← The Hollow

The Rules

Chapter 13 of 17 · 6784 words

The Thorne house had been old when the road was young.

It sat at the top of the ridge where the trees pulled back a little and let the sky in, a low gray farmhouse with a slate roof and windows that were too small for the walls they were set in, as though the house had been built by people who did not entirely trust the light. There was a porch that sagged in the middle. There was a chimney that had not been swept in a decade. There was a weathervane on the barn, a rusted iron rooster with its beak open, frozen mid-crow, and it did not move even though the wind up here was steady and cold and pulled at the collar of Sarah's coat.

Coats pulled his cruiser to the side of the road and got out and stood for a moment with his hand on the roof of the car, looking at the house. Sarah parked behind him and did the same. The two of them stood there in the road, and the wind came down off the ridge and moved through the bare branches, and the branches made a sound that was almost like breathing, in and out, in and out, and Sarah told herself it was the wind.

"She's expecting us," Coats said. "I called from the school. Took her a while to get to the phone." He took off his hat and held it against his chest, the way a man does when he is about to do something he does not want to do. "Let me do the talking at first. She's got a way of going sideways on you if she doesn't like the shape of a conversation."

"Sideways how?"

"She'll start telling you about something that happened in 1948 and you'll think she's lost the thread and then about ten minutes later you'll realize she was answering your question the whole time, you just weren't listening right."

They went up the walk. The flagstones were heaved and cracked by roots, and the grass that grew in the cracks was the pale dead grass of November, and there were no footsteps in it but their own. The porch steps complained under Coats's weight and complained again under Sarah's. The door had a brass knocker shaped like a hand, and Coats lifted the hand and let it fall three times, and the sound went into the house and came back hollow.

The door opened on a chain, six inches, and in the gap was the face of a woman who was not ninety years old.

Sarah had been expecting something. She had expected a shawl and a rocking chair and the smell of camphor and a mind gone soft at the edges. What she got was a woman standing very straight in a gray dress with her white hair pinned back from a face that was all bone and no give, and eyes that were the pale blue of January ice and just as warm, and those eyes went over Coats first and dismissed him and then went over Sarah and did not dismiss her.

"You're the schoolteacher," Mrs. Thorne said. It was not a question.

"I'm Sarah Grey."

"I know who you are. Your mother was Ellen Grey and she was a fool and she's dead now, and I'm sorry for it, and it doesn't change the fact that she was a fool." The chain rattled and the door swung wide. "Come in before you let the cold in. The cold up here has opinions."

The inside of the house was warmer than the outside by a margin that felt deliberate, as though the walls had been built to hold heat the way a hand holds water. There was a kitchen at the back with a woodstove throwing orange light on the ceiling, and there was a table in the middle of the room with three chairs around it, and the table was set with three cups and a pot of tea that was still steaming, and Sarah wondered how long the woman had been standing at the window watching the road.

"Sit," Mrs. Thorne said. "Both of you. Coats, you can put your hat on the table, it won't bite you, and you can stop looking at me like a dog that's been kicked. I know why you're here. Sit down."

They sat. Mrs. Thorne poured the tea. Her hands did not shake. She poured it the way a woman pours tea who has poured tea for ninety years and sees no reason to stop now, and the tea was black and bitter and Sarah drank it because it was warm and because she did not know what else to do with her hands.

"Now," Mrs. Thorne said, and sat down across from them, and folded her hands on the table. "You've come about the children. The ones that have gone missing. And the others before them, going back, going back." Her eyes went to Sarah. "How many now? Six? Seven?"

"Six," Coats said. "In the last three weeks. And a man from the logging crew, and a dog, and —"

"And you want me to tell you what to do about it." Mrs. Thorne's mouth did something that was not a smile. "Nobody's asked me what to do about it in forty years. They ask me about my hip. They ask me if I need anything from the store. Nobody asks me about the Hollow, because they don't want to hear the answer, and because they think I'm old and I've lost my mind, and because the ones who remember are dead and the ones who are alive have decided it's easier to forget." She picked up her cup and drank and set it down. "But you're here now. So. Ask."

