The Vanishing
The morning came up gray and close, the sky pressed low over Greythorn like a held breath. Sarah woke to the smell of wet leaves and the low murmur of the furnace, and for a moment—one clean, uncomplicated moment—she did not remember to be afraid.
Then she did. It came back the way it always did now, a cold weight settling behind her sternum. The singing. The window. The small, high voice that had known a song from her own childhood, a song she had not sung aloud in decades, a song her mother had hummed while she pinned sheets to the line. *She walks in green, she walks alone, she walks the wood till day is gone.* Sarah lay in the gray light and listened to the house. The house listened back. Somewhere below, a floorboard ticked as it cooled.
She got up.
Lily was already awake, sitting cross-legged on the floor of her room in her pajamas with the drawing station paper spread out around her like a fan of cards. She had drawn all night, apparently. Sarah stood in the doorway and looked at the pages. Trees. Trees and trees and trees, their branches reaching up like fingers, and in the corner of every page a small figure in a green dress, no bigger than a thumbnail, standing very still among the trunks.
"That's a lot of trees," Sarah said, and her voice came out steadier than she felt.
"I'm practicing," Lily said, not looking up. Her tongue was between her teeth. "The forest is hard to get right. It keeps changing."
"It's a drawing, sweetheart. It can't change."
Lily looked up at her then, and her eyes were clear and blue and entirely her father's, and she said, "It can if you're not looking."
Sarah made herself smile. She crouched down and gathered the pages into a stack, and her hands did not shake, because she was a woman who had raised a child alone in a city that had its own dangers and she was not going to be frightened by a drawing. "How about pancakes," she said. "And then we'll do the laundry together. You can hand me the pins."
"Okay," Lily said, and went back to her trees.
---
The laundry was a Saturday ritual now, one of the small domestic scaffolds Sarah had built to hold the days up. The washer was old and loud and walked itself an inch across the basement floor with every spin cycle, and the dryer took two hours to do what it should have done in forty minutes, so most of the wash went out on the line in the backyard, where the wind off the ridge could get at it. There was something good about the line. Something ordinary. Sheets snapping in the cold clean air, the smell of them when you brought them in, the way the light came through them like the world had been laundered too.
Sarah carried the basket out the back door and set it on the grass. The yard sloped gently down from the house to the tree line, a long green fall of grass gone to seed, and the line ran from a post near the porch to a post near the bottom of the slope, strung with four sagging wires. Beyond the second post the lawn gave up and the trees began—not the deep Hollow itself, not yet, but the ragged edge of it, the first rank of birch and hemlock that stood between the yard and the dark.
Lily came out behind her in her red rain boots and her yellow jacket, carrying the bag of clothespins in both arms like a treasure. She had drawn a tree on the back of her hand in green marker while Sarah wasn't looking. Sarah decided not to mention it.
"You pin the corners," Sarah said. "I'll do the middles. Don't let the sheets drag."
"I know," Lily said, with the immense dignity of the eight-year-old who has done this before. "I'm the pinner."
"You're the pinner."
The first sheet went up white and billowing, and Lily caught the corner and pinned it crooked, and Sarah reached over and straightened it, and the wind took the fabric and made it breathe. For a few minutes there was nothing in the world but the two of them and the wet cotton and the cold clean smell of the morning. Sarah found herself breathing easier. The line filled: two sheets, a load of towels, Lily's small shirts in their row of colors, Sarah's own things, the pillowcases. The basket emptied. The yard was a white and colored flutter, a domestic flag planting, a claim staked against the dark.
"Go get the second basket," Sarah said. "It's by the basement door. Don't run on the stairs."
Lily ran anyway, boots slapping the porch steps. Sarah heard the screen door bang. She stood in the yard with her hands on her hips and looked down the slope at the tree line, and the tree line looked back at her with the flat patience of something that had been there before the town and would be there after, and she made herself look away. She was not going to be frightened of trees. She was a schoolteacher. She taught eight-year-olds about photosynthesis and the water cycle. She knew what a forest was.
