← The Hollow

The First Night

Chapter 11 of 17 · 4942 words

The school lot filled and kept filling.

By seven there were forty of them, by half past there were sixty, and Sarah stood on the schoolhouse steps with her coat buttoned wrong and her hair uncombed and watched the town of Greythorn assemble itself into a search party. Someone had brought a folding table out of the church basement and set it up in the grass, and on it were spread the things that people bring to a thing like this: a thermos of coffee that steamed and then stopped steaming, a box of granola bars, a roll of duct tape, a map of the county printed off somebody's home computer, its edges already curling in the damp. The map had the Hollow drawn on it as a green shape, flat and harmless, the way a map makes any place look harmless. Someone had uncapped a marker and drawn a line around the near woods, a lopsided circle maybe a mile across, and inside that circle were three small x's where the first searchers had already been and come back.

Sarah kept looking at the x's. She could not stop looking at them.

Sheriff Coats stood at the folding table with his hat pushed back and his hands flat on the map, and he was talking in a low voice to the men around him, and the men were nodding. He looked like a man who had not slept. He looked, in fact, like a man who had been awake for a very long time and had stopped expecting to sleep again, and there was something in the way he held his shoulders that made Sarah think of a door being held shut from the inside. When he saw her on the steps he straightened and came over, and his boots made a sound in the wet gravel that she heard too clearly, the way you hear things when you have not slept.

"You should be inside," he said. "It's cold."

"I'm not going inside."

"I know." He took off his hat and turned it over in his hands. The brim was dark with rain. "Mrs. Grey—Sarah. I want to tell you what we're doing, so you don't have to imagine it. We've got six teams. Four men each. They go in from the south, the east, the old logging road, and the deer trail up past the Kessler place. They go in a hundred yards, no further, and they sweep the near woods in a line. They call out. They listen. They come back out and they report to me and then they go in again, another hundred yards. We do that until we've covered the near woods, or until—" He stopped.

"Until what."

"Until it gets dark," he said. "Nobody's in there after dark. That's not a thing I get to argue about, Sarah. That's the way it is, and every man here knows it, and if I tried to send them in past sundown they'd quit and go home and then nobody's looking for her at all."

"She's eight years old," Sarah said. Her voice came out very even, which surprised her. "She's eight years old and she's been gone since yesterday afternoon and you're telling me you're going to stop looking at dinnertime."

"I'm telling you what's going to happen," Coats said. "I'm not telling you it's right."

The teams went in at a quarter to eight.

Sarah watched them from the edge of the lot, where the mown grass gave way to the first scrubby saplings and the ground went soft and dark. The men went in in their lines, four abreast, and their flashlights swung and crossed, and their voices carried back to her across the wet field — *Lily! Lily Grey!* — and then, as they went deeper, the voices got smaller and farther apart, the way voices do, and the flashlights got smaller too, until they were just little moving points of yellow light in among the black trunks, like fireflies that had lost their way.

And then the woods took them.

That was the only way Sarah could think of it afterward. The woods took them the way water takes a stone, without any sound or struggle, and one moment she could see six lights moving in the trees and the next she could see none, and the voices had stopped carrying back at all, and there was only the mist and the dark spruce and the flat gray sky above them.

She stood there a long time. The cold came up through her shoes. Behind her, the men who had stayed in the lot — the ones too old or too young or too afraid — stood around the folding table and drank coffee and did not talk much, and the church ladies came with a second thermos and a platter of sandwiches wrapped in wax paper and set them down and went away again without saying anything, and the whole time not one of them looked at the trees. Sarah noticed it again, the way she had noticed it at the window. They looked at the map, at their boots, at the coffee in their hands. They looked at the sky. They did not look at the trees.

A hand touched her elbow. It was Mrs. Kessler, who had been her mother's friend, a small round woman in a man's parka that came down past her knees.

"Come sit in the truck, honey," Mrs. Kessler said. "You'll catch your death out here."

"I'm fine."

"You're shaking."

