← The Hollow

The Search Begins

Chapter 10 of 17 · 5416 words

The pancakes went cold on the griddle while Sarah stood at the kitchen window and watched the town come awake wrong.

She had made the batter without thinking, the way she had made it a thousand mornings, flour and egg and a pinch of salt, the ritual of it steadying her hands. Lily had set the table. She had put out two plates and two forks and two glasses of milk, and she had done it with a small, grave precision that Sarah found more unsettling than any tantrum. The child was being careful. The child was being good, the way children are good when they have learned that the adults around them are afraid.

Then the light had changed at the window, and Sarah had looked up, and the pancakes had begun to smoke.

They came down the road in twos and threes, out of the gray morning, in trucks and on foot, in raincoats and work boots and one man in his pajama bottoms and a Carhartt jacket, as though he had simply rolled out of bed and walked. They carried flashlights though it was nearly daylight. They carried thermoses and walking sticks and, here and there, the long-handled tools of men who did not know what else to bring to a thing like this—a pitchfork, a chain saw, a coil of rope. They gathered in the road in front of the schoolhouse, which was the only building in Greythorn with a lot big enough to hold them, and they stood in the wet grass with their breath steaming and did not, Sarah noticed, look at the trees.

Not one of them looked at the trees.

The Hollow began at the edge of the school lot, a wall of dark spruce and older, unnamed timber that rose up the slope behind the playground and did not stop rising until it met the low belly of the clouds. It was the thing you saw first when you came into Greythorn from the south, and the thing you stopped seeing first when you had lived here long enough, and this morning it stood there in the mist like a held breath, like a mouth deciding whether to open.

Sarah turned off the burner. The pancakes had gone black on one side. She scraped them into the trash and poured the rest of the batter down the sink and stood for a moment with her hands braced on the counter, breathing.

"Mommy?" Lily said from the table. "Are they here for the girl?"

Sarah turned around. "What girl, sweetheart."

"The girl who's lost." Lily had her fork in her fist and was watching the window with a patient, interested expression, the way she watched the birds at the feeder. "That's why they're all here. They're going to look for her in the woods."

Sarah crouched down beside her chair. "How do you know about that?"

"I heard the phone," Lily said. "When you were in the shower. It was a man and he said a girl didn't come home and he was crying a little, I think. But he was trying not to." She put down her fork and looked at her mother with her clear blue eyes. "She went into the woods, didn't she. That's why they won't look up."

Sarah's mouth had gone dry. "We don't know that. We don't know anything yet. Eat your pancakes."

She dressed Lily in her warmest sweater and her boots and a hat that covered her ears, and she did not know why she was dressing her for outside, except that she could not bear to leave her in the house alone, and she could not bear to be in the house alone herself. She wrapped her own coat around her shoulders and took Lily's hand and stepped out into the gray.

The air smelled of wet ash. That was the first thing. Not woodsmoke—wet ash, the smell of a fire that had been put out, and underneath it the green cold smell of the forest, which this morning seemed to have no bottom to it, no end. Sarah breathed through her mouth and walked across the road to the school lot.

She had not gone ten steps before she understood that the whole town was there.

Not the whole town. Perhaps forty people. But forty people in Greythorn was the whole town on a Tuesday morning, the whole town that was not too old or too sick or too afraid to come. They stood in their clusters and their family groups, and they spoke in low voices, and the low voices had the particular quality of people who are trying not to be overheard by something that might be listening. The men kept their hands in their pockets. The women held their coffee cups with both hands, like charms. Somebody's dog was there, a black shepherd, and it would not stop whining, and after a while its owner took it back to the truck and shut it inside.

"Sarah." Sheriff Coats came across the grass toward her, and he looked, this morning, like a man who had not slept and had not expected to. His eyes were pouched and red and his jaw was dark with stubble, and there was about him the particular calm of a man who had been waiting for a phone to ring for a long time and had finally heard it ring. "You shouldn't be out here. Take the little one home."

"Dan." She said it quietly, and she said it the way she used to say it when they were both younger and the world had seemed like a thing that could be reasoned with. "What's happened?"

He looked at Lily. Then he looked at the trees, and then away, and then at Sarah again. "Holly Keene. Eleven years old. She went out to the Hollis place last night to feed her aunt's goats, and she never came back. Her mother called me at four this morning." He paused. "Nobody's seen her since."

"Since four this morning?"

"Since last night," he said. "Since about seven. Her aunt says she hears the back door go. She thought she heard Holly singing, out in the yard." He stopped. He looked at the trees again. "Then nothing."

