the men behind her.
"—told him, I told him plain. You don't go in there after dark. Not for a calf, not for a dog, not for nothing. And he says to me, he says, I'm not afraid of any woods." The voice was old and cracked, and it carried in the way voices carried in a store with a wooden floor and a high ceiling. "And I said, well, you ought to be. You ought to be afraid. Because it don't matter what you're afraid of. It matters what you *know*."
The other man said something Sarah couldn't catch, and the first man coughed and cleared his throat and spat—she heard the sound of it, the crackle in the stove, the dry spit—and said, "Fifty years. Fifty years I've lived at the edge of that thing and I've kept my side of the arrangement. Everybody did. Everybody kept their side. You stayed out of it and it stayed out of you, and that was the deal, that was what the old ones set down and what we all signed on to without a paper or a word, and now—"
"Now what," the second man said. "Now what, that's what I want to know. What's changed?"
"What's changed is that it's *hungry*," the first man said, and his voice was low now, so low Sarah had to lean toward the aisle's end to hear it. "What's changed is that it's been getting hungry for a while and we've been pretending not to notice. Fifty years, and I tell you, I've heard things in that wood at night that would make a man's hair go white, and I never said a word, because that's the arrangement, that's the deal. But the deal's got a crack in it now. The deal's got a crack in it and the crack's getting wider, and anyone who says different is a fool or a liar or both."
"Maybe it's the girl," the second man said.
The first man was quiet for a moment. Sarah stood very still with the box of chalk in her hand and her heart going hard and slow in her chest.
"The Grey girl," the first man said at last. "Her and the little one. Coming back here like there wasn't nothing waiting. Like the town didn't have a *memory*."
"Now, I don't know about that," the second man said. "Her mother was a good woman. Her mother kept her side."
"Her mother kept her side," the first man agreed. "And her mother's *gone*. And the girl's come back with a child of her own and no man, and I ask you, what did she think was going to happen? What did she think, coming back here? You don't come back. That's the first thing you learn. You don't come back."
The store had gone very quiet. The bell above the door had stopped its ringing long ago. The only sound was the faint creak of the wooden floor as someone moved behind the counter, and Sarah became aware, in a slow and creeping way, that the men had stopped talking not because they had finished but because they knew she was there. She could feel it, the attention of the room turned toward her, the two old men on their crates at the back and the cashier behind the counter and the store itself, all of it listening.
She made herself move. She walked to the end of the aisle and around the corner of the shelf and she saw them then, two men in work clothes and caps, sitting on crates with their hands around tin cups, and they looked at her and their faces did something complicated and quick—guilt, and something else, something older, and fear—and then the first man, the one who had been talking, the one with the cracked voice, doffed his cap and said, "Miss Grey. Ma'am. We didn't—we didn't know as you were in here."
"That's all right," Sarah said. Her voice came out steady. She was proud of that. "I was just getting supplies."
"We was just talking," the second man said. "Just old men talking. You know how it is."
"I do," Sarah said. "My mother used to say old men talk and young men listen and nobody learns anything."
The first man laughed, a dry, rattling sound. "Your mother," he said. "Your mother was a sharp one. Sharp as a tack, that woman." He put his cap back on and looked at her and his eyes were pale and watery and very old. "You're staying, then? You and the little one?"
"I've taken the third-grade position," Sarah said. "At the school."
"That's nice," the man said. "That's real nice." He looked at the other man and back at her. "You mind yourself, Miss Grey. Out at the edge of things. You mind yourself and mind the little one, and you don't—" He stopped. He looked down at his tin cup. "Well," he said. "I'll not say it. But you mind yourself."
"What do I mind myself against?" Sarah asked.
The two men looked at each other and did not answer.
She paid for the chalk and the paper and the pencils and the notebooks with a twenty-dollar bill and the cashier—a thin, tired-looking man of about her own age, whom she recognized, after a moment, as the Kessler boy, though he was not a boy and had not been one in years—gave her change and did not meet her eyes. He looked at her chin, her shoulder, the register, the paper bag, the window, anything. His hands were quick and careful and they got her change right the first time.
"Thank you," Sarah said.
"You're welcome," the cashier said, to the register.
She took the bag and walked out of the store and the bell rang above her head and the door swung shut behind her and she stood on the porch in the gray afternoon and felt the whole town around her, the shape of it, the held breath of it, and she understood that the men in the store had told her something and nothing, that they had told her more than they meant to and less than she needed, and that the town had a memory and the memory was not the kind that faded.
She walked down the porch steps and along Main Street with the bag against her hip, and she thought about the words the man had said. *The arrangement. The deal. The old ones set it down.* She had heard those words before, of course. She had heard them all her life, the way every child in Greythorn heard them, the way you heard the words of a song you didn't remember learning. *Leave the Hollow alone.* *Don't go in after dark.* *Don't answer if it calls you by name.* They were children's rules, the kind of rules that made a town feel small and old and safe, and she had always thought of them the way she thought of the rules about the covered bridge—not true, exactly, but not false either, the kind of thing that kept children from doing the things children ought not to do.
But the man in the store had not sounded like a man telling a children's story. He had sounded like a man who was afraid, and who was ashamed of being afraid, and who had been keeping something in for a very long time and could not keep it in any longer.
