The Pact
The general store smelled the way she remembered, and that was the first strange thing, because she had not remembered it until she was inside it. Pine boards and cold ash from the stove in the corner, coffee ground fresh and old coffee burned, the faint sweetish ghost of penny candy that hadn't been sold in a generation but had soaked into the wood anyway. Kessler's had always smelled like this. It smelled like this still. The world could turn over twice and some things simply refused to.
Dale Kessler was behind the counter, and Mrs. Abernathy was right: he wasn't a boy anymore. He was maybe forty-five, wide through the shoulders, with his father's baldness coming on early and his mother's worried hands, which he dried on a rag as she came in. He looked at her the way people in Greythorn looked at her now—recognition arriving a half-second late, and behind it something careful, a door easing shut.
"Sarah Grey," he said. "As I live and breathe."
"Dale." She smiled, and it was not hard. He had been two years behind her in school, a quiet kid who stocked shelves after class. "It's good to see you."
"You too. You too." He came around the counter and shook her hand, then seemed uncertain what to do with his own. "Terrible about your mother. Truly. She was in here every Thursday, you know. Same list, every week. I could have set my watch by her."
"I didn't know that." She hadn't known a lot of things. That was the whole trouble with coming home after twenty-five years—the life had gone on without you, small and regular and real, and now you were a stranger reading the diary of someone you'd loved.
"She'd sit right there." He nodded at the chair by the stove, an old spindle-backed thing with a cushion worn flat. "Have a cup. Tell me what the weather was doing. She liked to know what the weather was doing."
Sarah bought her paper and pencils, a box of chalk, a package of construction paper in bright colors that would look cheerful on the bulletin board. Dale put it all in a paper sack and folded the top down and didn't charge her for the chalk, and she understood that this was the town's way of saying welcome home and also of saying we are watching to see what you will do.
"You had a girl come in with you," Dale said, not quite a question.
"Lily. She's eight."
"Eight." He said it slowly, turning the word over. "She'll be in the school, then."
"She's already made a friend. June somebody."
"June Trask." Dale's face did something complicated. "That's good. That's good." He wiped the counter with his rag, though the counter was clean. "Kids are resilient."
It was the sort of thing people said. It was the sort of thing she had said herself, in the city, to parents at conferences. But Dale said it the way you'd say *the fever has broken* or *the worst is behind us*, as if resilience were a thing that could be used up, and Sarah felt the question form in her mouth and did not ask it, because there were four other people in the store and all of them were listening without appearing to.
She said goodbye. Dale said come back soon. The bell over the door rang as she left, and she walked up Main Street with the sack against her hip and did not look at the Hollow, which was there at the end of every street in Greythorn, the way the sea is there at the end of every street in a coastal town, patient and enormous and impossible to ignore.
---
Mrs. Pettibone lived in the yellow house at the corner of Elm and Third, the one with the birdbath and the wind-chimes and the porch swing that Sarah had swung on as a child, though she could not have said whose house it had been then. She was ninety-one or ninety-two—Sarah was not certain, and neither, she suspected, was Mrs. Pettibone—and she had been Sarah's mother's neighbor for thirty years, which in the arithmetic of small towns made her family.
Sarah had not planned to stop. But she found herself on Elm Street with the sack of school supplies in her arms, and the yellow house was there, and Mrs. Pettibone was on the porch in a cardigan the color of weak tea, waving at her with a hand that shook.
"Sarah Grey," Mrs. Pettibone called, in a voice like dry leaves. "Come in out of the wind. I've got the kettle on. I've always got the kettle on. It's the only thing I've got left."
The house was warm and dim and crowded with things—doilies and figurines and framed photographs of people long dead, and the smell of lavender sachets and mothballs and something baking. Mrs. Pettibone settled her into a chair at the kitchen table and poured tea into cups so thin Sarah could see the light through them, and set out a plate of shortbread that she had made that morning, she said, though Sarah suspected she had made it that morning because she made it every morning, because a kitchen that has stopped making shortbread is a kitchen that has given up.
"You look like your mother," Mrs. Pettibone said, easing herself into the chair across from Sarah with a wince. "Around the eyes. She had the same look, like she was always about to say something and then thought better of it."
"I'm told I have her stubbornness."
"You have her worry." Mrs. Pettibone sipped her tea. "That's the Grey inheritance. The worry."
