← The Hollow

A Child's Drawing

Chapter 8 of 17 · 4976 words

The construction paper came in a roll, and Sarah had to weight the corners down with two mugs and a bag of flour to keep it from rolling itself back up like a living thing. She'd cleared the kitchen table—truly cleared it, not the way you cleared a table when you meant to clear it later—and set out the new box of chalk, the fat pencils with their erasers still pink and unblemished, a plastic sharpener shaped like a cat. Lily had been asking for a drawing station all week. Sarah had promised her one for days now, and the promise had sat in her chest like a swallowed stone, because she had made it the morning after the night she had heard the singing.

She had not told anyone about the singing. Not Dan Coats, who had looked at her across the hood of his cruiser with that flat careful gaze and said, *Don't go past the fence line after dark, Sarah, I mean it,* as though she were a child and not a woman who had raised a child alone in a city that had its own dangers, thank you very much. Not her mother's old friend Margaret at the post office, who had asked after Lily with a brightness that did not reach her eyes. Not even her own reflection, which she had begun to avoid in the black window over the sink after nine o'clock. The singing had been real. It had come from the tree line at the bottom of the yard, thin and high and sweet, a child's voice or something doing a very good impression of one, and it had sung a song her own mother had sung to her, a song she had not thought of in thirty years, a song about a lady dressed in green who went walking in the wood. She had stood at the window with her hand pressed flat against the cool glass and listened until it stopped, and then she had gone upstairs and checked on Lily, who was sleeping with her mouth open and her arm flung over the edge of the bed, and she had not slept at all.

So: the drawing station. A table cleared, paper weighted down, chalk laid out in a fan. A domestic act against the dark. It was the kind of thing her mother would have done.

"Can I do it now?" Lily was already in the chair, already reaching for the chalk, her small fingers dusty with the stuff before Sarah had even said yes. She was eight, and eight was a hungry age, hungry for paper and pencils and the next thing and the thing after that. She had her father's gray eyes—Sarah's own, really, but she had always thought of them as his, a small betrayal she had never confessed to anyone—and her hair was the pale brown that went gold in summer. She was wearing her school clothes still, the jumper with the frayed hem, and there was a smudge of something purple on her chin that Sarah chose not to investigate.

"Go ahead," Sarah said. "But not on the table. Use the paper."

"I *know*."

"And don't press too hard. The chalk breaks."

"I *know*, Mama."

Sarah poured herself a cup of coffee and sat down across from her daughter, and for a while there was only the small industrious noise of a child at work: chalk scraping, the tap of a color being traded for another, the soft huff of breath through Lily's nose when she concentrated. The kitchen was warm. The window over the sink had gone dark while they worked, the way October dark came now—early and total and a little too sudden, as though someone had thrown a switch. Sarah had put a lamp on the table. It made a yellow circle that did not quite reach the corners of the room. Outside, the wind moved through the bare branches of the maple by the porch, and the sound was dry and rattling and ordinary.

She should not have been afraid of ordinary things. That was the trouble. She had spent her whole adult life being a reasonable person, a person who taught third grade and paid her bills and did not believe in the things her mother had believed in, and now she was sitting in a warm kitchen listening to the wind and thinking about a song.

"Mama."

Sarah looked up. Lily had pushed the drawing to the middle of the table and was watching her with that steady, unblinking gaze that children have when they want you to see something and are waiting to find out what you'll do about it.

"What is it, sweetheart?"

"Look."

Sarah pulled the paper toward her. The chalk was new and the colors were bright, and Lily had used them all.

It was a forest. That was the first thing, and the first thing was fine—Lily drew forests the way other children drew houses and families and dogs, because she lived at the edge of one and because forests were what she saw out the window every day. But this forest was not the forest of a child's imagination, the friendly pines with their fluffy green tops and the smiling sun above. This forest was black. Lily had used the black chalk down almost to a stub and she had drawn the trees close together, so close their trunks touched, so close there was no space between them, and the branches overhead were tangled in a way that made Sarah's chest go tight, because they looked like they were holding hands. All of them. Every branch in the drawing reached out and touched another branch, and the canopy was a solid roof of black that no light could get through. The black chalk was smudged where Lily's hand had rested, and the smudge made it look like the trees were breathing.

