The Gaps
The knocker was a hand.
Not a hand that had been cast or carved to look like a hand, not stylized, not decorative. A hand, or the brass shape of one, fingers curled and thumb set against the middle finger the way a person knocks when they are impatient, and it had been polished by decades of other hands closing over it, so that the knuckles shone and the nails were worn smooth. Sarah looked at it for a moment too long. Coats looked at it too, and then he looked away, and she understood that he had looked at it many times before and had made his peace with it the way a man makes his peace with a thing he cannot change.
He lifted it and let it fall. Three times. The sound went into the house and did not come back out.
They waited. The wind came down off the ridge and worried at the bare branches and the branches made that sound again, in and out, and Sarah kept her eyes on the door and did not look at the trees.
It took a long time. Coats knocked a second time, and then they heard something inside, a slow shuffle, the sound of a walker being lifted and set down, lifted and set down, and then a bolt being drawn back, and then another, and then a chain, and the door opened the width of the chain and a face looked out at them from the dark of the house.
Old Mrs. Thorne was ninety years old and she looked like something the weather had been working on for a very long time. Her face was all ridges and hollows, and her eyes were the pale blue of a sky in winter, and they were not clouded, they were not wandering. They went from Coats to Sarah and back to Coats and they knew both of them.
"Sheriff," she said. Her voice was thin and dry, like a page turning. "You brought the schoolteacher."
"I did, ma'am. You remember Sarah Grey. Ruth Grey's girl."
"I remember." The old woman looked at Sarah through the gap in the door, and something moved in her face, something that was not quite recognition and not quite grief, a flicker of an old, old fear being taken out and turned over. "You've got your mother's chin. She had a stubborn chin. It didn't do her any good in the end."
"Ma'am," Coats said, "we'd like to come in and talk to you a while, if you're willing."
Mrs. Thorne did not move. The chain held the door where it was. Behind her the house was dark and smelled of woodsmoke and cold and something else, something that might have been camphor or might have been the smell of a house where an old person lives alone and the rooms they do not use have been closed up for years.
"You've come about the Hollow," she said.
"Yes, ma'am."
"You've come because it's waking up."
"Yes, ma'am," Coats said again, and his voice was very quiet.
The old woman was silent for a moment. The wind came around the corner of the porch and pushed at the door and the chain pulled taut and she leaned her weight against it, a small old woman in a cardigan the color of oatmeal, holding a door against the wind.
"It was never asleep," she said. "That's the lie we told. We told it so long we believed it. It was never asleep. It was only waiting. There's a difference, and the difference is everything, and no one remembers it anymore because I'm the only one left and I'm going." She looked at Sarah again. "Come in, then. Both of you. Wipe your feet. And don't look at the pictures in the hall."
---
The parlor was small and warm and crowded with things. There was a woodstove with a fire in it and a kettle on top of the stove and two chairs drawn up close to the heat. There were doilies on the arms of the chairs and a crocheted blanket folded on the back of one of them. There were photographs on the mantel and photographs on the walls, and Sarah tried not to look at them and looked at them anyway, the way you look at a thing you have been told not to look at, and they were only photographs, families and farms and faces out of the last century, and she could not have said why the old woman had warned them.
There was a clock on the mantel that had stopped at four minutes past three, and no one had wound it, and the room was very quiet except for the fire.
"Sit," Mrs. Thorne said. "Sit down. I'll make tea and then I'll tell you what you came to hear, and then you'll go, and I'll sit here and I'll listen to the trees, because that's what I do now. That's all I do now. I sit and I listen to the trees and I know what they're saying and no one else does."
Coats sat. Sarah sat. The old woman filled the kettle from a pitcher and set it back on the stove and lowered herself into the other chair with the careful, joint-by-joint motion of a body that had stopped being a friend to her some years ago.
"You want to know about the pact," she said.
"We want to know what's happening," Coats said. "We want to know how to stop it."
"You can't stop it. You can only keep it. That's what a pact is. You keep it or you break it, and it holds or it doesn't, and there's no stopping. There's only keeping." She looked into the fire. "My father kept it. His father kept it. It goes back to before the town, before the church, before the road. There were people here before there was a town and they knew, and they made the first keeping, and we have kept it after them, and we have kept it badly, because a thing kept badly is still kept, and we did not understand what we were keeping, not really, not ever, not since the first ones."