"I'm fine," Sarah said, and she was, she was fine, she was standing at the edge of the woods with her arms crossed and her jaw set and she was not going to sit in a truck and drink coffee and wait to be told. She was going to stand here and watch, and if the woods were going to take her daughter then the woods could God damn well look her in the eye while they did it.

Mrs. Kessler looked at her for a moment, and then she looked at the trees, just once, quickly, the way you might glance at a dog you were afraid of, and then she looked away again and squeezed Sarah's elbow and went back to the table.

The morning went on.

The teams came out at ten and reported, and went back in, and came out at noon and reported, and went back in. Each time they came out they came out a little quieter than they had gone in. They stood in the lot with their hands wrapped around cups of coffee and their eyes fixed on the middle distance, and when Coats asked them questions they answered in short flat sentences. *Nothing. Nothing. We called the whole way. Nothing.* One of them, a young man named Duane who worked at the feed store, had a scratch on his cheek that he could not explain, and when Coats asked him about it he put his hand up to it and looked surprised, as though he had not known it was there. "Bushwhacked, I guess," he said. "Didn't feel it."

Sarah stood at the edge and watched them come and go, and the thing she could not get out of her head was how quiet it was.

Not the lot — the lot was full of men and coffee and the sound of engines. The woods. The woods were quiet. They had been quiet all morning, and she had not understood how quiet until she stopped to listen, and then she could not stop listening, and the more she listened the quieter it got, until the quiet had a shape and a weight and a texture, until it was a thing you could put your hand against. There was no wind in there. The spruce tops did not move. There were no crows, and there should have been crows, there were always crows in a Vermont wood in November, and there were no squirrels and no jays and no sound of anything at all except, very faintly, once, far off, the sound of a man's voice calling a name, and then that stopped too.

She could hear her own heartbeat.

She stood at the edge of the mown grass with her hands at her sides and she could hear her own heartbeat, and the sound of it was so loud in her ears that she was afraid the men behind her could hear it too, and she thought: *This is what it sounds like. This is what it sounds like to be alone in a place that is not empty.*

Behind her, somebody's radio crackled and went quiet.

The afternoon went gray and then grayer. The mist came down the slope out of the Hollow in slow ropes and moved among the trees and thinned and thickened and thinned again, and the light began to go out of the sky the way it does in November, not all at once but by degrees, the gray going to pewter and the pewter going to slate. At half past three Coats called the teams in for the last sweep, and this time when they came out of the trees they came out fast, not running but walking fast, with their shoulders up around their ears, and the last man out kept looking back over his shoulder as though he had heard something and wanted to be sure it had not followed him.

Sarah caught Coats by the sleeve as he came past.

"One more," she said. "One more sweep."

"That was the last one."

"One more."

"Sarah." He turned and looked at her, and in the failing light his face looked old, older than she had ever seen it, and there was something in his eyes she had seen once before, on a night in August when she had found him sitting in his cruiser outside the school with the engine off and the windows down, listening to the woods. "It's four o'clock. It'll be dark in an hour. I can't send men in there at four o'clock in November."

"Then send them in now. Right now. They've got an hour."

"An hour to do what? We've covered the near woods twice over. She's not in the near woods." He said it gently, and that was the worst of it, the gentleness. "If she's in there at all she's deeper than we can go."

"Then go deeper."

"I can't ask a man to go deeper." His voice was low. "You know what I'm telling you. You've lived here. You know what I'd be asking them to do."

"I don't know anything," Sarah said. "I don't believe any of it. I never have. I don't believe in your pact and your—your stories and your woods that eat people. I believe my daughter is lost in a forest and it is getting dark and you are standing here telling me about the *way things are*—"

She stopped. Her voice had gotten loud and the men in the lot had turned to look at her, and she stood there breathing hard with her hands shaking and the tears coming up hot behind her eyes, and she was not going to cry in front of them, she was not.

Coats did not look away. He stood there with his hat in his hands and let her finish, and when she had finished he said, very quietly, "I know. I know what I'm telling you. And I'm telling you anyway. Because I've seen what happens to the men who go in after dark, and I'm not going to be the one who sends them. Not even for her. God help me. Not even for her."

"Then I'll go."