The kitchen clock ticked. Out the window, the maples along Elm Street were turning, orange and rust, and the wind moved through them with a sound like the sea. Sarah ate a piece of shortbread because it seemed to be expected of her. It was very good.
"I'm teaching at the school," she said. "Third grade. I start Monday."
"I heard." Mrs. Pettibone nodded slowly. "Word gets around. It always did. You'll have your hands full with that lot. The Trask girl, the Kessler twins, the little Corliss boy—" She stopped, and her mouth did something small and tight. "Well. Children are children."
"Mrs. Pettibone," Sarah said, because she had heard the pause, because she had been hearing pauses all morning, "what is everyone not telling me?"
The old woman looked at her for a long moment. Her eyes were the pale blue of old ice, and they were not confused at all. That was the thing about Mrs. Pettibone—you expected her to be vague, to drift, and she did drift, but underneath the drift was a current that ran straight and cold.
"You went to the store," Mrs. Pettibone said.
"I did."
"And Dale was polite and didn't charge you for the chalk."
"He didn't charge me for the chalk."
"That's the way it works." Mrs. Pettibone set down her cup. "That's the way it's always worked. We're polite and we don't charge for the chalk and we don't talk about it, and in return—" She stopped. The clock ticked. "In return, we're left alone."
"Left alone by whom?"
"By the Hollow."
Sarah waited. She had learned, in her years of teaching, that silence was a tool. You asked a question and then you shut up and let the other person fill the quiet, and usually they filled it with the truth.
Mrs. Pettibone filled it.
"My grandmother told me," she said. "Her grandmother told her. That's how old it is. Older, maybe. Nobody wrote it down. That's the point, you see—if you write it down, it becomes a thing that can be read, and if it can be read it can be changed, and if it can be changed—" She shook her head. "It's a story, that's all. But it's a story we've kept."
"Tell me."
And Mrs. Pettibone told her.
---
"There was a winter," Mrs. Pettibone said, "when the town nearly died. Not this town—the town before this town, the one that was here and then wasn't. My grandmother's grandmother remembered it, or said she did. There were forty families then, and it was a bad year, a killing year, the kind that comes once in a century. The river froze and the wells froze and the game went away and the children—" She paused, and her old hands found each other on the table and held on. "The children got sick. One after another, like candles going out. And the men went into the woods to hunt, because there was nothing else to do, and some of them came back and some of them didn't, and the ones who came back were not—" She stopped again.
"Not what?"
"Not themselves." Mrs. Pettibone's voice had gone very quiet. "They came back and they sat by the fire and they didn't speak, and when their wives spoke to them they looked up slow, like they'd forgotten the language. And one of them—the story says—one of them sat with his own daughter on his knee and did not know her name."
The kitchen was warm but Sarah felt cold. It was a good story, she thought. It was a very good story, the kind that had been told and retold until every word was worn smooth, and she could see how it had kept a town alive through a bad winter and a worse one—how it had given the cold and the hunger and the dying children a shape and a name and a reason.
"The elders went into the Hollow," Mrs. Pettibone said. "The ones who were left. They went in at dusk, all together, and they knelt down in the middle of it—there's a place in the middle, they said, a place where the trees are older than the trees—and they made a bargain. They said: we will leave you alone. We will not come into the woods after dark. We will not cut your trees or hunt your game. We will keep to the town and you keep to the forest, and we will not speak of you except to remember. And in return—"
She stopped.
"In return," Sarah said.
"In return, the Hollow would leave us alone. The sick children would get well. The men would remember their daughters' names. The winter would end." Mrs. Pettibone picked up her tea and found it cold and set it down again. "And it did end. That's the thing. The winter ended and the children got well and the men—most of the men—came back to themselves. So the bargain held. It held for a hundred and fifty years. We kept to the town and it kept to the forest, and we were left alone."
"And now?"
Mrs. Pettibone looked out the window at the maples, at the wind moving through them. "Now there's a road going in," she said. "Now there's a boy who went in after dark on a dare and came out with no memory of the night before. Now there's a girl who heard her dead grandmother singing in the trees and told her mother, and her mother told her to hush." She looked back at Sarah. "Now there's a schoolteacher who doesn't believe in old stories, and her daughter is eight years old."
Sarah set down her cup. It made a small click against the saucer, and in the quiet of the kitchen it sounded like a door closing.