Coats looked at the table. He looked at his hat. He looked at Sarah, and there was something in his face she had not seen there before, something that was not tiredness and not drink and was closer to fear than either.

"Tell her the rules," he said. "Tell her the way you told me. The whole of it. Not the church version. Not the version they teach the kids in Sunday school. The real one."

Mrs. Thorne looked at him for a long moment. Then she looked at Sarah, and her eyes were very steady, and very cold, and very old.

"The rules," she said. "All right. There are three of them, and they are not suggestions, and they are not superstitions, and they are not the kind of thing you can decide not to believe in and be safe from. You can decide not to believe in a stove and put your hand on it and it will burn you all the same. That's the first thing you have to understand, Sarah Grey. Belief has nothing to do with it. The rules are not a religion. They're a description of how things work, the way it's a description of how things work that water runs downhill. You can believe water runs uphill all you like. You'll still drown."

"I don't believe in —" Sarah started, and stopped, because Mrs. Thorne's eyes had come up and gone into her and there was no give in them at all.

"I know you don't," Mrs. Thorne said. "You're Ellen Grey's girl and Ellen Grey didn't believe in anything she couldn't put in a pie. That's why I'm telling you the way I'm telling you. Because you're going to want to argue with me, and I want you to understand that arguing is not one of the things the Hollow cares about. It doesn't care what you believe. It cares what you do. Now." She set her cup down with a click. "The first rule."

She held up one finger. The nail was clean and trimmed and the knuckle was swollen with arthritis and she held it up anyway, steady.

"Nobody goes into the Hollow after dark. Nobody. Not a man, not a woman, not a child, not a dog, not a horse, not a bird on a string. When the sun goes down, the Hollow is not yours anymore. It belongs to the other thing. And the other thing does not want you in it, and it will deal with you the way it deals with anything that comes into its house uninvited. Do you understand what I'm telling you?"

"I understand what you're saying."

"That's not the same thing. But it's a start." Mrs. Thorne lowered her finger. "The second rule. If the Hollow calls a name, you don't answer. You don't answer, you don't turn around, you don't say 'what,' you don't say 'who's there,' you don't even think the name back to yourself, because it can hear you thinking it, and thinking it is close enough to saying it. You walk. You walk and you don't run, because running is an answer too, running is the body saying yes, and you keep your eyes on the road in front of you and you get home and you shut your door and you don't open it again until the sun is up. Do you understand?"

"What does it —" Sarah began.

"I said, do you understand."

"Yes. I understand."

"The third rule." Mrs. Thorne held up three fingers now, and her hand was not quite steady anymore, and Sarah saw it and Coats saw it and neither of them said anything. "You don't take anything out. Nothing. Not a leaf, not a stone, not a twig, not a feather, not a flower, not a mushroom, not a cup of water from the stream, not a handful of dirt. Whatever's in the Hollow stays in the Hollow. If you go in — and you shouldn't, and you won't, but if you do — you go in with your hands empty and you come out with your hands empty, and if you find something in your pocket you didn't put there, you don't bring it home. You put it down where you found it and you walk away and you don't look back. That's the third rule. That's the one that matters most. That's the one that's been broken."

The stove ticked. The wind came down off the ridge and pushed at the windows and the glass rattled in its old frames, and somewhere out in the barn the iron rooster did not crow.

"Broken how?" Coats said. His voice was quiet. "I've been sheriff here eleven years. I've never taken anything out. My deputies —"

"It's not you." Mrs. Thorne's eyes were on Sarah now, and they did not move. "It's not the men in the woods. Men in the woods don't pick things up, they're too busy being afraid. It's the children. It's always the children. They find something pretty and they put it in their pocket and they bring it home and they don't know what they've done and they don't tell anyone because they think they'll be in trouble, and then —" She stopped. She picked up her tea and her hand was shaking now and she set it down again without drinking. "Then the Hollow comes to collect what's its. And it doesn't come politely. It comes the way a river comes when you've dammed it wrong. It comes and it takes, and it doesn't stop at taking back what was taken. It takes the whole house. It takes the whole family. It takes and it takes and it takes until the debt is paid, and the debt is never just the thing you took, the debt is interest too, the debt is the thing you took and everything it touched while it was in your house."