"What is it?" Sarah asked. "What's in the Hollow?"
The old woman turned her pale eyes on Sarah and for a moment she did not look old at all. She looked like a woman who had been carrying something heavy for a very long time and had just been asked if she would like to put it down.
"It's a mouth," she said. "That's the closest word I have. It's a mouth that is also a memory, or a memory that is also a mouth, and it eats what you remember and it remembers what it eats, and it has been hungry since before the town and it will be hungry after, and the only thing we ever had to give it was the keeping." She paused. "The keeping is this. We do not go in after dark. We do not speak of it as a living thing. We do not go looking for the ones it takes. And it leaves us alone. That's all. That's the whole of it. Three rules and a silence, and my father taught them to me and his father taught them to him and somewhere back before that someone taught them and they were not written down because writing is a kind of speaking and speaking is a kind of invitation."
"That's it?" Coats said. "That's the pact?"
"That's the pact."
"And people have been breaking it."
"People have been forgetting it," the old woman said, and her voice was sharp. "Breaking is one thing. A boy goes in on a dare and comes out with his memory gone, that's breaking, that's a trespass and it's punished and it's done. Forgetting is another thing. Forgetting is when the rules stop being rules and start being stories, and stories don't hold anything back. Stories are how the Hollow gets in. Every time someone tells the story of the girl who went in and came back wrong, they're speaking of it as a living thing, and every time they do that they open the door a little wider and they let it out a little further, and now the whole town tells the stories and the whole town has forgotten the rules and the door is open and it is not going to close itself."
The kettle began to rattle on the stove. Mrs. Thorne did not get up to see to it. She sat where she was and looked into the fire and her hands were trembling in her lap, and Sarah understood that the trembling was not age.
"Something happened last night," Coats said. "Something new."
"Yes," the old woman said. "I heard it. I hear everything up here. The trees told me."
"What did they tell you?"
"That something came back that should not have come back, and something went out that should not have gone out, and the Hollow is wearing a new face and the face is one of ours." She looked at Coats. "You know what I mean, Sheriff. You've seen it. You've seen it and you've drunk it down and you haven't said a word to anyone, and that's the only wisdom you've got, and it won't save you."
Coats did not answer. His hat was on his knee and he was turning it around and around in his hands, and his face had gone the color of the ash in the stove.
The kettle screamed. Sarah got up and took it off the heat and found the tea things on the counter by the sink, a brown pot and three cups, and she made the tea because no one else was going to, and her hands were steady and her heart was not. She set the cups on the little table between the chairs. The old woman took hers and held it and did not drink.
"Tell me about the girl," Sarah said. "The one who came back. Tell me what the stories say."
"The stories say she came back and she was not the same," Mrs. Thorne said. "Her name was Ellen Marsh and she was twelve years old and she went in on a dare in the summer of 1911 and she came out three days later and she was not the same. She did not remember her mother. She did not remember her own name. She remembered things that had not happened yet, or things that had happened to other people, or things that had never happened at all, and she would tell them in a voice that was not quite her voice, and the town kept her for a while because she was a child and because they did not know what else to do, and then one night she walked back into the Hollow and she did not come out again, and the town stopped telling her story because the telling made it worse." She looked at Sarah over the rim of her cup. "But they started telling it again. Didn't they. They always start again."
Sarah thought of the playground. She thought of the children on the blacktop at recess, the circle of them, the rhyme they chanted with their hands joined and their faces turned up. She thought of Lily coming home with pine needles in her hair.
"They're singing something," she said. "The children at the school. A rhyme. About the Hollow."
The old woman closed her eyes.
"Say it," she said.
"I don't know it all. It's — there's a part about the trees, and a part about the dark, and a part about someone who goes in and comes back and doesn't know their name."