Sarah thought about the window. The small high voice. *She walks in green, she walks alone.* She thought about it and she did not say it, because Lily was holding her hand and Lily's hand was warm and small and real, and because there are things you do not say in front of a child, and there are things you do not say in front of a town.

"Where's the search starting?" she said.

"Behind the school. Up the old logging road." He had his hat in his hands and he was turning it, slowly, by the brim. "We'll go in at the treeline and fan out. Three groups. Keep the road to your right. Call her name every fifty feet. Back by dark."

"Back by dark," Sarah repeated. "You're not going past the treeline."

It was not a question, and Dan Coats did not pretend it was. He put his hat on and pulled the brim down and said, "We'll go in at the treeline. That's where she was last seen. That's where we'll look."

"Dan. That's not what I asked."

"Take the child home, Sarah." He said it gently, and that was the worst of it, the gentleness. He turned away from her and raised his voice to the crowd, and his voice was a different voice now, the voice of a man who had done this before, and Sarah stood in the wet grass with her daughter's hand in hers and listened to him organize a search.

She had heard, once, a recording of a man who had been in a war, a man who had come home and become a fire chief in a small New England town, and someone had asked him how he stayed so calm when the alarm went, and he had said, *You do it enough times, you learn the shape of a bad morning, and you walk through the shape.* That was Dan Coats now. He had the shape of it. He split the volunteers into three parties and put a man named Ellis Crouch, who had been a forester before his knees went, in charge of the western line, and he put the Keenes' neighbor, a broad quiet woman named Della Pratt, in charge of the eastern, and he took the center himself. He told them to stay in sight of one another. He told them not to wander. He told them, and this was the part Sarah would remember, that if they heard anything—a voice, a whistle, a sound like a child calling—they were to stop where they stood and blow their whistles three times and wait, and not to go toward it.

"Not toward it," a man in the back said. "Dan, if it's the kid—"

"Not toward it," Dan said again, and his voice did not rise, and the man in the back did not say anything else. "Three blasts. We come to you. We all come to you. Nobody goes off alone."

Nobody goes off alone. Sarah stood there and watched the faces of the volunteers as they took this in, and she watched the way they nodded, and the way their eyes slid past one another, and the way not a single one of them asked the question that was sitting in the front of her own mouth like a stone.

She took Lily home. She made her a fresh pancake and sat with her while she ate it and did not taste anything herself. Then she called the school and told the secretary that she would not be in today, that her daughter was unwell, and she stood at the kitchen window with the phone still warm in her hand and watched the search parties go up the logging road behind the school and stop at the place where the trees began.

They stopped. All of them. They stood in a ragged line along the treeline, forty people in their coats and their boots, and Sarah watched them and waited for them to step in, and they did not step in.

One man—she thought it was the man in the pajama bottoms—took a single step forward, and stopped, and stood there with his arms at his sides, and then stepped back. She saw his shoulders move, the way a man's shoulders move when he takes a breath and holds it. Then she saw the whole line move forward, all together, the way a wave comes up a beach and then goes back, and they were at the edge, and then they were a little past the edge, and then they were in, and she could see the shapes of them between the trunks, and she could see the flashlights, and she could hear, faintly, across the wet grass and the road and the playground, the sound of her neighbors calling a child's name.

*Holly. Holly Keene.*

It should have been a comfort. It was not a comfort. She did not know why.

She found out why an hour later, when she walked back across to the school lot to bring Dan Coats the coffee she had made because she could not sit still, and she saw the search parties coming out of the trees.

They came out in twos and threes, the same way they had gone in, and they came out along the logging road and down the slope behind the playground, and their boots and the cuffs of their trousers were wet with the same beaded dew that had been on the grass when they went in. Their flashlights were off. Their faces were gray and closed. Della Pratt was crying, quietly, the way a woman cries when she does not want to be seen crying, and Ellis Crouch was walking with his hand on Della's shoulder and his mouth set in a line.

Sarah stood in the lot with the coffee in her hands and watched them come. She looked at her watch. It was not quite eight thirty. The search had begun at seven.

Dan Coats came out of the trees last, with his hat in his hands and his head down, and when he saw Sarah he stopped, and something moved across his face and was gone.

"That was fast," Sarah said.

"We covered the ground," he said. "It's thick in there. It's older than it looks. You can walk in a hundred yards and not see a thing that's ten feet from you."

"Dan." She held out the coffee. He took it. His hands were shaking, and she did not think it was the cold. "You went in at seven. You came out at eight twenty. That's an hour and twenty minutes. That's not a search. That's a walk."