Sarah's mouth was dry. She thought about the refrigerator at home. She thought about the drawing. She thought about the little figure in the trees and the words underneath that Lily had written, the words that Sarah had told herself meant nothing, the words she had not let herself read all the way to the end.

"Mrs. Thorne," she said. "What happens if you break a rule?"

Mrs. Thorne looked at her for a long time. The fire in the stove moved and the shadows moved with it and for a moment the old woman's face was not a face but a shape in the dark, a thing made of bone and patience and ninety years of knowing something she had never been able to say out loud.

"You're asking me what happens if you break a rule," she said. "And I'm telling you that the rules are not a fence. They're not a fence you can climb over and get scratched by. They're a description of the edge of a cliff. If you walk off the edge of a cliff, you don't get in trouble. You fall. There's no one to be in trouble with. There's just the falling, and the ground, and what's left after. Do you understand what I'm telling you?"

"I understand that you're not answering the question."

"Because there's no answer that would help you. Because if I told you what happens, you'd think, well, that's not so bad, that's a thing I could survive, that's a thing I could fix. And it's not. There's no fixing it. There's no surviving it. There's just the not doing it." Mrs. Thorne leaned forward, and her voice dropped, and it was not the voice of a ninety-year-old woman anymore, it was the voice of a woman who had been afraid for a very long time and had learned to be afraid quietly. "I have seen what comes back from the Hollow when the rules are broken. I have seen it with my own eyes, in this town, in my own lifetime. I have seen a man walk out of those trees with his face on wrong and his voice coming out of the wrong part of him, and he was my neighbor, and he was not my neighbor anymore. And I will not tell you the details because the details are not the point. The point is the rule. The point is the not doing it. The point is that you keep your child out of those trees and you keep her hands empty and you teach her the rules before she's old enough to break them by accident, because that's the way it happens, Sarah Grey. It doesn't happen to people who are wicked. It happens to people who are careless. It happens to children who find something pretty."

The silence in the kitchen was the silence of a held breath. Coats had not touched his tea. His hat sat on the table in front of him and his hands were flat on either side of it and his knuckles were white.

"Mrs. Thorne," Sarah said, and her voice came out steadier than she felt. "Lily has a drawing. It's been on our refrigerator for a week. It's a picture of the trees and there's a little figure in the trees and there are words underneath. I didn't read the words. I told myself it was just a drawing. I told myself —"

"Read the words," Mrs. Thorne said.

"I'm afraid to."

"I know you are. Read them anyway. Tonight. Before you go to sleep. And if there's anything in your house that Lily brought home from the woods — anything at all, a stone, a leaf, a feather, a piece of string, anything — you take it out and you put it back where it came from, and you do it in the daylight, and you do it with your eyes open, and you do not stop to think about it. Do you hear me? In the daylight. With your eyes open. And you don't go past the first line of trees. You set it down at the edge and you walk away and you don't look back and you don't say a word, not one word, not even to yourself."

"There's nothing in the house," Sarah said. "I would have seen it. I clean the house, I —"

"There's always something. You just don't know what to look for." Mrs. Thorne pushed her chair back and stood, and she was not steady on her feet, and she put her hand on the table to steady herself, and Coats half-rose to help her and she waved him back with a look. "You think a thing from the Hollow looks like a thing from the Hollow. It doesn't. It looks like a pretty rock. It looks like a bird's egg. It looks like a picture your child drew on a Tuesday afternoon because she wanted to draw a picture. The Hollow doesn't announce itself. That's how it gets in. It gets in through the ordinary. It gets in through the things you don't think to be afraid of."

