← The Hollow

What Ruth Knew

Chapter 16 of 17 · 4858 words

The boxes were in the attic, and the attic was cold.

Sarah had put off going up there for three months, and she had put it off for the ordinary reasons — grief, exhaustion, the way a house full of a dead woman's things seemed to hold its breath and wait for you to leave before it let itself go — and for one reason that was not ordinary at all. Her mother's house had always been a house that kept its secrets, and now that Ruth Grey was gone, the house had begun to keep them for her.

That was a child's thought. Sarah knew it was a child's thought. She was thirty-five years old and she taught third grade and she did not believe in haunted houses, or in pacts, or in any of it. But the house had been quiet in a way that was not empty-quiet, and the attic door at the end of the upstairs hall had a way of drawing her eye when she came out of the bathroom in the middle of the night, and so she had put it off, and put it off, and put it off, until the school board closed the school and she came home with a cardboard box of her classroom's things and a cold, flat fury in her chest and nowhere to put it.

She climbed the stairs that evening while Lily was at the kitchen table with a coloring book and a cup of milk. The attic door stuck, then gave, and the smell came down at her — cedar and dust and mothballs and something older underneath, something like leaves. She pulled the cord and the bulb came on, a single bare bulb on a cord, swinging slightly, casting the boxes in long moving shadows.

There were more of them than she had expected. Her mother had not been a hoarder, but she had been a keeper, and there were boxes from the move when Sarah's father died, boxes from before that, boxes that had never been unpacked at all. Sarah sat down on the dusty floorboards in her good work slacks and began to go through them, one at a time, because it had to be done and because the alternative was to go back downstairs and sit in the kitchen and watch her daughter color and think about the Hollow and the way the trees had looked from the school parking lot that afternoon, the way they had looked like they were leaning in.

Most of it was what she had expected. Photographs with the color gone orange. Old tax returns, which her mother had kept for reasons known only to her mother. A box of Sarah's own school papers, every one, kept for thirty years — a spelling test from second grade with a gold star on it, a drawing of a house with four stick figures out front, one of them labeled DADDY. Sarah looked at the drawing for a while and then folded it carefully and set it aside. The heating pipe knocked somewhere below her. The bulb swung.

The journal was in the bottom of the last box, and she almost missed it, because it was not a journal in the way she would have thought of one. It was a plain composition notebook, the kind with the black-and-white marbled cover that cost a dollar at any drugstore in America, and it was wrapped in a square of oilcloth tied with twine, as though her mother had been afraid of it getting wet, or afraid of what might seep in.

Sarah untied the twine. The cover was faded, and there was a ring on it where a cup had been set down, and on the inside front page, in her mother's neat, slanted, schoolteacher's handwriting — her mother had taught third grade too, twenty years of it, before Sarah was born and after — there was a date. October 1971.

And then, below the date, in smaller letters, pressed hard enough to score the paper: *For S., if she ever needs it. Burn the rest.*

Sarah sat very still in the cold attic with the bulb swinging and the pipe knocking and she felt something go through her that was not quite fear and not quite grief, a long, low note like a cello string touched and left to ring. She turned the page.

The first entry was dated October 14, 1971, and it was careful.

*The Hollins girl came back this morning. Four days. Her mother says she doesn't remember. I believe her mother. I went to see her. She was sitting at the kitchen table eating toast and she looked up at me and smiled and asked me how my roses were doing. I have no roses. I have never had roses. When I said so she looked at me as though I had said something rude and went back to her toast. D. says I'm making too much of it. D. is wrong. I have known the Hollins family for eleven years and the girl has never once asked me about my garden, which she cannot see from the road, and which as I say does not exist.*

*The thing to remember is that it isn't malice. It's curiosity. It's a child with a jar.*

Sarah turned the page.

The next entry was October 21st.

*I have begun to keep a list. Not a list of the missing. A list of the returned. There are more of them than anyone wants to count. I have eleven names now going back to 1948, and that is only what I know, and I am one woman in one house. What they have in common is the gap and what they don't have in common is what fills it. Some of them come back quieter. Some of them come back louder. The Hollins girl came back with a song she can't place and a fear of the color yellow.*

*I asked D. what his mother was afraid of, near the end. He said she wouldn't go past the mill road. I said, why the mill road, and he said she said the trees were thinner there. I do not know what that means. I intend to find out.*

The journal went on like that. October, November, December, the entries in her mother's slanting hand, careful and ordered like a lesson plan, and Sarah sat on the attic floor and read them and felt the cold come up through the floorboards and settle in her bones.

Her mother had kept a list of everyone who had ever come back from the Hollow. She had gone to their houses with a plate of cookies and a newspaper from town and sat in their kitchens and asked them questions that were not quite the questions she meant. She had drawn a map, two pages of it, the Hollow's edge traced in pencil on graph paper, with the houses numbered and the years marked, and on the map she had circled a place she called *the bald* — a clearing, Sarah gathered, a place where nothing grew, a half-mile in past the Kowalski property line — and circled it again and again until the graphite had gone shiny and gray.