"No."

"You can't stop me."

"I can," he said. "And I will. I'll put a man on your door before I let you walk into those trees tonight, Sarah, and you can hate me for it, and I'll deserve it, and I'll do it anyway."

She looked at him. The mist was moving behind him, out of the Hollow, and the first of the evening's dark was collecting under the trees.

"You've seen something," she said. "In there. You've seen something and you won't tell me what it was."

Coats put his hat on. He did it slowly, deliberately, the way a man does a thing with his hands so that he does not have to do a thing with his face.

"Go home," he said. "I'll come by at ten with the night watch. We'll have men on the road all night with their headlights on. If she's coming out, we'll see her. Go home and eat something and sit down."

"I'm not going home."

"Sarah."

"I'm not going home," she said. "I'm going to stand right here until you bring her out of those trees."

He looked at her for a long moment. Then he nodded, once, and turned away, and Sarah turned back to the woods and folded her arms against the cold and did not move.

The lot emptied slowly.

The church ladies packed up the thermoses and the platter and the wax paper and went home in a station wagon with its headlights on. The old men who had stood around the folding table all day got into their trucks and drove away, and their taillights went red down the road and disappeared. The teams stood in a loose knot for a while, talking low, and then they too got into their trucks and left, and the folding table stood alone in the wet grass with the map on it, and the curling edges of the map lifted in a wind that had come up, and Sarah stood at the edge of the lot and watched the last of the daylight go out of the sky.

It went slowly. That was the thing about November. The sky did not go black; it went the color of a bruise, and then the color of iron, and then the color of nothing, and the trees stood up against it black on black, and the mist moved among them, and the first star came out above the Hollow and was very cold and very far away.

At six o'clock the headlights came on.

Two cruisers and three pickups, parked nose to tail along the road at the edge of the school lot, all of them facing the Hollow with their high beams on. The light went into the trees and did not go far. It lit the first rank of spruce and the wet ground beneath them and then it stopped, or it did not stop so much as fail, the way a light fails at the bottom of deep water. Beyond the first rank of trees there was nothing but the dark, and the light went into the dark and was swallowed, and Sarah stood and looked at it and thought: *It's like shining a flashlight into a mouth.*

Coats came and stood beside her. He had a thermos in one hand and a folding chair in the other and he set the chair down in the grass and said, "Sit. Please. Just sit down."

She sat. She was so tired she could not feel her legs. She sat in the folding chair in the wet grass with the headlights behind her and her hands wrapped around the thermos and she did not drink the coffee, she just held it, because it was warm, and the warmth was the only thing in the world that felt real.

"Tell me," she said. "Tell me what you've seen."

"Not tonight."

"Tell me."

He was quiet for a while. The headlights hummed. Out in the dark a loon called, once, on the reservoir, and the sound came across the cold water and into the lot and was very lonely and very ordinary, and Sarah found herself clutching at it, at the ordinariness of it, the way you clutch at a branch when you are going under.

"When I was a boy," Coats said, "my cousin Danny went in. He was fourteen. It was October, and he'd been out hunting, and he didn't come home for supper. My uncle went out after him and came back alone at midnight and wouldn't say a word. Wouldn't say a word for three days. And on the third day Danny came walking out of the trees at the bottom of the Kessler field, just walked out, like he'd been for a stroll. He was fine. He was smiling. He came in and ate a whole loaf of bread and butter and went to sleep and slept fourteen hours. And when he woke up he didn't know who I was." Coats turned his hat over in his hands. "He knew his mother. He knew his father. He knew the dog. But there were whole years gone out of him. He couldn't remember the summer before. He couldn't remember his own birthday party. He couldn't remember me, and I'd lived next door to him my whole life, and we'd fished every brook in this county together. It was like somebody had taken a pair of scissors to him and cut out everything that had my name in it."

"What happened to him?"

"He's in Rutland now. Works at the tire place. He's fine. He's got a wife and a kid and he's fine. But he doesn't come back here. He won't cross the town line. And when I saw him at his mother's funeral he looked at me like I was a stranger, and I could see him trying to remember, I could see him reaching for it, and there was nothing there to reach for."