She walked to the window and looked out at the bare trees and the road going down the ridge and the light that was the color of weak tea and getting weaker.

"Dark in two hours," she said. "You should go. You don't want to be on that road after dark, and that's not a superstition, that's the first rule and you can apply it to the road as well as to the trees, because the road goes through the trees and the trees don't care where the road is." She turned back. "Coats. You've been sheriff here eleven years and you've kept the rules and you've kept your mouth shut and you've kept this town from burning itself down, and I know what it's cost you. I know what you saw. I know you don't talk about it. You don't have to talk about it with me. But you listen to me now. This is not a thing you can arrest. This is not a thing you can put in a cell and feed three times a day. This is a thing you can only keep out, and keeping it out means keeping the rules, and keeping the rules means making sure the whole town keeps them, and that means telling them the truth whether they want to hear it or not. You understand?"

"I understand," Coats said.

"Do you? Because you've been telling them it's a search. You've been telling them it's a search for missing children and the children are just lost in the woods and they'll be found. And maybe they will. Maybe some of them will. But that's not what's happening, and every day you tell them it's a search is a day they don't know the rules, and every day they don't know the rules is a day a child finds something pretty and puts it in her pocket." Mrs. Thorne's voice cracked, just once, and she pressed her lips together and was silent for a moment and then went on. "I'm ninety years old. I've got maybe a year left, maybe two, and most of it I'll spend forgetting my own name. When I'm gone there won't be anyone left who knows the whole of it. So you tell them. You tell them the rules and you don't tell them it's a search, and if they don't believe you —" She shrugged. "Then they don't believe you. But you'll have told them. And when it happens, and it will happen, they won't be able to say nobody warned them."

Coats stood. He put his hat on. He looked at the old woman and she looked back at him and something passed between them that Sarah could not read, something that had been there a long time and would be there until one of them was gone.

"I'll tell them," he said.

"See that you do." Mrs. Thorne turned to Sarah. "And you. Read the words. Tonight. And you come back and see me tomorrow and tell me what they said, because I'll want to know, and because you'll want to tell someone who believes you." She paused. "You've got your mother's stubbornness and you've got your mother's eyes and I didn't think much of your mother, but I think more of you. Don't prove me wrong."

Sarah stood. Her legs were not quite steady and she did not know why. She had come up here expecting an old woman's superstitions and she was leaving with something that sat in her chest like a stone.

"Mrs. Thorne," she said. "The thing in the Hollow. What is it?"

Mrs. Thorne looked at her. The firelight moved on her face and her eyes were January ice and they did not blink.

"It's the Hollow," she said. "That's all. That's the whole of it. It's not a creature and it's not a ghost and it's not the devil and it's not a god. It's the Hollow, and the Hollow is old, older than the town, older than the trees, older than the mountains, and it does what it does because that's what it does, and there's no reasoning with it and no bargaining with it and no praying to it. There's only the rules. There's only keeping out of its way and keeping your hands empty and keeping your mouth shut when it calls your name." She opened the door. The cold came in. "Now go. Before the light goes. And Sarah —"

Sarah turned in the doorway.

"When it calls your name," Mrs. Thorne said, "and it will, because you're in it now, you're in it the way your mother was in it and the way I've been in it for ninety years — when it calls your name, it won't sound like a monster. It'll sound like someone you love. That's the trick of it. That's the thing nobody tells you. It'll sound like your mother, or your husband, or your child, and it'll call you by the name only they call you by, and it'll be so close to right that you'll want to answer. Don't. You walk. You keep walking and you don't look back and you don't answer, and you get home, and you shut the door, and you wait for the sun." She stepped back into the dark of the house. "That's all I know. That's all anyone knows. God help us all if it's not enough."

The door closed. The chain rattled. The brass hand hung still on the wood and did not knock again.