"It's what we can do," he said. He drank the coffee. He did not look at her. "It's what we're going to do, Sarah, and then we're going to do it again tomorrow, and if the state police come—" He stopped. He looked at his coffee. "The state police will come. They'll come this afternoon. And they'll do what they do, and they'll ask what we did, and we'll tell them we searched the near woods and we'll tell them we'll search again tomorrow, and that will be the truth."

"The near woods." Sarah heard her own voice go thin. "There's a child in there, Dan. There's a child in the *far* woods, if she's anywhere, and you know it, and you know that I know it, so I'm going to ask you one more time. Why won't you go past the treeline?"

The lot had gone quiet. The volunteers were drifting away toward their trucks, and the ones who were not drifting away were standing very still, listening, and not pretending not to. Della Pratt had stopped crying. Ellis Crouch had taken his hand off her shoulder and put it in his pocket.

Dan Coats looked at Sarah for a long moment. His eyes were red and pouched and very tired, and in them she saw something she had not expected to see, something that was not the calm of a man who had done this before. It was fear. It was the fear of a man who had stood at the edge of a thing and known exactly what it was.

"Because we don't," he said at last. "Because that's the way it's done here. It's the way it's always been done here, and it's the way it was done when I was a boy and when my father was a boy, and the day we stop doing it the way it's done is the day this town finds out what it's been paying for all these years." He put his hat on. "Take the child home, Sarah. Please. I'm asking you as a friend."

He walked away. She stood in the lot with the cold coffee in her hands and watched him go, and then she looked at the trees.

They stood at the edge of the school lot the way they had stood all morning, dark and close and patient, and the mist was in them and the light was in the mist and the light was gray and the mist was gray and the two of them were the same color, the color of a thing that has been left out in the rain. And Sarah Grey, who did not believe in the old stories, stood and looked at them and felt something look back.

Not eyes. Nothing so simple. It was the way the trees held their silence—a silence that had a shape to it, a silence that was not empty but full, the way a room is full when someone has just left it. It was the way the branches of the nearest spruce hung down over the logging road, and the way the road went in under them and did not come out. It was the way she could not, no matter how she tried, see more than thirty feet into the dark between the trunks, and the way her own eyes kept sliding off that dark and going back to the bright wet grass, the way a hand slides off a wet stone.

She thought of the song. *She walks in green, she walks alone.* She thought of Lily's drawings, the small green figure in the corner of every page, standing very still among the trunks. She thought of Holly Keene, eleven years old, going out to feed her aunt's goats in the last of the light, and hearing something in the yard, and singing.

She went home. She locked the door. She sat on the floor with Lily and helped her draw trees, and she did not look at the corner of the page.

---

The afternoon came in gray and stayed gray, and the state police came as Dan had said they would, two of them in a clean black cruiser that looked obscene against the wet green of the town, and they asked their questions and took their notes and stood at the treeline with their hands on their hips and looked in. Sarah watched them from her kitchen window. She watched one of them—the older one, a sergeant with a mustache—take off his hat and scratch his head and say something to the other one, and she watched the other one shake his head, and she watched them both look at the trees for a long time. Then they got back in the cruiser and drove away, and Sarah understood that they would come back tomorrow, and the day after, and then they would stop coming, because that was how it worked in towns like this, and because there was nothing in the near woods to find.

The near woods. She kept coming back to it. She kept turning it over in her hands like a stone she had picked up on a beach and could not put down.

She put Lily down for a nap at one o'clock, and Lily went without a fight, which was unlike her, and which Sarah did not let herself think about. She sat on the edge of the bed and smoothed the hair back from her daughter's forehead and watched her fall asleep, and then she went downstairs and stood in the front room with her arms wrapped around herself and looked at the wall.

Her mother's house. She had grown up in this house. She had grown up in this house and she had left it at eighteen and she had come back at thirty-five to bury the woman who had raised her in it, and in all that time she had never once asked herself the question she was asking herself now. She had never once asked herself why her mother had never gone into the woods.

Because she hadn't. Sarah knew that now, the way you know a thing you have always known and have only just noticed. Her mother had gardened and kept chickens and walked to the church and the store and the school, and she had never once, in all the years of Sarah's childhood, walked into the Hollow. Not to pick berries. Not to cut a Christmas tree. Not even to the edge. The women of Greythorn had gone into those woods for generations to gather ramps and fiddleheads and witch hazel, and Sarah's mother had not, and Sarah had never thought to ask her why.

