The School Closes
The school board met on a Tuesday, in the basement of the municipal building, in a room that had been designed for storage and had been pressed into service as a meeting chamber sometime during the Eisenhower administration and never properly forgiven for it. The ceiling was low and the fluorescent light was the color of old teeth, and the folding chairs had been arranged in two rows facing a card table where the board sat with their hands folded and their faces arranged into expressions of grave responsibility.
Sarah sat in the back row and watched them do it.
She had known it was coming. Everyone had known it was coming. The town had been holding its breath since the Harlow boy walked out of the Hollow with no memory of the four days he'd been gone and a song in his mouth that nobody could place, and the breath had gone out of it in a long, slow exhale when the Kowalski twins didn't come out at all and the searchers found their jackets folded neatly on a stump a half-mile in, folded like laundry, folded like someone had taken them off and set them down and walked away into the trees without them. After that the parents had started keeping their children home, a few at first and then more, and by the end of October Sarah had been teaching eleven students in a room built for thirty, and by the middle of November she had been teaching six.
The board chairman was a man named Hollis Pruitt who sold farm equipment and had a soft, apologetic way of talking that made everything he said sound like an apology for something he hadn't done. He read from a sheet of paper. The paper shook slightly in his hands, and Sarah watched the shake and thought: he's afraid too. They're all afraid. They're sitting up there in their good coats and they're afraid of the same thing I'm afraid of, and the only difference between us is that they get to do something about it and I don't.
"The Greythorn Consolidated School will be closed indefinitely, effective immediately," Pruitt read, "pending a full review by the board in consultation with state officials and—" He paused. He looked at the paper. He looked at the other board members, and they looked back at him with the flat, terrified solidarity of people who have agreed on a story and are praying they can stick to it. "—and relevant parties," he finished, and the words fell into the room and lay there.
Relevant parties. Sarah almost laughed. She pressed her lips together and did not.
There was a murmur from the audience, which was not large. Maybe twenty people, the parents of the children who still came, and a few of the older residents who came to every public meeting because it was something to do, and Sheriff Coats standing at the back of the room with his hat in his hands, not sitting down, not leaning against the wall, just standing there with his jaw set and his eyes moving slowly across the room the way they did, counting exits, counting faces, counting the things that might need counting.
"The bus will continue to run on its regular schedule," Pruitt said, "to transport students to the regional school in Marshfield, for those families who wish to—"
"Those families," said a woman in the front row. Sarah didn't turn to see who it was. She knew the voice. Donna Harlow, whose son Michael had come back from the Hollow with a song in his mouth and a look in his eyes that hadn't gone away yet, that might never go away. "Those families. You mean the families that can afford to send their children an hour away and back every day. You mean the families that have two cars and a parent at home. You mean—"
"Donna," said Pruitt gently.
"Don't Donna me, Hollis Pruitt. Don't you sit up there behind your card table and Donna me." Her voice cracked. "My son is eight years old. He doesn't sleep. He sits up in his bed at night and he hums. He hums, Hollis. He doesn't know he's doing it. I ask him what he's humming and he says he doesn't know, he says it's just a song, he says it's just a song he heard somewhere, and I ask him where and he says—" Her voice dropped. The room had gone very quiet. "He says he heard it in the trees."
Nobody said anything. The fluorescent light buzzed overhead, that flat, insect drone, and Sarah could hear the furnace running somewhere in the guts of the building, pushing heat through pipes that knocked and settled and knocked again.
"The school is closed," Pruitt said. His voice was almost a whisper. "I'm sorry. The school is closed."
The meeting did not last much longer after that. There were a few more items on the agenda, a discussion of the bus schedule and a motion to post notices at the post office and the general store, and then Pruitt asked if there was any other business and there was no other business, and the folding chairs scraped against the linoleum and the people stood up and put on their coats and went out into the cold.
Sarah stayed where she was. She sat in her chair in the back row and watched them go, and Coats came up the aisle toward her and stopped and stood there with his hat in his hands.
"I'm sorry, Sarah," he said.
"Don't." She stood up. Her legs felt strange, distant, like they belonged to someone else. "Don't apologize. You didn't close the school."
"I didn't stop it, either."
She looked at him. His eyes were red-rimmed and his hands were not quite steady on the brim of his hat, and she thought about what Mrs. Thorne had said to them on the porch of that house, the things she had said before her mind had drifted off into the fog and left them standing there. She thought about the hand on the knocker and the way Coats had looked away from it, and she thought about the way he was looking at her now, like a man who has been carrying something for a very long time and has just been told he might be allowed to set it down.