---

They drove down the ridge in silence, Coats ahead and Sarah behind, and the light went from weak tea to gray to the color of old dishwater, and the trees pressed close on either side of the road and the branches overhead made a tunnel that got darker with every turn of the wheels. Sarah kept her eyes on Coats's taillights. She did not look at the trees. She did not look at the spaces between the trees. She did not think about the way the branches had made a sound like breathing, in and out, in and out, and she did not think about the words on Lily's drawing, and she did not think about the third rule, and she did not think about the thing in her daughter's room that she had not known to look for.

She thought about it anyway. That was the thing about thoughts. You could tell yourself not to have them and they came anyway, the way water came under a door.

At the bottom of the ridge the road met the paved road and the trees pulled back and the sky opened up and there was still a little light in it, a thin band of orange along the western edge of things, and Sarah let out a breath she had not known she was holding. Coats pulled over onto the shoulder and got out and she pulled over behind him and got out and the two of them stood in the road in the last of the light and looked at each other.

"Your hands are shaking," Coats said.

"I know." Sarah put her hands in her pockets. "Yours aren't."

"I've had longer to get used to it." He took out a cigarette and lit it and the smoke went up into the cold air and hung there. "I'm going to tell you what I know. Not what she told you. What I know. From being here. From seeing the things I've seen. You can take it or leave it and I won't think less of you either way, but you asked me once why I don't go into the Hollow and I'm going to tell you now and you're going to listen."

"I'm listening."

Coats took a long drag and let it out slow. The cigarette glowed orange in the gray and it was the brightest thing in the world for a moment.

"The rules she gave you are the rules. She's right about all of it. But there's a fourth one she didn't say and I don't know if she didn't say it because she doesn't know it or because she couldn't bring herself to say it in front of you, and it's this: it learns. Whatever's in there, it learns. It learns the way a child learns or a dog learns. It learns what works and it does more of it. When I first came here it was just the trees and the dark and the missing. Nobody heard voices. Nobody saw things at the edge of the yard. It just took and it was done and if you kept the rules you were safe. But it's been learning. It's been learning for eleven years and it's been learning faster lately, and now it doesn't just take. Now it calls. Now it wears. Now it comes out of the trees and it stands in the yard and it looks like somebody you know and it says something only that person would say and it waits for you to make a mistake." He flicked the cigarette into the road and stepped on it. "That's what's changed. That's why the pact is breaking. Not because we broke a rule. Because it learned a new way to make us break one."

Sarah's mouth was dry again. "The children. The ones who've gone missing. You think —"

"I think some of them are lost in the woods and I think some of them are not lost at all and I think the ones that are not lost are the ones we're never going to find, and I think the worst thing I can do is tell their parents that." Coats's voice was flat and tired and there was something underneath it that was not tired at all. "I've got a list in my head of every person who's gone into that Hollow in the eleven years I've been sheriff. It's not a long list. It's nine names. Six of them are the children from the last three weeks. The other three are from before, and one of them was my deputy, and one of them was a woman I went to school with, and one of them was a man I drank with every Friday for six years and I never once asked him why he went in because I already knew and I didn't want to hear it." He looked at her. "You want to know what happens when you break a rule. I'll tell you what I know. I know that three people went into that Hollow and didn't come out the way they went in, and I know that two of them came back and one of them didn't, and I know that the two who came back were not the same people who went in. One of them left town a year later and I get a postcard from her every Christmas from a town in Arizona and the postcard never says anything but 'I'm fine' and the handwriting is wrong. The other one is still here. He lives out on the county road and he doesn't talk to anybody and he doesn't come into town and when I drive past his house at night the lights are on in every window and he's standing in one of them looking out. Every window. All night. I've never seen him sleep."

"What happened to him?"

"I don't know. I asked him once. I asked him what he saw in there and he looked at me and he said, 'It wasn't what I saw. It was what it saw.' And then he closed the door." Coats put his hat on. "That's the fourth rule, Sarah. It learns. It watches. It remembers. And the more it remembers the better it gets at being the thing you'll answer to." He walked back to his car and opened the door and stood with his hand on it. "Go home. Read the drawing. Look through your daughter's room and find whatever she brought back and take it out tomorrow in the daylight and put it at the edge of the trees and walk away. And then you come find me and we'll figure out what's next. But don't wait. The longer a thing from the Hollow is in your house the more it belongs to you and the more you belong to it, and I've seen what that looks like and I'm not going to let it happen to Lily."