"Yes," Mrs. Thorne said. "That's the one. They've been singing that rhyme in this valley for a hundred years and longer, and every generation thinks they made it up, and every generation is wrong, and every time it's sung it opens the door a little wider. That's what the Hollow does, girl. It doesn't take you in the night like a wolf. It teaches you a song. It teaches you a song and you teach it to your children and your children teach it to theirs and pretty soon the whole valley is singing and the door is wide open and no one remembers there was ever a door at all."
"Then we stop singing it," Sarah said. "We tell the children to stop."
"It's too late for that. It's been sung. It's in the air now, it's in the walls of the school, it's in the water. You can't un-sing a song. You can only sing a different one, and no one remembers a different one, because the only ones who knew it are dead and I'm the last and I'm going." The old woman set her cup down. It rattled in the saucer. "I'm going," she said again, and for the first time her voice cracked, and Sarah saw the fear in her, sharp and bright and young, a fear that had been waiting inside her for eighty years and had never once gotten smaller. "I'm the last one who knows the keeping and I'm going and when I go there's no one left who knows the rules, and then it will be free, and it will not stop at the edge of the trees."
The fire popped. The wind pressed at the windows. Coats sat with his hat in his hands and did not look at either of them.
"Mrs. Thorne," Sarah said. "What happened to your father?"
The old woman looked at her for a long time.
"He kept it," she said at last. "He kept it all his life. And when he was old he went out one evening to bring in the cows and he did not come back, and the cows came in without him, all of them, single file, and they stood in the barn and they would not eat. I was twelve years old. I went out to the edge of the trees and I called for him and the trees were quiet, and I stood there a long time and I knew I could go in and I did not go in, and that was the keeping. That was the whole of the keeping, one girl at the edge of the trees deciding not to go in, and it held. It held for sixty years." She looked at the fire. "I don't know if it will hold now."
---
They were on the road back down the ridge, Coats's cruiser ahead and Sarah's car behind, when the radio in the cruiser crackled and a voice came through, and Sarah could not hear the words but she heard the tone, and she saw Coats's shoulders come up and his head come around, and then he pulled the cruiser to the side of the road and stopped and she stopped behind him and he got out.
"What is it?" she said.
"Search party found somebody," he said. He was already reaching for the radio on his shoulder. "One of the volunteers. Fellow named Hollis. He came walking out of the trees on the north side, just walked out like it was nothing, and he's sitting on the tailgate of a truck right now and he won't say a word." He pressed the button. "This is Coats. I'm on my way. Don't let him leave. Don't let anyone talk to him until I get there. You hear me? Nobody."
The radio crackled back. Coats got in the cruiser and pulled out and Sarah followed, and the road came down off the ridge and turned and the trees closed in on both sides, close and dark and quiet, and Sarah drove with her hands tight on the wheel and did not look at them.
---
The command post was in the parking lot of the fire station. There were trucks and cruisers and a folding table with a thermos and a map on it, and there were maybe thirty people standing around in their heavy coats with their hands in their pockets, and the light was the gray light of a November afternoon that never quite gets going and never quite ends. They had been out since dawn. They were looking for a boy named Petey Marsh, who was nine years old and who had been missing for two days, and who was, Sarah had learned that morning, the great-grandson of Ellen Marsh, the girl who had gone into the Hollow in 1911 and come back wrong and gone in again.
The town had not stopped telling that story after all. It had just changed the names.
Hollis was sitting on the tailgate of a green pickup at the far end of the lot, apart from the others, with a blanket around his shoulders that someone had given him. He was a big man, forty or so, with a broad red face and a beard that needed trimming, and he was wearing hunting camo and heavy boots and a cap that had been pushed back on his head. He was staring at the asphalt between his feet. There were pine needles in his hair, and pine needles on the shoulders of his coat, and a few on the blanket, and they were green and fresh, as though he had been standing under a pine tree that very morning.
Coats walked over to him. Sarah stayed back by the table, but she was close enough to hear, and no one told her to go.
"Hollis," Coats said. "It's Dan Coats."
Hollis looked up. His eyes were the eyes of a man who had been woken out of a deep sleep and had not yet worked out where he was. He looked at Coats and then past him, at the lot, at the trucks and the people and the gray sky, and something moved in his face, a slow, dull confusion.