"You know something," she said. "You know something you haven't told me."
"I know a lot of things I haven't told you." He put his hat on. "Most of them I don't know how to say. The rest of them I don't want to say. There's a difference."
"Sheriff—"
"Go home, Sarah." His voice was tired. "Go home to your girl. Keep her inside after dark. Keep the doors locked and the curtains drawn and if you hear anything in the night, anything at all, don't go out to look at it. Don't open the door. Don't answer if it knocks." He paused. "Especially if it knocks."
He turned and walked away, and his boots made a sound on the linoleum that echoed in the empty room long after he was gone.
---
The house on Elm Street was quiet when she got home. It was always quiet now, in a way it hadn't been when her mother was alive, when there had been the radio going in the kitchen and the television murmuring in the living room and the constant soft percussion of another person moving through a house, opening cabinets, running water, living. Sarah had grown up in this house and she had left it and she had come back to it, and now she was learning it all over again, the way you learn a language you used to speak as a child, the way you learn the creaks and groans of an old house's bones.
Lily was at the kitchen table with her crayons.
She had her tongue between her teeth, the way she did when she was concentrating, and her hair had come loose from its braid and hung in her face, and she was drawing with the fierce, total absorption of a child who has been left alone with her art and has decided to make the most of it. The table was covered with paper. There were sheets of it, some of them finished, some of them abandoned, some of them crumpled into balls and pushed to the edge where they teetered and occasionally fell. Sarah stood in the doorway and looked at her daughter and felt the day settle onto her shoulders like a wet coat.
"Hey, bug," she said.
Lily looked up. Her eyes were bright, and there was a smudge of purple crayon on her cheek, and she smiled the way she smiled, which was sudden and whole and entirely without reservation. "Mama. You're home."
"I'm home." Sarah hung her coat on the hook by the door and crossed the kitchen and sat down across from her daughter. The chair was the one her mother had sat in, the one with the cushion that had been flattened by twenty years of the same weight, and Sarah sat in it and felt the ghost of her mother's shape beneath her and did not let herself think about it. "What are you drawing?"
Lily turned the paper around. "The trees," she said.
Sarah looked at it.
It was not a child's drawing of trees. That was the first thing she noticed, and she noticed it the way you notice a wrong note in a piece of music, a half-step off, a thing that shouldn't be there. The trees in the drawing were tall and thin and black, and they had no leaves, and they were drawn with a precision that Lily did not possess, a precision that Sarah had not seen in any of her daughter's work before. The branches were articulated, individual, each one a separate line that branched and branched and branched again, fractal, infinite, and the lines went down and down and down into a darkness that the purple crayon had not been able to fill all the way, so that there were white spaces in it, gaps, places where the paper showed through like light.
And in the middle of the trees, there was a figure.
It was small. It was drawn in black, the same black as the trees, and it was facing away from the viewer, facing into the dark, and it was wearing a coat. Sarah looked at the coat and felt something cold move through her, a trickle of ice water down the back of her neck.
"Lily," she said. "Who is that?"
Lily looked at the drawing. She tilted her head. "I don't know," she said. "I think it's someone who got lost."
"Did you see this somewhere?"
"I dreamed it." Lily picked up a green crayon and began to color something in the corner of the paper, something Sarah couldn't see. "I dream about it a lot. The trees. They're always there when I close my eyes. They're not scary, Mama. They're just trees."
Sarah looked at the figure in the coat and thought about the Kowalski twins' jackets folded on a stump, and she thought about the Harlow boy humming a song he'd heard in the trees, and she thought about the way the wind had sounded coming down off the ridge, in and out, in and out, like breathing.
"Lily," she said. "Have you been going outside? At night?"
Lily's crayon stopped moving. She looked up at her mother, and her eyes were still bright, still Lily's eyes, still the eyes of the child Sarah had held in her arms on the day she was born, but there was something behind them now, something Sarah hadn't seen before, or hadn't wanted to see.
"No, Mama," she said. "I know better. You told me. The trees are dangerous at night."
"That's right. That's right, bug." Sarah reached across the table and took her daughter's hand. It was warm, small, sticky with crayon wax. "The trees are dangerous at night. You stay inside. You stay inside and you don't open the door, no matter what."
Lily nodded. "I know," she said. "The knocking."
Sarah's hand tightened. "What knocking?"
"The knocking at the door." Lily pulled her hand away and went back to her drawing. "In my dream. There's always knocking. But I don't answer it. You told me not to answer it."
"That's right." Sarah's voice was steady. She was proud of how steady it was. "That's right, bug. You don't answer it."
Lily hummed.