He got in the car and started the engine and the headlights came on and cut two white tunnels through the gray, and Sarah stood in the road and watched him pull away and the taillights go small and red and then gone around the bend. The last of the light went with him. The sky was gray and then darker gray and then the color of a bruise, and the trees on either side of the road stood very still, and the wind had stopped, and the silence that came down was the silence of a held breath and it went on and on and did not break.

Sarah got in her car. She drove home. She did not look in the rearview mirror. She did not look at the trees. She told herself she was not afraid and she knew she was lying, and she kept her hands on the wheel and her eyes on the road and she did not answer when, somewhere behind her in the dark between the trees, something that sounded like her mother called her name.

---

The house was warm and the lights were on and Lily was at the kitchen table doing her homework with her tongue between her teeth, and Sarah stood in the doorway and looked at her daughter and felt the fear in her chest turn over and show its other face, which was love, which was the same thing seen from a different angle.

"Mom?" Lily looked up. "You're late. Mrs. Paulsen made me dinner. It was spaghetti. It was okay."

"I know. I'm sorry." Sarah hung up her coat. "I had to go see someone with Sheriff Coats."

"About the missing kids?"

"Yes."

"Did you find them?"

"No." Sarah came to the table and sat down across from her daughter. "Not yet. Lily, I need to ask you something and I need you to tell me the truth. You're not in trouble. No matter what the answer is, you're not in trouble. Do you understand?"

Lily's eyes got wide and wary, the way a child's eyes do when an adult says you're not in trouble, because a child knows that you're not in trouble is what people say right before you are. But she nodded.

"The drawing on the refrigerator," Sarah said. "The one with the trees. Did you draw it from something you saw?"

Lily looked at the table. She looked at her homework. She looked at her hands.

"I drew it from the woods," she said. "I saw them when we were driving home from school. The trees were doing something."

"Doing what?"

"They were moving. Not like wind. Like —" Lily made a shape with her hands, a shape that meant nothing and everything. "Like they were talking to each other. And there was a little thing in there. A little shiny thing. And I wanted to look at it but I didn't go in, Mom, I promise I didn't go in, I know the rules, everybody knows the rules, you don't go in the woods after dark and you don't —"

"What rules?" Sarah said. Her voice was very quiet. "Lily. What rules?"

Lily looked at her. The kitchen light was on overhead and it made her face very clear and very young and very serious.

"The rules about the Hollow," she said. "The ones the kids tell. You don't go in after dark and you don't answer if it calls your name and you don't take anything out." She paused. "And you don't tell grown-ups, because grown-ups don't believe you and then they get mad."

Sarah sat very still. The refrigerator hummed. The clock on the wall ticked. Somewhere in the house a pipe knocked and was still.

"Lily," she said. "Did you bring anything out of the woods? Anything at all. A rock, a leaf, a — anything. It's okay if you did. You're not in trouble. But I need to know."

Lily's face did something complicated. She looked at the refrigerator and then at her mother and then at her hands again.

"There's a rock," she said. "It's in my room. It's pretty. It's got a hole in it and you can see through the hole and when you look through the hole you can see —" She stopped. "I don't want to say what you can see."

"Where did you get it?"

"At the edge of the schoolyard. By the trees. It was just sitting there. It was sitting there like it was waiting for me."

Sarah stood up. Her legs were not steady but they held her. "Show me."

They went up the stairs together, Lily first and Sarah behind, and the hallway light was on and the doors were closed and the house was warm and ordinary and safe, and Sarah thought about the third rule, and about the thing waiting at the edge of the schoolyard, and about how it got in through the ordinary, how it got in through the things you didn't think to be afraid of, and she thought: it was waiting for her. It was sitting there like it was waiting for her.