In the middle of the forest, in a small clearing that was not quite a clearing—the black trunks leaned in around it like people looking down at something on the ground—there were two figures.

They were drawn simply, the way Lily drew all people, stick bodies and round heads. But she had taken care with these two. She had drawn them holding hands. And the figure on the right had a face: two dots for eyes, a curve for a smile, a scribble of yellow for hair.

The figure on the left had no face at all. The head was a blank oval of white paper, untouched by chalk, as though Lily had drawn the shape and then stopped, or as though she had drawn the shape and then erased something, though there was no eraser in the box and no smudge where a face should be. The faceless one was taller than the other. It had one hand reaching out to hold the small figure's hand, and the other arm hung down at its side, and there was something about the way it stood—straight, patient, waiting—that made Sarah's scalp prickle.

"That's me," Lily said, pointing at the figure with the yellow hair. "And that's my friend."

Sarah's mouth was dry. She made herself smile. "That's a very good drawing, sweetheart. You got the trees so dark."

"They're dark," Lily agreed. "They're dark all the way up. You can't see the sky."

"No," Sarah said. "I guess you can't." She turned the paper a little, as though a different angle might reveal something she had missed. "Who's your friend?"

Lily shrugged. She had picked up the purple chalk and was drawing something at the corner of the page, a small careful shape that Sarah could not identify yet. "My friend," she said, as though that were the whole answer, as though there were only one friend in the world and everyone knew who it was.

"Does your friend have a name?"

Another shrug. "He doesn't say his name."

"He?"

"I think it's a he." Lily looked up, and her gray eyes were clear and untroubled. "He's tall. Taller than you. He waits for me at the edge of the trees."

Sarah's heart had begun to beat in a place she could feel, a hard pulse at the base of her throat. *At the edge of the trees.* The tree line was forty feet from the back porch. She had told Lily a hundred times not to go past the fence. She had told her the day they moved in, and every day since, and Lily was a good child, a child who listened, mostly.

"When do you see him?" Sarah asked. Her voice came out steady. She was proud of that.

"At recess," Lily said. "And sometimes at night. He comes to the window."

The purple chalk stopped moving. Lily looked at what she had drawn in the corner and seemed satisfied with it, and then she pushed the paper away and slid down from the chair and went to the refrigerator for a juice box, and the whole thing was over, the way things were over with children, casually, absolutely, leaving the adult sitting in the wreckage.

Sarah sat very still. She looked at the drawing. The faceless figure looked back at her, which was absurd, because it had no eyes. But the blank oval of its head was like a light in the dark, like a hole cut in the world, and she could not stop looking at it. After a moment she turned the paper over and set it aside, and she got up and went to the back door and checked the lock, which was already locked, and then she checked it again.

That night she lay awake. Lily had gone to bed at eight with her stuffed rabbit and her night-light and no fuss, and Sarah had read to her from *The Wind in the Willows* until her eyes closed, and then she had sat on the edge of the bed for a long time listening to her daughter breathe. The house made its small settling noises. The wind had died. The silence that came in its place was not the comfortable silence of a house at night; it was a listening silence, a held-breath silence, as though the whole world outside the walls had gone quiet to hear what she would do next.

She got up at eleven and went downstairs and poured a finger of the whiskey she had bought at Kessler's two days before, which she had told herself was for cooking. She drank it standing at the kitchen counter with the lights off. The moon was up, and the moonlight came through the window over the sink and laid a pale square on the floor, and she stood in the dark and looked out at the yard and the tree line beyond it, and she thought about the song. She thought about the words. *A lady dressed in green, a lady dressed in green, she walks the wood at midnight and she is never seen.* Her mother had sung it to her. Her mother had sung it the way you sang any nursery rhyme, lightly, without meaning, and Sarah had never once asked her where it came from, and now her mother was dead and the song was in the trees.