"Sheriff," he said. His voice was hoarse. "What — am I — is it morning?"
"It's afternoon, Hollis. It's about three o'clock."
"Three." Hollis looked down at his hands. He turned them over. There was dirt under his nails and a scratch on the back of one hand, a scratch that had already scabbed. "I don't — we went out at first light. We were going to walk the north edge, me and the Boyers, and then —" He stopped.
"And then what?"
"And then I don't know." He said it slowly, as though he were reading it off a page he could not quite see. "I don't know. I was walking and then I was walking. That's all I've got. I was on the north edge and then I was on the north edge and there was a gap in between and the gap was —" He looked up at Coats, and now there was something in his eyes that had not been there before, something that was trying to be fear and could not quite get there. "How long?"
"A while," Coats said. "A couple of hours, maybe."
"Two hours." Hollis said it flatly. "Two hours." He looked at the pine needles on his sleeve. He picked one off and held it up and looked at it, a green needle, fresh, and he looked at it the way a man looks at a thing he has never seen before. "Where'd I get this?"
"Where do you think?"
"I don't think anything. That's what I'm telling you. There's nothing there. There's a gap and then there's me standing at the edge of the trees and the Boyers yelling my name from about a hundred yards off, and that's it. That's the whole of it." He looked at Coats and his face was working now, the way a face works when a man is trying to hold something in. "I don't remember walking out. I don't remember getting to the edge. I don't remember anything between the first hour and the Boyers finding me."
Coats was quiet for a moment. Then he said, very gently, "What's your wife's name, Hollis?"
Hollis opened his mouth.
Then he closed it.
Sarah watched his face. She watched it go from confusion to something else, something that was not confusion at all, something that was the beginning of a terror so large it had not yet arrived, the way you see a wave coming from a long way out and you know it is going to be taller than you. His mouth was open. His eyes were moving, left and right, the way a man's eyes move when he is searching a room for something he has lost and he cannot remember where he put it.
"Mary," he said. And then, uncertainly: "Mary. Mary. That's — that's right. That's her name. Mary."
"Okay," Coats said. "Okay. What's her maiden name?"
Hollis looked at him.
"What's her maiden name, Hollis?"
"I don't —" Hollis's voice cracked. "I don't know. Why don't I know? We've been married nineteen years, why don't I —" He put his hands over his face. The blanket slid off his shoulders and fell in the dirt and he did not pick it up. "What's wrong with me. What's wrong with me."
"Nothing's wrong with you," Coats said, and his voice was steady and calm and it was the voice of a man who has done this before, who has stood in this exact spot and said these exact words to someone else and watched them come apart. "You had a turn, that's all. It happens out there. The cold, the woods, you get turned around and your head gets scrambled. It'll come back. It always comes back."
"Does it?" Hollis said, from behind his hands.
"Most of it." Coats put a hand on his shoulder. "Go home. Go home and sit with Mary and have something hot to eat and get some sleep, and in the morning you'll feel more like yourself. I'll have someone drive you. You shouldn't be driving."
"I came in my own truck."
"I know. Someone'll drive you and someone'll bring your truck around tomorrow." Coats looked over at the knot of volunteers by the table, and his voice changed, went hard and flat and loud enough to carry. "That goes for all of you. We're done for the day. Everybody go home. Go home and get some rest and be back here at first light."
There was a murmur from the volunteers. One of them, a woman in a red hat, said, "But Sheriff, Petey's still —"
"I know Petey's still out there," Coats said. "I know it. And I'm telling you we're done for the day. It's going to be dark in an hour and I'm not having a search party in those trees after dark, not tonight, not for anybody. We go back at first light and we find him." He looked around at all of them, at their faces, and his voice dropped. "And I don't want to hear anybody talking about what happened to Hollis. You hear me? Any of you. Not to your wives, not to your neighbors, not to the reporters if they come sniffing around. Hollis had a turn in the cold and he's fine and that's the end of it. Anybody starts telling stories about the Hollow, anybody starts saying he came back wrong or he lost his memory or any of that foolishness, I'll have them out of this search and I'll have them in a cell. That's a promise, not a threat. We clear?"