Sarah sat very still. The coffee in the thermos had stopped being warm.

"So that's what it does," she said. "It takes your memories."

"It takes things," Coats said. "That's what I know. That's all I know. It takes things and it gives them back, or it doesn't, and the ones it gives back are never quite the same. And it doesn't do it because it's cruel. That's the part I can't explain to anybody who hasn't lived here. It doesn't do it because it's cruel. It does it the way the river does it, or the cold. It's not personal. It's just what it is."

"And my daughter is in there."

"Yes."

"With it."

"Yes."

Sarah looked at the headlights. The beams went into the trees and stopped and the dark beyond them was so complete that it did not look like a place at all. It looked like the end of the world, like the edge of a picture somebody had stopped painting.

"Then I'm going to sit here," she said, "until it gives her back."

Coats nodded. He pulled his coat around him and sat down on the wet grass beside her chair, and neither of them said anything for a long while.

The night came down.

The headlights burned. The mist moved. At some point Coats went to his cruiser and came back with a blanket and put it around her shoulders without asking, and at some point he went again and came back with two cups of coffee from the thermos in the trunk, and at some point the moon rose above the Hollow, thin and white and cold, and laid a little silver on the tops of the spruces, and the spruces did not move.

And then, around eleven, the woods made a sound.

It was not a loud sound. That was the thing about it. It was so quiet that Sarah was not sure at first that she had heard anything at all, and she sat up in her chair with her heart going and her hand on the armrest and she listened, and the sound came again.

It was a child, singing.

It was far off, deep in the trees, and it was very small, and it was a tune Sarah knew. She knew it the way you know a thing from before you had words for it, from before you had anything, from the deep before-time of being small and being sung to. It was a tune her mother had sung to her. It was a tune she sang to Lily.

*Hush, little bird, don't you cry,*

*Mama's going to sing you a lullaby.*

Sarah was out of the chair before she knew she had moved. She was at the edge of the grass and her hands were cold and the blanket had fallen and she was staring into the trees and the singing went on, faint and clear and sweet, a child's voice, a little girl's voice, coming out of the dark.

"Lily," she said. Her voice cracked. "Lily!"

The singing stopped.

The silence that came after it was worse than the singing had been. It was the silence of a held breath, of a thing that had been making a sound and had stopped to listen. Sarah stood at the edge of the trees with her heart slamming and the cold coming up through her shoes and she could feel the woods looking at her. She could not have said how. There was no wind, no sound, no movement in the dark, and yet every hair on her arms stood up, and she knew, the way you know in a dream that you are being watched, that something in there had heard her and was glad.

"Sarah." Coats's hand was on her arm. He had come up behind her without her hearing him and his voice was low and urgent. "Sarah, don't. Don't go in there."

"That was her. That was her voice."

"That was not her voice."

"It was her voice, Dan, I know my daughter's voice—"

"That," Coats said, "is how it calls you in."

She turned on him. She was shaking all over, and she did not know if it was the cold or the fear or the terrible, treacherous hope, and she did not care. "You don't know that. You don't know anything. You're a drunk in a uniform who sits in his car and listens to the trees and tells himself stories—"

"I know," Coats said. "I know I am. I know exactly what I am." His hand was still on her arm and it was steady. "And I know what I heard. And I'm telling you, Sarah, that is not your daughter. Your daughter is eight years old and she is out there somewhere in the dark and if that were her voice she would not be singing a song she learned from you. She would be screaming. She would be crying for you. She would be making the sounds a lost child makes. That—" he nodded at the trees, "—that is something that has heard her sing and is using it. It's wearing her voice like a coat. Don't you go in there. Don't you let it put that coat on you."

The woods were silent. The moon was very white on the tops of the trees.

And then, from far in, from deeper than the singing had been, there came a sound that was not singing and was not silence. It was a low sound, a long sound, a sound like the lowest string of a cello drawn slowly across, and it came out of the Hollow and rolled across the field and into the lot and it did not stop, it went on and on, and under it, very faint, there was a sound like many people breathing.