The whiskey burned going down. She put the glass in the sink and went back upstairs and lay down, and she did not sleep, and at some point in the small hours she heard it again: the singing, thin and far off, coming from the direction of the Hollow. It was not a child's voice. It was the memory of a child's voice, or a child's voice remembered by something that had never been a child, and it sang the lady-in-green song and then it stopped, and in the silence after it stopped she heard something else, very faint, very far, that might have been laughter and might have been the wind in the bare branches and might have been nothing at all.

In the morning she called the school.

She told herself she was being ridiculous. She told herself she was a reasonable woman, a schoolteacher, and that children said things, that children drew things, that an eight-year-old's imagination was a wide and lawless country and it was the job of adults to be unimpressed by the weather in it. She told herself all of this while the phone rang and while she waited for the secretary to fetch Mrs. Blanchard, and by the time the principal came on the line she had almost convinced herself.

"Mrs. Grey," Mrs. Blanchard said. "What can I do for you?"

"Sarah, please." She was standing at the kitchen window with her back to the table, where the drawing still lay face down. "I wanted to ask about Lily. About how she's settling in."

"She's a lovely child. No trouble at all. Quiet, but that's not unusual mid-year. She's made friends."

"Has she?" Sarah kept her voice light. "Anyone in particular?"

"She sits with the Coyle girl at lunch. And the little Wexler boy, sometimes, when he's in school." A pause. "He's been out a fair bit this fall. His mother keeps him home when he's poorly."

"When he's poorly," Sarah repeated.

"Nothing serious," Mrs. Blanchard said, in the voice of a woman who had said *nothing serious* before and meant it less each time. "But you know how it is. Autumn colds. And the Wexlers are—" She stopped. "They keep to themselves."

Sarah looked out the window. The morning was gray and low, and the Hollow stood at the bottom of the yard like a wall of shadow, and the crows that usually moved in it were not moving. There were no crows this morning. She had not seen a crow in days.

"Mrs. Blanchard," she said, "does Lily play near the trees at recess? The edge of the playground, the tree line?"

"She's not supposed to go past the fence. None of them are. We keep an eye."

"But has she?"

A silence. It was a small silence, no more than two seconds, but Sarah heard the shape of it. "I'll speak to her teacher," Mrs. Blanchard said. "If you're concerned."

"I'm not—" Sarah began, and then stopped, because she was, and because the woman on the other end of the line had heard it in her voice already. "Thank you," she said. "I'd appreciate that."

After she hung up she stood at the window for a long time. The Hollow did not move. That was the thing about it; it never moved, not in any way you could point to and say *there, it moved.* But when you looked away and looked back it was different. The trees were in different positions, or the light fell differently, or the shadows had rearranged themselves into a new pattern, and you could not prove any of it. She had read once that the eye only ever took in a small part of the world at any one moment, that the brain filled in the rest, that there was no such thing as continuous vision, only a series of still pictures the mind stitched together. She had liked that fact before. She had used it in class, when the third-graders asked about optical illusions. Now it felt like a warning.

She turned away from the window and picked up the drawing and looked at it again.

In the corner of the page, where Lily had been working with the purple chalk before she pushed the paper away, there was a small shape Sarah had not noticed before. It was not a forest and it was not a figure. It was a house, drawn simply, a square with a triangle roof and a door and two windows, and Sarah could see that Lily had taken care with it, because the door had a knob and the windows had curtains and there was smoke coming out of the chimney in a careful curl.

It was their house. She knew it was their house. The porch was on the wrong side and the chimney was too tall and the smoke was going the wrong way, but it was their house, and on the roof Lily had written, in letters that were still a little too large and a little too spaced out, the word *HOME.*

And there was a window in the drawing that was not lit. The other window had yellow chalk in it, a warm square of light, and the smoke came from the chimney in a cheerful curl, but the second window was black, black as the trees, black as though someone had gone over it and over it until the paper was shiny with chalk, and inside that black window there was a small white oval, unfilled, blank.

A face. A blank face in the window. Looking out.

Sarah's hand had begun to shake. She set the drawing down on the table and smoothed it flat, and she stood there with her palm pressed against the paper as though she could hold the thing still, hold it down, keep it from getting up and walking out of the room.

"Lily," she called. "Sweetheart. Come here a minute."

Lily came in from the living room, where she had been watching Saturday cartoons with the volume low. She was wearing her rabbit slippers and her hair was a nest on one side from sleeping. "What?"