The volunteers looked at each other. Nobody said anything. The woman in the red hat looked at the ground.
"We clear?" Coats said again.
"Yes, Sheriff," someone said. And then the others, one by one, murmuring it, yes, Sheriff, clear, Sheriff, and they began to gather up their things, the thermoses and the maps and the folding table, and the parking lot filled with the sounds of doors opening and engines starting and boots on asphalt. Coats stood by Hollis, who was sitting on the tailgate with his hands in his lap and his face gray and his mouth moving, very slightly, shaping a word that Sarah could not hear. Maybe it was Mary. Maybe it was something else.
Sarah stayed by the table.
When the lot had mostly emptied she walked over. Coats looked up at her and his face was tired, so tired, the face of a man who had been holding something up for a long time and had just been asked to hold it a little longer.
"You want to ask me something," he said.
"I want to know how many times you've done that."
He looked at her. Then he looked at Hollis, who was staring at his own hands again, and he said, quietly, "Eddie Boyers, four years ago. Went in after his dog. Came back with a nosebleed and couldn't remember his daughter's birthday. It came back to him in about a week. Most of it." He paused. "And there was a woman before that, a summer person, came up from Boston to paint the leaves, went for a walk at dusk. She came back three days later and she didn't know her own name and she never did know it again. Her sister came and got her and took her home and I don't know what happened after that. I don't want to know."
"What about the ones who don't come back?"
"Those," Coats said, "we don't talk about."
He picked up the blanket from the dirt and shook it out and folded it and set it on the tailgate next to Hollis, who did not look at him, who was still staring at his hands and moving his mouth, shaping a word, or a name, or the beginning of a song.
---
Sarah drove home the long way. She did not know why she drove the long way. The short way went past the edge of the school and the church and the little row of shops on Main, and the long way went out around the north end of town, past the dairy farm and the old grist mill and the road that turned off and went up into the trees.
She took the long way.
The light was going. The sky over the ridge was the color of a bruise, and the trees along the road were black against it, and the road was empty except for her. She drove with the radio off. She did not want to hear a voice. She did not want to hear anything but the engine and the tires on the asphalt and the wind.
She thought about Hollis. She thought about his face when Coats had asked him his wife's name, the way it had opened and then closed and then opened again, the way a door opens when the wind pushes it and then swings back. She thought about the pine needles in his hair, green and fresh, as though he had been standing under a pine tree that very morning, and she thought about the fact that the north edge of the Hollow was all oak and maple and birch, and there was not a pine on it for half a mile.
She thought about the gap. Two hours. A gap in a man's life, a hole where the memory should have been, and the man walking out of the trees with the hole in him and nothing to fill it but a green pine needle and a name he could not be sure of.
She thought about the fact that the Hollow did not just take things. It took things and it used them. It wore them like masks. And somewhere in the dark of those trees, in the two hours that Hollis could not account for, something had been wearing Hollis.
She turned off the long road onto her own road and the trees pulled back a little and the sky opened up and the farmhouse was there at the end of the lane, and the porch light was on, and her mother's old car was in the drive, and Lily's bicycle was on its side in the grass where she had left it.
Sarah parked and sat in the car for a moment with her hands on the wheel. The engine ticked as it cooled. The wind came across the field and pushed at the car and the bare branches at the edge of the yard made that sound, in and out, in and out, and Sarah sat there and listened to it and did not tell herself it was the wind. She was done telling herself that.
She got out of the car and went up the walk and opened the door.
"Lily?" she called. "I'm home."
The house was warm. The kitchen light was on and there was a pot on the stove and the radio was playing something low and the smell of it all was the smell of her mother's kitchen, the kitchen she had grown up in, the kitchen she had come back to. It should have been a comfort. It should have been the best thing in the world.
"Lily?"
"Upstairs," Lily called. Her voice came down the stairs, high and clear and ordinary, and Sarah stood in the hall with her hand on the newel post and felt the knot in her chest loosen a little. "I'm doing my homework."
Sarah went up. The stairs creaked in the places they had always creaked. The hall light was on and the door to Lily's room was open and Lily was sitting at her little desk with her back to the door and a colored pencil in her hand and her tongue between her teeth the way it always was when she was concentrating.