She went upstairs. Her mother's room was at the end of the hall, and Sarah had not touched it since the funeral. The door was shut. She stood in front of it with her hand on the knob and felt the old house settle around her, the floorboards ticking as they cooled, the furnace murmuring in the basement, the whole frame of the place creaking softly the way old houses do when the wind leans on them.

She opened the door.

The room smelled of lavender and dust. The bed was made, the quilt pulled up smooth, the way her mother had always made it, and Sarah stood in the doorway and looked at it and felt the grief come up in her, sudden and hot, and pushed it back down. She was here for a reason. She crossed to the dresser and opened the top drawer, where her mother had kept the things she did not want anyone to see, and found what she had known she would find: a shoebox, and in the shoebox, a stack of papers.

Census records. A deed from 1871. A hand-drawn map of the Hollow on butcher paper, gone brown at the edges, with the logging roads marked in pencil and the town line in ink and, in the middle of the forest, a place marked with a small careful circle and no name. And under the map, a notebook, and in the notebook, in her mother's hand, a list.

Sarah sat down on the floor with her back against the bed and read the list. Names. Dates. Some of the names she knew, because they were on the war memorial in the town square, and some she did not, because they were older than the memorial. Next to each name there was a date, and next to each date, a word.

*Taken. Taken. Returned. Taken. Returned.*

And at the bottom of the last page, in her mother's hand, in ink that had gone brown, a single line:

*The pact holds as long as the town keeps to the near woods. It does not hold if we go looking.*

Sarah sat on the floor of her mother's room and read that line four times. Then she closed the notebook and put it in her pocket and sat very still.

The furnace murmured. The floorboards ticked. Somewhere below her, in the room where her daughter slept, a small high voice began, very softly, to hum a song.

Sarah was on her feet and in the hall before she knew she had moved. She took the stairs at a run and came into Lily's room with her heart in her throat and found her daughter sitting up in bed with her eyes open and her hands folded in her lap, humming. Just humming. Her face was calm and her eyes were clear and she looked up at Sarah and smiled.

"Mommy," she said. "I had a dream."

Sarah knelt by the bed. Her hands were shaking. "What did you dream, sweetheart?"

"I dreamed about the girl," Lily said. "Holly. She was in the woods and she wasn't scared. She said it was quiet in there. She said it was the quietest place she'd ever been." She tilted her head. "She said she was going to stay a while."

Sarah took her daughter's hands in her own and held them. They were warm. They were real. The room was full of gray afternoon light, and the rain had started, and it ticked against the window the way the floorboards ticked, and for a moment Sarah could not tell the difference between the sound of the rain and the sound of the house and the sound of her own blood in her ears.

"Lily," she said. "I need you to listen to me. I need you to listen very carefully."

"I'm listening," Lily said.

"If the girl in the woods ever asks you to come to her," Sarah said, "you say no. You say no and you come and find me. Do you understand?"

Lily looked at her for a long moment. Then she nodded, slowly, the way children nod when they are being asked to promise something they do not fully understand, and Sarah pulled her close and held her and felt her daughter's heart beating against her own, and outside the rain came down on the Hollow and the Hollow drank it in.

She did not sleep that night. She lay in the dark with the notebook on the nightstand and the rain on the roof and she thought about the line in her mother's hand. *It does not hold if we go looking.*

And she thought about Holly Keene, eleven years old, in the quietest place she had ever been, staying a while.

And she thought: *Then we will have to go looking.*

---

The rain stopped before dawn, and the day came up clear and cold, and by seven o'clock the town was in the school lot again, and there were more of them this time. Sarah counted sixty, maybe seventy. They had come from the farms out on the Ridge Road and from the trailer park by the river and from the big old houses on the square, and they stood in the wet grass with their breath steaming and their flashlights in their hands and their faces set, and they did not look at the trees.

Dan Coats was there. He had not slept either. She could see it in the way he held his shoulders and the way his eyes kept going to the treeline and coming back. He had the shape of a bad morning on him, and he walked through it, and Sarah stood at the edge of the crowd with Lily's hand in hers and watched him do it.

"Same as yesterday," he told them. "Three parties. Same lines. Call her name every fifty feet. Three blasts on the whistle and you stop where you stand." He paused. "We go in at the treeline. We do not go past the marked ground."

"Sheriff." A man's voice, from the back. It was Ellis Crouch. He had his forester's cap on and his hands in his pockets and his jaw was set. "Sheriff, we covered the marked ground yesterday. We covered it twice. There's nothing in there to find."