Every headlight flickered.

All five of them, the cruisers and the pickups, all five at once, and the light in the trees stuttered and dimmed and came back up, and in the moment it dimmed Sarah saw something in the trees. She saw it the way you see a thing in a lightning flash, all at once and never again. She saw a shape among the trunks that was not a trunk, a tall pale shape that stood very still, and it had no face that she could see, and it was looking at her.

The lights came back up and there was nothing there but the trees.

The low sound stopped.

Sarah stood very still in the wet grass with Coats's hand on her arm, and she was aware of a great many things at once: the cold, the hum of the generators, the smell of wet leaves and exhaust, her own heart, the taste of copper in her mouth. And she was aware, too, of a thing she could not name, a thing that had come into her at the moment the lights flickered and had not left. It was a feeling like being remembered. It was like standing in a room you have never been in and knowing exactly where the furniture is. It was like hearing your name spoken in a voice you have never heard.

"Dan," she said. Her voice was very small. "What did I just see?"

"Nothing," Coats said. "You didn't see anything. You were looking at the trees and the lights flickered and you didn't see anything at all." His hand tightened on her arm. "Do you understand me? That's what you saw. Nothing."

She looked at him. His face in the moonlight was gray and old and very tired, and his eyes were the eyes of a man who had been looking at that same nothing for thirty years.

"You've seen it before," she said.

"Get in the car, Sarah."

"What is it?"

"Get in the car."

"*What is it?*"

"I don't know," he said, and his voice cracked, and it was the first time she had ever heard it crack. "I don't know what it is. I've been sheriff of this town for twenty-six years and I don't know what it is and I don't want to know what it is. I know what it does. I know the rules. I know you don't go in after dark and you don't answer it when it calls and you don't look at it when the lights go out. And I know that every year it gets a little bolder, a little closer, and every year the rules get a little harder to keep, and every year there's one more kid who doesn't come out of the woods and one more family that packs up and leaves. That's what I know. That's all I know. Now get in the car."

She got in the car.

She did not remember deciding to. She remembered the cold and the headlights and Coats's hand on her arm, and then she was sitting in the passenger seat of the cruiser with the heater roaring and the blanket around her shoulders and the trees going past the window, black and close, and she was shaking so hard her teeth chattered.

Coats drove her home. He did not say anything on the way and neither did she. The road was dark and the headlights cut a tunnel through the mist and once, just once, on the long straight stretch past the Kessler place, Sarah thought she saw something standing at the edge of the trees, a tall pale shape, and she did not look at it, and Coats did not look at it, and the car went past and the dark closed over it.

He walked her to the door. The porch light was on, the one she had left on when she had gone out that morning, and it made a little yellow pool on the wet steps, and she stood in it and could not make herself go in.

"I'll have a man on the road all night," Coats said. "Two men. Headlights on. If she comes out, they'll see her."

"And if she doesn't come out?"

He did not answer that.

"Dan." She caught his sleeve. "The singing. It knew the song I sing to her. How does it know the song I sing to her?"

Coats looked at her for a long moment. The porch light made his face strange, all shadows.

"Because she sang it," he said. "Out there. In the dark. She sang it to herself to keep from being afraid, and it heard her, and now it knows the song." He put his hat on. "That's the thing about it, Sarah. That's the thing nobody wants to say out loud. It doesn't just take things. It learns them. And it uses them to call you in." He stepped back off the porch. "Lock your door. I'll be back at dawn."

He drove away. The taillights went red down the road and turned at the corner and were gone.

Sarah stood on her own porch in the yellow light with the blanket around her shoulders and she looked at the door of her house, and then she looked past it, out to where the Hollow stood black against the stars at the end of the field.

The woods were silent.

She could hear her own heartbeat.

She went inside and locked the door and did not turn off the porch light, and she sat down in the kitchen with her coat still on and her hands wrapped around a cup of tea she did not drink, and she listened to the silence of the trees, and the silence of the trees went on and on, and somewhere out in it, in the deep dark under the spruces, a child was singing a lullaby, very softly, to keep from being afraid.