Lily's room was small and neat and pink, and there was a bed with a quilt and a desk with a lamp and a shelf with books and a window with the curtain drawn, and on the windowsill there was a rock.

It was the size of a plum. It was gray and smooth and it had a hole worn through the middle of it, a perfect circle, and the light from the lamp went through the hole and made a small round shadow on the wall, and the shadow was not the same shape as the hole.

Sarah looked at the shadow. She looked at it for a long time. The shadow was the shape of a small round room with a door, and in the door there was a figure, and the figure was very small and very still and it was facing the wrong way, and as she watched, it turned around.

"Mom?" Lily's voice came from a long way off. "Mom, you're scaring me."

Sarah reached out and picked up the rock. It was cold. It was colder than a rock should be, colder than the windowsill, colder than the room, and the cold went up her arm and into her chest and settled there like something that had been looking for a place to stay.

"Get your coat," she said. "We're going out."

"It's dark."

"I know. We're not going into the woods. We're going to the edge of the yard. We're going to put this where it came from and we're going to come back inside and we're going to lock the door." Sarah's voice was steady and she did not know how. "And then we're going to read the words on your drawing. All of them. Out loud. Together."

Lily's eyes were wide and her face was white and she was eight years old and she was more afraid than any child should have to be, and she nodded, and she got her coat.

They went down the stairs and out the back door and across the yard, and the yard was dark and the grass was crisp with frost and the sky overhead was clear and cold and full of stars, and at the edge of the yard the trees began. They stood in a line, the trees, and they were very still, and the dark between them was not the dark of a moonless night, it was a different dark, it was a dark that had a shape to it, a dark that was looking back.

Sarah walked to the edge of the yard with the rock in her hand and she did not go past the first line of trees. She set the rock down on the ground where the grass met the roots and she stood up and she took Lily's hand and she turned around and she walked back to the house and she did not look back and she did not say a word.

Behind her, in the trees, something made a sound.

It was not a word. It was the beginning of a word, the shape of a word, a word that started with an S and was almost her name, and it was almost her mother's voice, and it was almost right.

She kept walking. She kept her eyes on the house and her hand on her daughter's hand and she kept walking, and the door was there and the light was there and she opened the door and pushed Lily through it and stepped through herself and shut the door and locked it, and then she stood with her back against the door and her eyes closed and she breathed.

"That was the first rule," Lily said, in a small voice. "And the second one. You didn't answer."

"That was the second rule," Sarah said. "And the third one. We put it back."

"Mom." Lily's voice was very small. "You didn't put it back where it came from. You put it at the edge. It came from the schoolyard."

Sarah opened her eyes. She looked at her daughter. She thought about what Mrs. Thorne had said, about the rules being a description of the edge of a cliff, and about the things that happened to people who were careless, and about the way the Hollow learned.

"It's close enough," she said. "It's close enough for tonight."

They went into the kitchen and Sarah took the drawing down off the refrigerator and laid it on the table under the light. The trees were there, the dark trees, and the little figure was there, small and still and facing the wrong way. And underneath, in Lily's careful eight-year-old handwriting, were the words that Sarah had not let herself read, the words she had known were there and had told herself meant nothing.

She read them out loud. Her voice was steady and it did not shake and she read them the way she read to her class, clearly and slowly and all the way to the end.

The words said: IT WANTS TO BE INVITED. DON'T SAY ITS NAME.

Sarah looked at the words. She looked at the trees. She looked at the little figure facing the wrong way, and she thought about the shadow on the wall, and the small round room, and the door, and the figure in the door turning around.

"Mom," Lily said. "What does it mean?"

Sarah folded the drawing in half and then in half again and then she put it in the pocket of her coat and she looked at her daughter and she made herself smile.

"It means we're going to be very careful," she said. "It means we're going to keep the rules."

Outside, in the dark, at the edge of the yard, in the trees, the thing that had almost called her name settled in to wait. It had been patient for a hundred and fifty years. It could be patient a little longer.

It had learned the shape