"Mrs. Pettibone," she said carefully, "I'm a teacher. I believe in things I can see. I believe in weather and bacteria and the fact that children get sick and then they get well, and I believe that a bad winter is a bad winter and a good story is a good story, and I don't think—" She stopped, because the old woman was smiling, and the smile was not unkind.
"No," Mrs. Pettibone said. "Your mother didn't believe either. Not at first. She'd come over for tea and she'd say, *Mrs. Pettibone, you don't really believe all that,* and I'd say, *It doesn't matter what I believe, dear. It believes in me.*" She laughed, a dry sound, like pages turning. "She came around. They all come around, in the end. That's the trouble with this town. It doesn't give you a choice."
"What does that mean?"
"It means the pact is breaking." Mrs. Pettibone said it plainly, without drama, the way you'd say *the roof needs fixing* or *the apples are early this year*. "It's been breaking for a while. A year, maybe two. The woods have been—" She searched for the word. "Restless. People have been forgetting things. Small things, at first. Where they put their keys. What they came into the room for. And then bigger things." She looked at Sarah. "Do you know what the Hollow takes, Sarah? When it takes?"
"No."
"Memories." The old woman's voice was soft. "Not your things. Not your life, not most of the time. Your memories. That's what it eats. That's what it wears. It puts them on like—" She gestured with her shaking hand, a small, helpless gesture. "Like a coat. And it walks around in them. And sometimes, when it's wearing someone's memories, it calls out to the people who love them. In their voice. It calls, and the people come, because how could they not? How could you not go, if you heard your child calling from the trees?"
Sarah's hands were cold. She put them around her teacup, but the tea had gone cold too.
"That's a very effective story," she said, and her voice was steady, and she was proud of it. "It explains everything and nothing. It explains why people don't go into the woods, and it explains why they forget things, and it explains why they're afraid, and it gives them a reason to be afraid that isn't just—" She stopped.
"Just what?"
"Just that it's dark and the woods are big and we're small." Sarah shook her head. "Mrs. Pettibone, I've lived in cities. I've lived in places where you don't know your neighbor's name and nobody tells you stories about the forest because there isn't any forest. And people were just as afraid there. They were afraid of traffic and crime and strangers and the news. They were afraid of everything. And it wasn't because of a pact. It was because—" She stopped again.
"Because people are afraid," Mrs. Pettibone said. "Yes. I know. I've been afraid my whole life, Sarah. I've been afraid of the Hollow since I was a girl, and I've kept the rules, and I've been left alone. And I've watched other people not keep the rules, and I've watched what happened to them." She leaned forward. "You want to know what happened to the Corliss boy?"
Sarah did not want to know. But she was already nodding.
"Three years ago," Mrs. Pettibone said. "He was eleven. He went into the Hollow on a dare, after dark, with two other boys. The other two came back before midnight, crying, saying they'd heard something and run. The Corliss boy came back the next morning." She paused. "He was standing in his own kitchen when his mother came down. Standing there in his muddy boots. And his mother said, *Where have you been, I've been worried sick,* and he looked at her and said, *Who are you?*"
"Amnesia," Sarah said. "It happens. Head trauma, stress, cold—"
"He didn't remember her. He didn't remember his own name. He didn't remember the house or the town or the dog he'd had since he was five. He remembered—" Mrs. Pettibone's voice caught. "He remembered a song. That's all. A song his grandmother used to sing him, when he was small. He hummed it, over and over, for a week. And then one day he stopped humming it, and he looked at his mother, and he said, *Mama, why are you crying?*" She sat back. "He got better. Most of him. He's nine now, he's in your class, he'll be one of your third-graders. He's a good boy. He has trouble sleeping, and he doesn't like the dark, and he doesn't remember a single thing from the first eleven years of his life, but he's a good boy."
The clock ticked. The wind moved in the maples.
"That's a sad story," Sarah said. "But it's not—"
"It's not proof." Mrs. Pettibone nodded. "No. It's not. I don't have proof. Nobody does. That's the whole point of a pact, Sarah. You don't get proof. You get a story you keep, and you keep to your side of it, and you hope." She reached across the table and put her hand on Sarah's, and her hand was light as a bird's bones. "Keep to the town, dear. Keep your girl close. Don't go into the woods after dark, and don't let her go, and don't ask too many questions. That's the pact. That's all it's ever been."