The second basket was heavier. Sheets again, and the heavy quilt from her mother's bed that she had finally washed because she could not bear to sleep under it anymore without it smelling of her mother, and now she could not bear to sleep under it at all, so it went on the line with the rest, a big faded patchwork thing that bellied out in the wind like a ship under sail. Lily came back out with the pins and they worked together, and Sarah told her a story about when she was a girl and her own mother had hung laundry in this same yard, and how once a whole flock of chickadees had landed on the line and sat there like a row of notes on a staff, and Lily laughed and said that was impossible, and Sarah said it was true anyway, and the morning was almost good.
Almost.
She noticed the quiet first. Not silence—there was still the wind, still the snap of fabric—but the birds had stopped. The chickadees and the jays and the crows that had been bickering in the birches all morning had gone still, all at once, the way a room goes still when someone new walks in. Sarah paused with a pillowcase in her hand and listened. The wind dropped. The sheets hung limp and then filled again. And in that little trough of quiet she heard, very faint and very far, the sound of children laughing.
She turned her head. The sound came from down the slope, from the tree line, from the direction of the Hollow. It was a bright sound, a game sound, the sound of hide-and-seek and tag and somebody's mother calling them in for lunch. It was the sound of children, plural, more than one, and it was coming from the trees.
"Lily," Sarah said. "Come here."
Lily was at the far end of the line, on her tiptoes, reaching up to pin the corner of the quilt. "I'm almost done," she said.
"Lily. Now."
The laughing stopped. The wind came back. Lily turned around with the last pin in her hand and her face open and unafraid, and Sarah felt the fear go through her like a wire, and then she felt ashamed of it, because there was nothing there. There was nothing there. It was a trick of the wind. It was the ridge playing echoes. It was a Saturday morning in a small town and her daughter was pinning a quilt to a line and the birds had simply gone quiet the way birds do.
"I need you to hold the basket," Sarah said, because she needed Lily beside her, needed her within arm's reach, and she was not going to say so. "The quilt's too heavy. I need two hands and a holder."
Lily came back up the slope with the empty basket and stood beside her, and Sarah pinned the heavy quilt herself with Lily holding the basket steady, and the morning went on. The quilt was the last of it. The line was full. The yard was a flutter of white and color and the wind was cold and clean and the birds had not come back, but the furnace was humming in the house and the coffee was still warm in the pot and Lily was standing right there, her small warm shoulder against Sarah's hip, and everything was fine.
"Go put the basket back," Sarah said. "I'm going to bring the first load in. The sheets are dry."
Lily took the basket and went up the porch steps. The screen door banged. Sarah stood at the line and unpinned the first sheet, and it came away in her arms soft and warm from the sun that wasn't quite there, and she buried her face in it for a moment, and the smell was soap and wind and the faint ghost of her mother's lavender, and her eyes stung and she did not cry, because she was done crying in this yard.
She carried the sheet up to the house and through the back door and down the hall to the living room, where she spread it over the arm of the sofa to fold. She went back for the second sheet. She folded. She went back for the towels. She folded. The work was good work, the kind that emptied the head, and she did it with the back door open so she could hear the wind in the line and the house settling and, somewhere in the yard, her daughter.
She was on the third trip, her arms full of Lily's small shirts, when she realized she had not heard Lily in a while.
Not long. Five minutes, maybe. The shirts were a quick load, and she had folded the towels slowly because she was tired, and Lily had been in the yard or on the porch or in the kitchen the whole time, and eight-year-olds were quiet sometimes, eight-year-olds played their own games in their own heads, there was nothing wrong with quiet. Sarah set the shirts down on the sofa. She went to the back door and looked out.
The yard was empty. The line was empty. The wind moved through the grass and turned the seed heads over and the light was gray and even and nothing moved in the yard but the grass.