It was a small sound, almost nothing, the sound a child makes when they're content, when they're working, when they're not thinking about what they're doing. It rose and fell, three notes and then four, and then it repeated, and then it repeated again, and Sarah sat in her mother's chair and listened to her daughter hum a song she did not know and felt the cold move through her again, deeper this time, settling into her bones.
"Lily," she said. "What's that song?"
Lily looked up. "What song?"
"The one you're humming."
Lily's forehead wrinkled. She looked genuinely confused, the way children do when they're caught doing something they didn't know they were doing. "I wasn't humming," she said. "Was I humming?"
"You were humming."
"Oh." Lily looked down at her drawing. "I don't know. It's just a song. I heard it somewhere."
Sarah sat very still.
She thought about the Harlow boy, sitting up in his bed at night, humming a song he couldn't name. She thought about Mrs. Thorne's pale blue eyes and the way they had gone from Coats to Sarah and back to Coats, and the way she had said You brought the schoolteacher, and the way her voice had cracked on the word schoolteacher, like it was a thing that could be taken away.
She thought about the Hollow, and the pact, and the things Coats wouldn't say, and the way the trees had sounded in and out on the ridge, in and out, breathing.
"Finish your drawing," she said. "It's almost dinner."
---
That night, after Lily was asleep, Sarah sat in the living room and watched the window.
The curtains were drawn, the way Coats had told her, and the door was locked, and the porch light was on, though she couldn't have said why. It was a thing her mother had always done, kept the porch light burning all night, and Sarah had never asked why and now her mother was dead and there was no one to ask. She sat in the chair by the window and listened to the house and thought about the drawing.
The figure in the coat. Facing into the dark. The trees branching down and down and down.
She told herself it was nothing. She told herself children drew strange things, that Lily was eight years old and her imagination was a wide and wild place, that she had heard stories at school, from the other children, from the ones whose parents hadn't told them to be quiet about it. She told herself that the song was a song she had heard somewhere and forgotten, that songs got into your head and stayed there the way burrs got into your socks, that there was nothing strange about it, nothing wrong.
She told herself all of this and did not believe any of it.
The house creaked. She knew the creaks. She had grown up with them. The creak in the hall was the third board from the bathroom, and the creak in the kitchen was the cabinet door that didn't quite close, and the creak in the ceiling was the old joists settling under the weight of the second floor. She knew them all, and she listened to them, and she waited.
At some point she realized she was humming.
It came up out of her without warning, the way a song does, the way a tune gets into your head and you catch yourself whistling it in the grocery store or the car. Three notes and then four. Then repeat. She stopped herself, pressed her lips together, and sat very still in the chair.
The house was quiet. The furnace hummed in the basement. The wind moved outside, pressing against the windows, pressing against the walls, and somewhere in the pipes a sound began.
It was faint at first. She almost didn't hear it, might have missed it if she hadn't been sitting so still, so silent, listening for anything, listening for everything. A whisper in the pipes, a thread of sound, rising and falling. She sat up straighter in the chair and turned her head toward the wall.
Three notes. Then four.
She stood up. The chair creaked beneath her, and she winced at the sound, and then she walked to the wall and put her ear against it. The plaster was cold. The pipes ran through the wall, the old galvanized pipes that had been installed when her grandfather was a boy, and they carried water and heat and sound, and somewhere inside them something was humming.
Three notes. Then four. Then repeat.
It was the same song. It was the same song Lily had been humming at the kitchen table, the same song the Harlow boy hummed in his bed at night, the same song that had no name and no source and no reason to be there except that it was, it was there, it was in the pipes and it was in the walls and it was in the house.
Sarah pulled her ear away from the wall. Her heart was beating hard, and her hands were cold, and she stood in the middle of her mother's living room and listened to the pipes hum and tried to tell herself it was the furnace, it was the water heater, it was the old pipes settling and singing the way old pipes do. She tried to tell herself that and she almost believed it, almost, and then the humming stopped.
It didn't fade. It didn't trail off. It stopped, all at once, like a hand closing over a mouth.
The silence that followed was worse than the sound.
Sarah stood in the living room and listened to the silence and felt it pressing against her, thick and close, like water, like the dark. She thought about the Hollow and the way it went quiet at night, the way the birds stopped and the insects stopped and the wind stopped, the way the forest held its breath and waited for you to make a mistake. She thought about the way the silence had followed her home.
She thought about Lily, asleep upstairs.
She was moving before she knew she was moving, out of the living room and up the stairs, her hand on the banister, her feet finding the steps in the dark. The hallway was dark and the door to Lily's room was closed and she opened it, slowly, carefully, and stood in the doorway and looked at her daughter.