"Come look at your drawing with me."

Lily came and stood at her elbow and looked. She did not seem troubled. She seemed, if anything, pleased that her mother was interested. She pointed at the house. "That's ours," she said. "That's the porch and that's my window and that's your window."

"What's in the window, sweetheart?"

Lily looked at the black window with the white oval in it, and for a moment her face was still, and then she shrugged. "That's just the dark," she said. "The dark has a face sometimes."

"The dark has a face."

"Uh-huh." Lily picked up a green chalk and began to color over the black trees, a bright careless green that obliterated them. "Can I have a snack? I'm hungry."

Sarah made her a snack. She made her a peanut butter sandwich and cut it into triangles and poured her a glass of milk, and she sat across from her daughter and watched her eat, and she did not say anything else about the drawing, and she did not say anything else about the dark's face, and she did not say anything else about the friend at the edge of the trees. She waited until Lily had finished her sandwich and had gone back to her cartoons, and then she went into the front hall and put on her coat and her boots and she stood at the front door with her hand on the knob for a long moment before she opened it.

The morning was cold and raw. The sky was the color of pewter and the grass was gray with frost, and the Hollow stood at the end of the yard like something waiting to be noticed. Sarah walked down the lawn. She walked past the clothesline and past the old apple tree with its black crooked branches, and she stopped at the fence line, at the place where the grass gave way to the first of the trees, and she looked at the ground.

The ground was frozen. There was frost in the grass, and there were leaves, and there was a path.

It was a small path, a child's path, the kind made by small feet coming and going over and over until the grass wore away and the dirt showed through. It came from the back of the house and it went to the fence and it went through the fence, through a gap in the wire that Sarah had not noticed before, and it went on into the trees. It went into the Hollow.

Sarah stood at the gap and looked into the trees. The morning light did not go far in. Ten feet, fifteen, and then the shadows took it, and the shadows were not the shadows of a gray October morning but something older and darker, a dark that had been there a long time and meant to stay.

She should not have gone in. She knew she should not have gone in. Dan Coats had told her, and her mother had told her, and the whole town had told her in a hundred small ways that did not add up to a sentence but added up to a warning all the same. But she was a mother, and there was a path, and her daughter's small feet had worn it into the dirt.

She went three steps in. That was all. Three steps, and the light changed, and the silence changed, and she stood among the trees and listened.

There were no birds. There were no insects. There was no wind. There was nothing but the sound of her own breathing and the sound of her own heart and, very far off, so far off she could not have sworn to it, the sound of a child singing.

*—lady dressed in green, a lady dressed in green—*

Sarah turned and walked back out of the trees. She walked quickly, and then she ran, and she did not stop until she was at the back door with her hand on the knob and her breath coming hard and white in the cold air. She went inside and locked the door behind her and stood in the kitchen with her back against it, and she looked at the table where the drawing lay, and she made herself walk over to it and pick it up and fold it in half and in half again and put it in the drawer under the silverware, where she would not have to see it, and then she sat down in the chair by the stove and put her face in her hands.

She did not cry. She was too frightened to cry. She sat there with her face in her hands and she thought about the way her mother had looked at her in those last weeks, the way her mother had said *you'll understand when you have a child of your own,* and she thought about the way Lily had said *the dark has a face sometimes* the way other children said *the sky is blue,* and she thought about the singing in the trees.

At noon she called Dan Coats.

He was not at the station. The dispatcher said he was out on a call and took a message, and Sarah gave her name and her number and hung up, and then she stood at the kitchen window and watched the Hollow and waited. At two o'clock the phone rang and it was not Dan, it was Margaret from the post office wanting to know if Sarah had received a parcel, and at three o'clock the phone rang again and it was Mrs. Blanchard from the school saying that she had spoken to Lily's teacher and that Lily had not, as far as anyone knew, been going past the fence at recess, and that she was sure Sarah had nothing to worry about, and Sarah said thank you and hung up and did not believe a word of it.