Sarah looked at the old woman's hand on hers and felt something turn over in her chest, something that was not quite fear and not quite pity. She thought of Lily on the floor outside Room 9, trading stickers with June Trask. She thought of the footsteps in the hall that morning, stopping outside her door and then moving away.
"I'll keep her close," she said. It was the only thing she could say that was true.
---
She walked back to the school with the sack of supplies against her hip and the taste of shortbread in her mouth. The wind had picked up and the leaves were coming down in earnest now, red and gold, rattling along the sidewalk like something alive. She did not believe in pacts. She believed in isolation and inbreeding and the stories people told to make the dark less dark. She believed that a town that had been poor and cut off for two hundred years would have stories, and that the stories would be strange, and that the strangeness would feed on itself.
But she could not stop thinking about the Corliss boy. A boy who had gone into the woods and come out without his memories. That was a thing that happened. It happened with head injuries, with hypothermia, with trauma. It happened. She had read about it.
She had never heard of a boy who came out humming a song he didn't know he knew.
---
The school was quiet when she got back, the way schools are quiet in the middle of the day when the children are in their classrooms and the hallways are empty and the whole building seems to be holding its breath. She stopped at the office to drop off her receipts with Mrs. Abernathy, who was on the phone and waved her through, and then she walked down the corridor to Room 6.
The door was closed. She had left it open.
She stood in the hallway with her hand on the knob and looked at the door, at the small square window in it, at the light coming through the window in a way that was wrong. The light was green. The light in Room 6, which had tall windows facing south and east, should have been white, or gold, or gray. It should not have been green.
She opened the door.
The room was empty. The desks were in their rows. The chalkboard said *Ms. Grey* in her own careful hand. The construction paper was stacked on the desk where she had left it, and the paper sack was beside it, and the chalk was in the drawer. Everything was exactly as she had left it.
But the light was green, and the room smelled of pine.
She stood in the doorway and breathed it in—that cold, resiny smell, like a Christmas tree, like the inside of a forest—and she looked at the windows, which were closed, and at the floor, which was clean, and at the ceiling, which was whole. There was no reason for the room to smell of pine. There were no pine trees on the school grounds. There was a spruce on the front lawn, a big blue spruce that the town decorated at Christmas, but spruce did not smell like this. This was the smell of deep woods, of duff and needles and old, old wood, and it was in her classroom, and it was getting stronger.
She walked to the windows. She put her hand on the glass. It was cold, colder than it should have been for October, and she looked out at the playground, at the swing set and the blacktop and the blue spruce, and beyond that at the line of trees that marked the edge of the Hollow, and the trees were still. The wind was blowing hard enough to move the swing set, to send the leaves skittering across the blacktop, but the trees were still. Not a branch moved. Not a leaf turned. They stood there in a row like something waiting.
And then, from the trees, she heard a child singing.
It was faint, so faint she might have imagined it, a thin thread of sound on the wind. A girl's voice, high and clear, singing a song Sarah did not know:
*Bye, baby bunting,*
*Daddy's gone a-hunting,*
*Gone to get a rabbit skin*
*To wrap the baby bunting in.*
Sarah's hand was flat against the cold glass. The song went on, verse after verse, the same three lines over and over, and it was a song she had never taught Lily, a song she had not heard since she was a child herself, and it was coming from the trees.
She looked at the trees. She looked for a figure, a shape, a flash of color. There was nothing. Only the still dark line of them, and the voice, and the green light in the room, and the smell of pine.
Then the door opened behind her and Mrs. Abernathy said, "Sarah? The copier's jammed again, would you—" and Sarah turned, and the light was white, ordinary October light, and the smell of pine was gone.
---
She found Lily in the gymnasium, sitting on the bleachers with June Trask and three other girls, playing a complicated game with a cup and a ball that seemed to have no rules and no end. Lily saw her and waved, and her face was whole and happy and entirely eight years old, and Sarah felt something in her chest unclench.
"Time to go, bug."
"Five more minutes."
"Two more minutes."
"Three."
"Three." Sarah sat down on the bleacher below her and watched the girls play, and the gym was warm and smelled of floor wax and sneakers and the particular dusty smell of a school, and there was no pine in it at all.
June Trask was a serious child with her mother's dark eyebrows and a way of looking at you straight on that made Sarah feel she was being evaluated. She was good for Lily, Sarah thought. She was steady.
"Ms. Grey," June said, without looking up from her cup and ball, "is it true you saw the Hollow?"