"Lily," Sarah called. Her voice did not carry far. "Lily, come in."
Nothing. The house behind her was quiet in a way that had a shape to it, a listening quality, and Sarah turned and went through the downstairs calling her daughter's name, the kitchen, the dining room, the front hall, the stairs, and her voice got louder each time and her heart got louder with it, and the house gave her back nothing but its own settling. She went up the stairs two at a time. Lily's room. The bathroom. Her own room. The hall closet with the coats. She came back down and stood in the kitchen with her hand on the counter and made herself think.
Lily had come in with the basket. The screen door had banged. Sarah had heard it. After that—after that she had been folding, and the back door had been open, and Lily could have gone out again, could have gone around the front, could have gone to the porch, could have gone anywhere in the five minutes Sarah had spent with her face in a sheet.
The back door stood open. Sarah went out onto the porch and down the steps and stood in the yard, and the wind came up from the tree line and pushed at her, and she looked down the slope.
There were footprints in the wet grass.
Small footprints. The tread of red rain boots, the little circles and bars of them, coming down the porch steps and across the lawn, spaced at the length of a child's stride, and they went down the slope toward the tree line in a line as straight as a ruled sentence, and they did not wander, and they did not stop.
"Lily!" Sarah screamed. "Lily, where are you?"
The wind took her voice and carried it down the slope and into the trees, and the trees did not give it back. Sarah ran. She ran down the slope with the grass whipping at her ankles, and the footprints ran ahead of her, neat and small and red-heeled, and she followed them the way you follow a rope in the dark, and she was thinking, she was thinking with the cold clear part of her mind that stayed awake while the rest of her went to pieces, that Lily's boots were red and the prints were red and the prints were small and she could see them, she could see exactly where her daughter had gone, and that was a mercy, that was something, that was—
The footprints stopped.
Sarah stopped. She stood at the edge of the yard, at the place where the mown grass gave up and the wild grass began, and the footprints went three steps further and then stopped, and there were no prints in the wild grass, no prints in the mud, no prints in the leaf litter under the birches. The trail ended as though the child had been lifted. As though the child had been taken up. Sarah stood and stared at the last pair of prints, the two neat ovals pressed into the wet grass with the tread pattern clear and the heel deeper than the toe, as though Lily had been standing there, as though she had stopped, as though she had turned—and then nothing. Nothing but grass. Nothing but the wind.
The tree line was twenty feet away. The birches stood in their white rows, and behind them the hemlocks, and behind them the dark. It was not the deep Hollow yet. It was the edge, the ragged hem of it, and Sarah stood at the end of the footprints and looked into the trees and the trees looked back at her and were silent.
"Lily," she said, and her voice was small now. "Lily, please."
And from somewhere in the trees, not far, not far at all, a child's voice said, "Mama."
Sarah went into the woods.
She did not think about the fence line. She did not think about Dan Coats and his flat careful gaze and his *don't go past the fence line after dark, Sarah, I mean it.* It was not dark. It was morning, gray and close and cold, and her daughter was in the trees, and there was no decision to make, there was only the going. She pushed between the birches and the low branches whipped her face and she called Lily's name and the woods were silent, silent, that terrible listening silence, and the ground under her feet was soft with old leaves and she could not see any prints, she could not see any prints at all.
"Lily! Answer me!"
"Mama," the voice said again, and it was closer now, or it was farther, or it was the same distance and moving with her, and Sarah turned toward it and the trees turned too, the birches sliding past each other, and she could not have said which way she had come. The light was gray and even and sourceless and the trees stood in their rows and the silence was so complete that she could hear her own blood.
"Lily. Baby. Keep talking. Mama's coming."
But the voice did not answer. The silence came back down over the woods like a lid, and Sarah stood among the birches with her hands at her sides and her breath smoking in the cold, and she understood, in that moment, with a clarity that felt like falling, that she had been called. That the voice had said *Mama* the way a hook is baited. That she had walked into the trees the way her daughter's footprints had walked down the slope—straight, and without wandering, and without stopping.