Lily was asleep. She was curled on her side with her hands under her cheek and her blanket pulled up to her chin, and her breathing was slow and even, and the nightlight in the corner of the room cast a soft yellow glow over the walls. The drawings were still on the table in the kitchen, and the one of the trees was on top, and Sarah had not moved it. She had not been able to make herself touch it.
She stood in the doorway and watched her daughter sleep and listened to the silence, and after a while she heard it again.
The humming.
It was coming from the walls. From the pipes. Three notes and then four, soft and steady, and it was not the furnace and it was not the water heater and it was not the old pipes settling. It was a voice. It was a song. It was coming through the walls of her mother's house and into her daughter's room, and Sarah stood in the doorway and listened to it and felt something inside her go very still and very cold.
She crossed the room. She knelt beside Lily's bed and put her hand on her daughter's shoulder and shook her gently. "Lily," she whispered. "Lily, wake up."
Lily's eyes opened. They were dark and confused and then they focused on her mother's face and she smiled, sleepy, trusting. "Mama?"
"Can you hear that?"
Lily was silent for a moment. She tilted her head. "Hear what?"
"The humming. In the walls."
Lily listened. Her eyes moved to the wall, to the pipes, and Sarah watched her daughter's face and waited and felt the cold spread through her chest.
"I don't hear anything," Lily said. "Mama, I don't hear anything."
Sarah listened. The humming was still there, still soft, still steady, three notes and then four. It was there and it was clear and it was in the walls, and her daughter could not hear it.
"Go back to sleep, bug," Sarah said. Her voice was steady. She was proud of how steady it was. "It's nothing. It's just the house."
Lily nodded and closed her eyes and was asleep again in moments, the way children are, the way they fall into sleep like stones into water. Sarah stayed where she was, kneeling beside the bed, her hand on her daughter's shoulder, and listened to the humming in the walls.
It went on for a long time. It went on until Sarah lost track of the minutes and the hours, until the night pressed against the window and the house creaked and settled around her, until she could not tell the difference between the pipes and her own heartbeat. And then, slowly, it faded, not stopping but receding, drawing back into the walls and the dark, the way water draws back from the shore.
Sarah sat on the floor beside her daughter's bed and did not sleep.
---
In the morning she called Coats.
The phone rang four times before he picked up, and when he did his voice was rough and thick, the voice of a man who had been awake all night and had not wanted to be. "Coats."
"Sheriff. It's Sarah Grey."
A pause. She heard him shift, heard the creak of a chair, heard something that might have been a glass being set down on a table. "What's wrong?"
"I need to see Mrs. Thorne again."
Another pause. Longer this time. "Sarah—"
"Last night I heard humming in my pipes. The same song Lily was humming. The same song the Harlow boy hums." She kept her voice level. She had been keeping her voice level for hours, and she was very good at it now. "Lily couldn't hear it. It was there and it was loud and she couldn't hear it, and Sheriff, she's been drawing things. She drew the trees. She drew a figure in a coat walking into the trees. She said she dreamed it. She said she's been dreaming it a lot."
The silence on the other end of the line was long and heavy.
"I'll pick you up at nine," Coats said. "Don't tell anyone you're going. Don't tell anyone where you're going."
"Sheriff—"
"Nine o'clock." His voice was flat. "And Sarah—keep Lily inside today. Keep her inside and keep the doors locked and don't let her answer the door if anyone knocks."
"Who would knock?"
He didn't answer. The line went dead.
Sarah stood in the kitchen with the phone in her hand and listened to the dial tone and thought about the figure in her daughter's drawing, facing into the dark, walking into the trees. She thought about the hand on Mrs. Thorne's door, the brass hand with its fingers curled and its knuckles polished smooth by decades of other hands.
She thought about the knocking in Lily's dream.
She hung up the phone very gently, and went to check the locks on the doors, and then she went to the window and looked out at the trees.
They were still. They were always still now. The wind moved through the yard and stirred the dead leaves and the bare branches, but the trees at the edge of the property, the ones that marked the beginning of the old forest, the ones that grew thicker and darker as they went up toward the ridge, did not move. They stood there in the morning light and they were still, and Sarah stood at the window and looked at them and felt them looking back.
She turned away. She went to the kitchen table and picked up Lily's drawing, the one of the trees and the figure in the coat, and she held it in her hands and looked at it for a long time.
Then she folded it, carefully, into quarters, and put it in the drawer with the dishtowels, and closed the drawer, and did not look at it again.
In the other room, Lily was humming.
Three notes. Then four. Then repeat.