The gym went quiet. The other girls stopped playing. Lily looked at her mother with interest.
"I don't know what you mean, June."
"Everyone says you went away and came back," June said. "And everyone says your mother died and you came back to live in her house. And everyone says you don't believe in the pact." She said the word the way adults said it, with weight, with care. "Is it true?"
Sarah looked at the girl, at her serious dark eyes, and felt the whole town looking back at her through them.
"I believe in being kind to my neighbors," she said. "And I believe in getting home before dark. And I believe it's time for you girls to go find your coats."
June held her gaze for a moment longer, then nodded, satisfied, and stood up. "Okay," she said. "See you tomorrow, Lily."
"See you tomorrow."
They walked out through the empty halls, Sarah's hand on Lily's shoulder, and the halls were ordinary and warm and smelled of chalk and floor wax and the ghost of peanut butter sandwiches. The blue spruce stood on the front lawn, and the trees beyond the playground were moving now, bending and swaying in the wind, ordinary trees in an ordinary October.
Sarah did not look at them. She looked at her daughter instead, at Lily's bright hair and her small serious face and the sticker on her sleeve, and she kept her hand on Lily's shoulder all the way to the car.
---
That night, after Lily was asleep, Sarah sat at her mother's kitchen table with a cup of tea and the notebook she had bought for lesson plans, and she did not write lesson plans. She wrote down what she remembered of Mrs. Pettibone's story, in order, in her careful teacher's handwriting, because she believed in writing things down. She wrote the part about the winter and the sick children and the men who went into the woods and came back wrong. She wrote the part about the elders kneeling in the middle of the Hollow, where the trees were older than the trees. She wrote the part about what the Hollow took, and how it wore what it took, and how it called in the voices of the people you loved.
She wrote the words of the song. *Bye, baby bunting. Daddy's gone a-hunting.* She wrote them down and then she looked at them for a long time.
She had never taught Lily that song. She had never sung it. She did not know where she knew it from.
She closed the notebook and turned off the light and went upstairs, and in the dark of the hallway she stopped outside Lily's door and listened. Lily was breathing slow and deep, the way children breathe when they are truly asleep, and Sarah stood there in the dark and listened and was comforted.
Then, from the trees at the edge of the yard, so faint she might have imagined it, she heard a girl's voice singing.
*Bye, baby bunting.*
She did not move. She did not look out the window. She stood in the dark hallway with her hand on her daughter's door and she listened to the song come out of the trees, verse after verse, patient and sweet and perfectly in tune, and she thought: *There is a reasonable explanation.* She thought: *It's the wind. It's a neighbor's radio. It's my own ears, my own tired mind, filling the dark with what I expect to hear.*
She thought: *Mrs. Pettibone is an old woman with an old story, and stories are not true just because they are old.*
The song went on.
*Gone to get a rabbit skin*
*To wrap the baby bunting in.*
And then it stopped, not fading, not trailing off, but stopping, the way a singer stops when the song is done, and the silence that followed was the silence of the Hollow, that vast and listening silence, and Sarah stood in it for a long time before she went to her own room and closed the door.
She did not sleep well. She lay awake and listened to the house settle around her, the old boards ticking, the furnace coming on and going off, and somewhere in the small hours she got up and went to the window and looked out at the yard.
The trees were still. The moon was up. And in the frost on the lawn, in the silver light, there were footprints.
Small ones. A child's. They came out of the trees and crossed the lawn and stopped at the edge of the porch, at the foot of the steps, and they did not go back.
Sarah stood at the window and looked at them until the moon went behind a cloud and the yard was dark, and then she went back to bed and lay very still and did not wake Lily, and did not go down to look, and did not tell anyone, because what would she say? What could she possibly say?
The pact, Mrs. Pettibone had said, is breaking.
And in the morning the frost had melted and the footprints were gone, and Lily came down to breakfast humming a song Sarah had never taught her, a song about a baby bunting, and she could not remember where she had heard it.
"From the trees, Mama," she said, when Sarah asked. "The trees were singing it last night. Didn't you hear?"
Sarah looked at her daughter across the kitchen table, at her bright and honest face, and she thought of the pact, and the footprints, and the green light in Room 6, and the voice in the trees that knew a song she had never known she knew.
"I heard it," she said.
And she did not know, then, whether she was lying to her daughter or to herself.