She turned around. She turned around three times, slowly, and the birches looked the same in every direction, and the light was gray and even and sourceless, and she did not know which way was the yard. She could not see the house. She could not see the line. She could not see the slope. She had gone perhaps fifty feet into the trees and the world behind her had closed up like water.
*Don't panic,* she told herself. *The house is downhill. The slope goes down to the yard. Find the slope and follow it up.* But the ground was flat here, flat and soft with leaves, and there was no slope, and the birches stood and the hemlocks stood and the silence pressed in.
And then, from her left, from somewhere among the hemlocks, she heard the singing.
It was the same song. Thin and high and sweet, a child's voice or something doing a very good impression of one, and it sang the words her mother had sung, the old song, the one about the lady dressed in green:
*She walks in green, she walks alone,*
*she walks the wood till day is gone,*
*and if you follow where she's been,*
*you'll walk with her and not be seen.*
Sarah stood still. The song came from the left and it was close, and it was not Lily's voice, it was not Lily's voice at all, it was too sweet and too even and it did not breathe, and Sarah did not turn toward it. She turned away from it. She turned her back on the singing and she walked, and she kept her eyes on the ground, and she looked for the prints, she looked for any sign, and the singing followed her, patient and sweet and slightly behind her, the way a thought follows you when you are trying not to think it.
*And if you follow where she's been—*
"Lily!" she screamed, and her voice broke, and the singing stopped, and the silence came back, and Sarah walked and walked and the trees did not end.
She found the fence line by accident. She had been walking for what felt like a long time, though the light had not changed, and her hands were scratched and her hair was full of twigs and she had begun to be afraid in a new way, a cold creeping way, the fear of a thing that does not end—and then there it was, the old wire fence, the rusted posts leaning, the strands sagging, and beyond it the back of somebody's field and the roof of a barn. She had come out on the far side of the Hollow's hem, half a mile from her own yard, and she climbed the fence and tore her coat and did not care, and she stood in the field and looked back at the trees.
The trees stood. The wind moved in them. The birds had come back—she could hear them, a jay scolding somewhere, a crow—and the world was ordinary and gray and cold, and the Hollow behind her was only a forest, only trees, only a place where the light was a little dimmer and the air a little stiller and nothing moved but the branches.
"Lily," Sarah said. Her voice was a ruin. "Lily, please."
And from the trees, from deep in the trees, faint and sweet and patient, a child's voice said, "Mama."
Sarah stood at the fence with her hands on the wire and her blood roaring in her ears, and she did not go back in. She did not go back in because she knew, now, with the cold clear part of her mind that had stayed awake, that she had been called out of the yard and called through the trees and called to the fence, and that if she went back in she would not come out. She knew it the way she knew her own name. And she knew that her daughter was in there, and that the thing in there was wearing her daughter's voice like a coat, and that she had left the prints behind, and that the prints had stopped.
She turned and ran for the road.
---
The sheriff's cruiser came up the drive with its lights going and no siren, because Dan Coats was a man who had learned that a siren in a small town was a kind of promise, and he did not want to promise anything he could not deliver. Sarah was standing in the yard when he got out. She had run the half mile down the road and back up her own drive and she had gone through the house calling and she had gone down the slope again to the last of the footprints and she had stood there and not gone in, and then she had called the station, and now she stood in the yard with her arms wrapped around herself and her coat torn and her face the color of the sheets on the line.
Dan Coats got out of the cruiser and looked at her, and then he looked past her, down the slope, at the tree line, and something in his face closed like a door.
"How long," he said.