She passed the library and the church and the diner, and in the diner window she saw a woman looking out at her, a woman she thought at first was a stranger and then recognized, with a small cold shock, as herself—her own reflection in the glass, her own face under the gray sky. She stopped for a moment and looked at it. She looked older than she felt. She looked like her mother. And behind her reflection, in the glass, in the dark of the diner, there was something—a shape, a shadow, a movement—that she took at first for a customer at a table, and then for a coat on a hook, and then, when she turned her head to look directly at it, for nothing at all.
She walked on. The bag was heavy and the afternoon was gray and she was suddenly very tired, tired in a way that had nothing to do with the morning's work, tired in her bones, tired the way she had been tired in the first weeks after her mother's funeral, when she had come back to Greythorn to bury a woman and had found herself instead buried under the town, under the house, under the memory of a girl she had been and a life she had left.
At the end of Main Street, before the covered bridge, there was a bench. It was the same bench that had been there when she was a child, a green wooden bench with iron arms, and it faced the river and the bridge and, beyond them, the hill and the woods. Sarah sat down on it. She put the bag between her feet and she looked out at the woods and she tried to see them the way she had seen them as a girl—as just trees, as the place you were told not to go, as the dark at the edge of the world—and she could not.
The woods were very still. That was the thing she noticed, sitting there. It was the middle of the day and the woods were very still. There was no wind in them, no movement of branch or leaf, no birds. She had heard birds on the walk down from the school, she was almost sure of it, sparrows in the hedges along Elm Street, and now she could not hear a single one. The river made its small sound against the stones and the bridge made its small sound under the wind and the woods made no sound at all, and she sat and looked at them and felt the stillness of them the way you felt a person standing behind you in a dark room.
She thought about the man in the store. *Fifty years I've lived at the edge of that thing and I've kept my side of the arrangement.* She thought about what it meant to live at the edge of a thing for fifty years, to keep your side of an arrangement you had never signed, to raise a family and bury a wife and grow old in the shadow of a wood that was always there and never spoke. She thought about the things people knew and did not say, and about how a town could carry a knowledge the way a body carried a tumor—silently, in the dark, until it grew big enough to press on something vital.
And she thought about Lily. Lily in Room 9 with Mrs. Abernathy and June, trading stickers, laughing, fine. Lily was fine. But Lily had come back to Greythorn too, and the town had a memory, and the memory had teeth in it, and Sarah could not shake the feeling that she had brought her daughter into something she did not understand—that by coming back she had opened a door she could not close, and that whatever was on the other side of it had been waiting for a very long time.
She sat on the bench for a while. The gray afternoon deepened toward evening. The river went on making its sound and the woods went on making none. And then, because she had to, because she had a child to pick up and a classroom to finish and a life to make, she stood, and picked up her bag, and walked back up Main Street toward the school.
She passed the diner again and did not look in the window. She passed the library and the church and the pharmacy and the feed and seed. At the corner of Main and Elm she saw the two old men come out of the Kessler store with their tin cups and their caps, and they saw her and nodded to her, and she nodded back, and they went up the hill toward the houses at the edge of town, and she stood at the corner and watched them go.
The first man—the one who had been talking, the one with the cracked voice—stopped at the top of the hill and turned and looked back at her. He was small in the distance and his cap was a dark spot against the pale sky, and he looked at her for a long moment, and then he raised one hand and pointed, not at her, not at the town, but past her, past the bridge, past the river, out toward the woods.
And then he turned and went on, and the two old men went up over the hill and were gone.
Sarah stood at the corner for a moment. The bag was heavy in her hand. The sky was going the color of old pewter and the first lamps were coming on along Main Street, and somewhere a dog barked and then stopped barking, and the silence that came after it was very large.
She went back to the school and collected Lily, who was tired and happy and had traded stickers for a small plastic horse and had named it. She drove home along the river road with her daughter in the back seat talking about June and about the horse and about what she was going to do tomorrow, and she listened and said yes and that's nice and did not tell her what the man in the store had said, and did not tell her what she had felt sitting on the bench at the end of Main Street looking out at the still and silent woods.
At home she made supper and helped Lily with her bath and read to her from *Blueberries for Sal*, which she had brought home from the classroom because it had been her favorite and because she wanted, in some small way, to give her daughter a piece of the childhood she had had before the town had taught her to be afraid. Lily fell asleep with her hand under her cheek and her breathing slow and even, and Sarah sat on the edge of the bed and watched her for a long time, and then she stood and turned out the light and went to the window.
The woods were at the edge of the yard, beyond the garden, beyond the fence. They were black now, black against a black sky, and they were silent, and Sarah stood at the window with her arms crossed against the cold that had nothing to do with the season and looked out at them.
The trees did not move. The trees did not move at all.
And then, from somewhere in the blackness, so faint she might have imagined it, so faint she told herself she had imagined it, there came a sound. A small sound. A child's voice, singing, very far away and very high, a tune she almost knew and could not quite remember, the way you almost remember a dream.
She stood at the window and listened. The singing went on for a moment and then it stopped. The woods were silent.
Sarah did not move for a long time. Then she crossed the room and drew the curtain and went downstairs and sat in the dark of the kitchen with her hands around a cup of tea that went cold in her hands, and she did not go to bed for a while, and when she did she dreamed of a bench at the end of Main Street and a man with a cap and a cracked voice pointing out toward the woods, and in the dream the woods were full of children, all of them singing, all of them singing the same song, and she could not understand the words.