"Then we cover it again," Dan said.

"For how long?" Ellis said. "How long do we cover the same hundred yards while that little girl is out there somewhere in the far woods? How long do we do that, Dan, before we admit that we're not searching for her at all, we're just—" He stopped. He looked at the trees and then away. "We're just going through the motions."

The lot had gone very quiet. Dan Coats stood with his hat in his hands and looked at Ellis Crouch, and Sarah saw the fear come up in his face again, and saw him push it down.

"We do it the way it's done," he said.

"The way it's done," Ellis said. "The way it's done is we stay out of the woods and let the woods keep what it takes. That's the way it's done, Dan, and we all know it, and that little girl is out there right now because the way it's done failed her." His voice had gone rough. "My grandfather went in. You know that. You know what happened to him. He went in after the Pedersen boy, in 'thirty-eight, and he came out three days later and he couldn't remember his own name, and he never remembered it again. My grandmother fed him with a spoon for twenty years." He took his hands out of his pockets. "I'm not saying I want to go past the marked ground. I'm saying I want to know what the marked ground is for."

"It's for keeping us alive," Dan said, and his voice was very quiet. "That's what it's for, Ellis. That's all it's ever been for."

"Then say it," Ellis said. "Say it out loud, in front of everybody, so we all know what we're doing here. Say what's in the woods."

Dan Coats looked at him for a long moment. The mist was rising off the grass. The trees stood at the edge of the lot the way they had stood for a hundred and fifty years, and the light was in them, and the silence was in them, and it had a shape to it, and Sarah felt the shape of it press against her the way a hand presses against a window.

"I don't know what's in the woods," Dan said at last. "I've never known. I've been in there once, when I was nineteen years old, and I came out with a hole in my memory the size of a summer, and I've never gone back." He put his hat on. "I'm not going to say a word more about it. We do it the way it's done. If any of you want to go home, go home. I won't hold it against you."

Nobody went home. They stood in the wet grass and looked at their boots and their flashlights and the trees, and then they split into their three parties and went up the logging road and in at the treeline, and Sarah stood in the lot with her daughter's hand in hers and watched them go.

They were in the trees for an hour and ten minutes. She timed it. They came out along the logging road with their faces gray and their flashlights off, and Della Pratt was not crying this time, she was just walking, and Ellis Crouch walked beside her with his hand on her shoulder and his jaw set and his eyes on the ground.

Dan Coats came out last. He stopped at the treeline and stood for a moment with his back to the town, looking in, and Sarah saw his shoulders move, the way a man's shoulders move when he takes a breath and holds it. Then he turned around and came down the slope to the lot, and when he saw Sarah standing there with Lily's hand in hers, he stopped.

"Dan," Sarah said. "I found something in my mother's things."

He looked at her. His eyes were red and pouched and very tired, and he did not say anything.

"A notebook," she said. "A list of names. And a map of the Hollow, with the marked ground on it, and a place in the middle with no name." She held his gaze. "And a line in my mother's hand that says the pact holds as long as the town keeps to the near woods. It does not hold if we go looking."

Dan Coats closed his eyes. He stood in the wet grass with his hat in his hands and his eyes closed, and for a moment he looked like a man in a church, and then he opened them and looked at her, and there was something in his face she had not seen there before. Not fear, this time. Something older than fear. Something like grief.

"Your mother," he said. "Your mother knew."

"She knew," Sarah said. "And she never told me. And now there's a little girl in those woods, and you and I both know she's not in the near woods, and we both know what the pact costs." She took a step toward him. "I'm going in, Dan. I'm going past the marked ground. I'm going to find her."

"You can't," he said. "Sarah, you can't. You don't know what—"

"Then come with me," she said. "Or don't. But I'm going in, and I'm going in today, and I'm not going to do it the way it's done."

She turned her back on him and walked across the lot toward the treeline with Lily's hand in hers, and behind her she heard the silence of sixty people who had heard what she said, and she heard Dan Coats say her name, once, quietly, the way a man says the name of a thing he is afraid of losing. She did not stop. She walked up the logging road with the wet grass brushing her boots and the trees coming closer and closer, and at the treeline she stopped and looked down at her daughter.

Lily was looking into the trees. Her face was calm and her eyes were clear and blue, and her hand was warm and small and real in Sarah's hand, and she said, "It's okay, Mommy. She knows we're coming."

"Who does, sweetheart?"

"The girl," Lily said, and smiled, and Sarah felt the trees lean in to listen.