"I don't know. Twenty minutes. Maybe thirty. I was hanging laundry. She was on the porch. The screen door banged and then—" Sarah heard her own voice climbing and could not stop it. "There are footprints. Down the slope. They just stop, Dan, they stop at the edge and there's nothing after, and I went in, I went in after her and I heard—"
"Sarah." Dan's voice was flat and careful, the voice of a man talking somebody off a ledge. "Stop. Breathe. Did you see her in the trees?"
"No. I heard her. I heard her say—" Sarah stopped. She looked at Dan's face and saw what was in it, and she understood that whatever she said next, he would already have known it, and that he would not want to hear it said out loud. "I heard a child's voice. Calling me."
Dan Coats looked at her for a long moment. Then he took his radio off his shoulder and called the station and told them to get the volunteers out, and he said the word *search* and he said the word *Hollow* and his voice did not change on either word, and Sarah stood in her own yard and listened to a man organize the finding of her daughter and felt the world tilt under her.
"Dan." She caught his sleeve. "You know something. You've known something since I came back. What's in those woods?"
He looked at her hand on his sleeve and then at her face, and for a moment the flat careful thing in him slipped, and she saw what was under it: a tired man, a frightened man, a man who had seen something once and had spent years not saying it. "Where did the prints stop?" he said.
"At the edge of the mown grass. Just before the birches."
"Show me."
They went down the slope together. The wind had come up and the grass was moving and the prints were fainter now, the wet ground drying, the little tread-marks filling in, and Sarah walked with her eyes on them and her heart in her throat and Dan Coats walked beside her with his hand on his belt and said nothing at all. The last pair of prints was still there, two neat ovals in the grass, and beyond them the wild grass stood unmarked, and the birches stood in their white rows, and the wind moved in the hemlocks and the birds were quiet again.
Dan stood and looked at the prints for a long time. Then he took off his hat and held it in both hands and looked into the trees.
"Dan." Sarah's voice was a whisper. "What is it? What took her?"
"Nobody knows what it is," he said. "That's the truth of it. Nobody's ever known. We call it the Hollow because that's what it is—a hollow, a place that's empty, a place that takes." He turned the hat over in his hands. "My grandmother knew. Your mother knew. There's not many left who know, and the ones who do won't say it out loud, because saying it out loud is how you get its attention."
"It has my daughter's voice."
Dan closed his eyes. "I know."
"It said *Mama.*"
"I know." He put his hat back on and his face was the flat careful face again, and Sarah wanted to hit him, wanted to take him by the shoulders and shake the carefulness out of him. "Sarah, listen to me. The volunteers are going to come, and they're going to search the woods, and they're going to walk the fence line and the ridge and the fire roads, and they will not find her. I'm telling you that now so you're not surprised. They will not find her because she's not in the woods the way a lost child is in the woods. She's been taken, and the thing that took her doesn't leave a trail."
"Then what do we do?"
Dan Coats looked at her, and his eyes were wet, and he did not look away. "There's one person in this town who knows the whole of it. Who knows the history, and the pact, and what it wants, and what it takes to get a child back. She's ninety years old and her mind is going, and she doesn't like me, and she's the only chance your girl has got. We go to Mrs. Thorne. We go now, before the light goes. Because after dark, Sarah—" He stopped. He looked at the trees. "After dark nobody goes into that Hollow and comes back with their memories. And some don't come back at all."
Sarah stood at the edge of the mown grass and looked at her daughter's last footprints, two neat ovals in the wet green, and the wind came up and moved the grass and the prints began to blur, and she thought: *five minutes. I turned my back for five minutes.*
"Take me to her," she said.
---
The volunteers came, and the volunteers searched. Sarah watched them from the yard because she could not make herself go inside. She watched them come up the drive in their trucks and their old cars, men in blaze orange and women in raincoats, the high school principal and the woman from the post office and the boy who bagged groceries, and they fanned out along the fence line with flashlights and they called Lily's name into the trees, and their voices went in and did not come back. They searched until the light began to go. They found nothing. They found less than nothing—they found no print, no scrap of yellow jacket, no red boot. The trail stopped where it had stopped, and the men stood around it in a ring and looked at the ground and then at the trees, and Sarah saw them do it, saw them all look up at the tree line at the same moment, and saw them all take a step back from it without meaning to. Not one of them would go past the birches. Not one of them said why.