At four o'clock the light began to go. She turned on the lamps. She made Lily a supper of macaroni and cheese and she ate a little of it herself and she did not taste any of it. She gave Lily a bath and read her a story and put her to bed, and then she sat on the edge of the bed and said, "Lily. Sweetheart. You know you're not to go past the fence."

"I know."

"You promise me?"

"I promise." Lily's eyes were already closing. "Mama?"

"Yes, sweetheart."

"My friend says you're not to worry."

Sarah's hand, which had been stroking her daughter's hair, went still. "Your friend said that?"

"Uh-huh. He says it's all right. He says the wood is just the wood." Lily yawned enormously. "He says you used to know that."

Sarah sat there for a long time after Lily fell asleep. She sat in the dark with her hand on her daughter's shoulder and she listened to the house and she listened to the silence outside and she thought about the words *you used to know that,* and she thought about the way you forgot things, the way you forgot them so completely that you could not tell the difference between a thing you had forgotten and a thing that had never been.

She went downstairs. She poured herself a whiskey and did not drink it. She sat at the kitchen table with her hands wrapped around the glass and she looked at the drawer where the drawing was and she did not open it. Outside the window the moon was rising over the Hollow, and the trees stood black against it, and she watched them and they watched her and the night went on.

At midnight the phone rang.

She picked it up on the first ring. "Hello?"

"Sarah." It was Dan Coats, and his voice was the voice of a man who had been awake for a long time and had not been enjoying it. "I got your message. What's happened?"

"I need to talk to you." She kept her voice low. "Not on the phone. Can you come out here?"

A pause. She could hear something in the background on his end, a radio, maybe, or the wind. "Tomorrow," he said. "I'll come by in the morning."

"No. Tonight. Please. Dan—" She stopped, and started again. "Lily says she has a friend. At the edge of the trees. She drew a picture. There's a path through the fence, Dan. A path her feet made."

The silence on the other end of the line went on so long that she thought he had hung up.

"Dan?"

"I'm here." His voice was different now. It was the voice of a man who had heard something he did not want to hear and was deciding what to do about it. "Don't go outside," he said. "Don't let Lily out of your sight. Lock the doors and keep the lights on and don't answer if anyone knocks."

"Dan, what is it? What's out there?"

"Tomorrow," he said. "I'll be there at first light."

He hung up. Sarah stood in the kitchen with the phone in her hand and the dial tone buzzing in her ear, and then she set it down and went to the back door and checked the lock, and then she checked the windows, all of them, one by one, and drew the curtains across. She went upstairs and sat in the chair by Lily's bed and watched her daughter sleep. Lily slept with her mouth open and her arm flung over the edge of the bed and her rabbit tucked under her chin, and she looked small and warm and safe, and Sarah sat in the chair and watched her and did not sleep.

At some point in the small hours she got up and went to the window. The moon was high and the yard was silver with frost and the Hollow was a black wall at the end of everything. She stood at the window and looked at it and the Hollow looked back at her, and she thought about the way Lily had said *he waits for me at the edge of the trees,* and she thought about the way the branches in the drawing had held hands, and she thought about the faceless thing in the clearing with its patient arm reaching out.

She thought: *it knows her name. It knows mine. It says I used to know.*

And then, because she could not help it, because the night was long and the silence was long and she was very tired, she thought about the summer she was eight years old and the friend she had had then, the friend she had met at the edge of the trees, the friend whose face she could not remember now, and she stood at the window with her hand pressed flat against the cold glass and she tried to remember, and the not-remembering was like a hole in her that the cold came through.

In the morning she would call Dan Coats again and he would come, and there would be questions and answers and things said and things not said. In the morning she would take the drawing out of the drawer and look at it again and she would see something in it she had not seen before, some small detail that would make her understand that she had been wrong about everything, that the world was not the reasonable place she had believed in, that there were things in it that had been waiting a long time and were patient and did not forget.

But that was the morning. For now there was the night and the window and the Hollow, and the small warm weight of her daughter sleeping in the next room, and the song she could almost hear, the song about the lady dressed in green, and the silence after it, which was worse.

She went back to the chair. She sat down. She watched her daughter breathe.

And outside, in the dark, at the edge of the trees, something that had no face waited with its hand held out, as it had waited for a long time, as it would wait a little longer.