"What are you working on?" Sarah said.
"A drawing." Lily did not turn around. "For the wall. Miss Pell said we could put them on the wall."
"Can I see?"
"Not yet. It's not finished." Lily's hand moved, the pencil scratching at the paper. "When it's finished."
Sarah leaned against the door frame. She was so tired. She was tired down into her bones, and the tiredness was not the kind that sleep would fix, it was the kind that came from having seen a thing you could not unsee, and she looked at her daughter's back and her daughter's hair and the small careful motion of her daughter's hand and she thought, I will not let this touch you. I will not let this into this house.
"Did you have a good day at school?" she said.
"It was okay." Scratch, scratch, scratch. "We did the rhyme at recess again."
Sarah's hand tightened on the door frame.
"Lily," she said. "Sweetheart. I don't think you should do that rhyme anymore."
Lily's pencil stopped.
"Why not?"
"Because —" Sarah chose her words carefully. "Because it's not a nice rhyme. It's about a little girl who got lost, and it makes people sad. And I don't think we should sing songs about people getting lost. It's not kind."
Lily was quiet for a moment. Then she said, "But it's just a song."
"I know. But some songs are —" Sarah stopped. She thought of Mrs. Thorne in her chair by the fire, and what she had said. It teaches you a song. "Some songs are not just songs. And I'd feel better if you didn't sing that one. Will you do that for me?"
"Okay," Lily said. She picked up her pencil again and the scratching resumed. "Mama?"
"Yes, sweetheart?"
"Who's the girl in the trees?"
Sarah's blood went cold. She stood very still in the doorway and the world seemed to narrow to a point, to the back of her daughter's head and the pencil in her daughter's hand and the paper on the desk, and in the silence she could hear the wind in the bare branches and the branches made that sound, in and out, in and out, and somewhere below, in the kitchen, the radio played on.
"What girl, Lily?"
"The girl in my drawing." Lily's hand moved. "I'm drawing her. She's standing in the trees and she's looking out and she's got needles in her hair. She's got a lot of needles in her hair."
Sarah crossed the room. She crossed it in three steps and she put her hand on the back of Lily's chair and she looked at the drawing on the desk, and the drawing was done in colored pencil, in green and brown and a dark blue that was almost black, and there were the trees, and there was the girl standing among them, and she was looking out, and she had long hair and there were small green needles in it, and her face was blank and smooth and had no features at all.
"Lily," Sarah said, and her voice was very steady and very quiet, and it was the steadiest voice she had ever used. "Who is this?"
"I don't know," Lily said. She put down her pencil. "I just saw her. She was standing there and she was looking at me and she wanted me to draw her." She looked up at her mother, and her face was perfectly calm, perfectly ordinary, a child's face, a face that had not yet learned to be afraid of anything. "Do you think it's good?"
Sarah looked at the drawing. She looked at the trees, the dark knotted trunks, the branches that were almost but not quite like any branches she had ever seen. She looked at the girl with no face and the green needles in her hair. And she looked, at the bottom of the page, in the corner, where Lily had written a name in careful block letters, a name that Sarah had never told her, a name that Sarah had only heard for the first time that very afternoon, in a small warm parlor on the top of the ridge.
ELLEN.
"It's very good," Sarah said. "It's very good, sweetheart. Why don't you put it away now and come down and help me with supper."
"Okay," Lily said. She picked up the paper and slid it into her folder and closed the folder and put it in her backpack, and she got up and took Sarah's hand and they went down the stairs together, and Sarah held her daughter's hand and did not look back at the room, at the desk, at the window, at the dark trees beyond the glass.
But she felt them. She felt them the way you feel a person's eyes on the back of your neck in an empty room. She felt them looking, and she felt them waiting, and she felt them learning the shape of her house.
And down at the edge of the yard, where the field met the trees, the wind came through the bare branches and made a sound that was almost like breathing, in and out, in and out, and if you had stood there and listened very carefully, the way Mrs. Thorne listened, the way the old ones used to listen, you might have heard that it was not quite the wind at all.
It was a song.