By the time Dan Coats came back up the slope to get her, the light was the color of weak tea and the wind had turned cold and the line in the yard was still full of her daughter's small shirts, blowing and snapping, red and yellow and blue, and Sarah had not brought them in. She could not. She stood and looked at them and they were the only color in the world.
"Sarah." Dan's voice was gentle now, gentler than she had ever heard it. "We need to go. Mrs. Thorne's house is out past the ridge road. It's a drive, and I want to be back before full dark."
Sarah turned from the shirts. Her face was dry and her eyes were dry and something in her had gone very quiet and very cold. "What does it want?" she said. "You said it takes. What does it want?"
Dan Coats stood in her yard with his hat in his hands. "It wants what it can't make," he said. "It's a hollow, Sarah. It's empty. It's got no voice of its own, no face of its own, no memories of its own. So it takes them. It takes the voices and the faces and the memories and it wears them. It's been wearing this town's memories for two hundred years. And a child—" He stopped. He looked at the tree line. "A child is the best thing it can find. A child is all voice. All song. All memory, not yet made. A child is the thing it wants most."
Sarah walked past him to the cruiser. She got into the passenger seat and sat with her hands folded in her lap and looked out the window at the line of her daughter's shirts. Dan got in beside her and started the engine and the cruiser turned around in the yard and went down the drive, and the shirts snapped in the wind behind them, and the yard emptied, and the light went out of the sky.
They were halfway down the drive when Sarah said, "It sang to me. In the woods. It sang a song my mother used to sing. How does it know a song my mother used to sing?"
Dan Coats drove with his eyes on the road. "Your mother grew up here," he said. "She sang it in these woods when she was a girl. It heard her. It's been hearing us for two hundred years, Sarah. It's got all our songs."
Sarah looked out the window at the trees going past, and the trees went past and past, and the light in them was the color of old blood.
"Drive faster," she said.
---
Old Mrs. Thorne's house stood at the end of the ridge road with its shutters closed and one yellow light burning in a window, and the woods came right up to the back of it, right up to the porch rails, so close that the branches touched the roof and scraped it when the wind blew. Sarah got out of the cruiser and stood in the road and looked at the house and the trees behind it and the one yellow window, and she could hear the branches scraping, and she could hear the wind, and she could hear, very faint and very far, from somewhere in the woods, a child's voice singing.
Dan Coats came around the cruiser and stood beside her and did not say anything. He did not have to. They stood together in the road and listened to the singing, and the singing went on and on, patient and sweet, and Sarah Grey stood in the last of the light with her hands at her sides and her heart gone cold and thought: *I hear you. I hear you. And I am coming.*
The front door of the house opened. Old Mrs. Thorne stood in the doorway with a shawl around her shoulders, and her white hair was loose and her hands were knotted on the frame, and she looked past Dan Coats and past Sarah and out at the woods, and her old face was sharp with a fear that had outlived everything else in her, a fear that had kept her mind alive when everything else had gone.
"It's taken a child," she said. It was not a question. "It's breaking the pact. It's taken a child at last."
"Yes," Sarah said. "It's taken mine."
Mrs. Thorne looked at her then, and her old eyes were clear and terrible. "Then come in," she said. "Both of you. And close the door behind you and lock it, and don't look at the trees, and don't answer if it calls. It's dark now. Say nothing after dark. Nothing at all."
Sarah went up the walk. The singing followed her, thin and high and sweet, her mother's song and her daughter's voice, and she did not look at the trees. She did not answer. She went into the house and Dan Coats came behind her and closed the door and locked it, and the yellow light closed over them both, and somewhere out in the dark the singing went on, patient and sweet, calling her by name.