*The bald is where he took me,* someone had told her. That was 1973. The name had been inked out.

*Nobody comes out of the bald,* someone else had told her. 1974.

*Don't write my name,* a third had said. 1974, the same month, three weeks later. *Please don't write my name. I don't want to be on a list.*

Her mother had written the names anyway. Sarah could see the pressure of the pen, the way it had bitten into the page. Her mother had been afraid of the list being found, and she had kept the list anyway, because she was a schoolteacher, and schoolteachers keep records. It was, Sarah thought, the most her mother thing that her mother had ever done.

She turned the pages and the years turned with them. 1975. 1978, a run of blank months, then a single entry: *I have stopped going to the edge. The edge is not the edge. It is a door and I have been knocking.* 1979. The entries got shorter and more careful. Some of them were in code — not a real code, nothing you could break with a pencil, but a schoolteacher's shorthand, initials and abbreviations and arrows, and Sarah read them the way she had learned to read her mother's grocery lists, by inference, by the shape of the letters more than the letters themselves.

1980. Sarah had been born in 1980. There was a gap in the journal from March to September of that year, and when the entries resumed, they were different. The careful schoolteacher's hand was gone. The new hand was still her mother's but the slant had changed, and the words were bigger, and there were more of them, and they had a heat in them that Sarah had never once heard in her mother's voice.

*I have stopped the list. I have stopped the map. I have stopped going to the edge. I am going to be a mother now and a mother does not knock on doors.*

And then, a week later: *I have taken the map down off the wall. I have put it in a box. I will not take it out again. D. is right. It is not that I am making too much of it. It is that I have been making it into a thing I can study, and it is not a thing that can be studied. It is a thing that studies back.*

And then, three pages further on, in a hand that shook: *It asked about the baby.*

Sarah put the notebook down.

She was aware, suddenly and with an acuity that felt like a hand on the back of her neck, of the attic around her — the boxes, the bulb, the long shadows, the smell of cedar and leaves. The pipe knocked. The wind pressed at the eaves. And somewhere below her, in the warm yellow kitchen where she had left her daughter with a coloring book and a cup of milk, there was a silence that she did not like.

She got up. She went down the attic stairs faster than she meant to, and the bulb swung behind her and threw her shadow down the wall, and she came out into the upstairs hall and stood at the top of the stairs and listened, and the house was quiet in the way it had been quiet for three months.

"Lily," she called.

"Mama," Lily called back, from the kitchen, in the ordinary voice of an eight-year-old who has been coloring and is a little bored and wants company. "Can I have another cup of milk?"

Sarah let out a breath she had not known she was holding. "In a minute, baby."

She went back up the attic stairs. She sat down on the floorboards and she picked up the notebook and she kept reading, because she had come this far, and because the thing she was most afraid of was the thing she did not yet know.

The entries after 1980 were sparse. Her mother had kept her word. The map stayed in the box. The list stayed in the box. But every year or so, in the fall, there was an entry, and each of them was short, and each of them was the same in a way that made Sarah's stomach go tight.

*The Harlow boy's grandmother came to the door today. She wanted to talk about the edge. I said I didn't know what she meant. I lied. I am sorry. I lied.*

*Someone has been walking on the mill road at night. I can hear it from the back porch. It is not a person. It walks like a person who is thinking about something else.*

*The Kowalskis are leaving their porch light on all night. They think it helps. It does not help. It is a firefly to a jar.*

And then, in 1994, when Sarah was fourteen: *It knows her name. I don't know how it knows her name. She has never gone past the mailbox. She has never gone past the mailbox and it knows her name.*

Sarah closed the notebook.

She sat for a while. The bulb swung. The wind worked at the eaves. Downstairs, Lily was singing something, low and tuneless, the way she did when she was concentrating on her coloring, and Sarah listened to it and it was the most ordinary sound in the world and she wanted to go downstairs and put her arms around her daughter and never let go and she also wanted to keep reading, because whatever was in the notebook had been written for her, and her mother had said so, on the first page, in her own hand.

*For S., if she ever needs it.*

She turned the pages. The last stretch of the notebook was mostly blank. There were a few entries in the mid-2000s, her mother's hand getting spidery with age, and then a gap of several years, and then, near the back, a run of entries that were close together, dated in the autumn of the year before her mother died. Sarah's father had died in the spring of that year. Her mother had been alone in this house with the Hollow at the end of the road and a notebook full of names in a box in the attic.

*The Harlow boy is walking again. He is seven. He walks to the mailbox and back and he stands at the mailbox for a long time before he comes back in.*

*I have begun to write things down again and I have promised myself that this time I will not make a study of it. I will only write what I see.*

*What I see is that it is closer than it was. The silence is different. When I was a girl the silence started at the treeline and now it starts at the fence.*

*I went to the edge today. I stood at the edge and I said, I know you. I said, you know me. I said, we have an understanding. And the woods were quiet and I waited and I waited and then something said my name back to me, in my own voice, from about twenty feet in. Like an echo that had gotten loose.*

Sarah's hands were cold. She turned the page.

*It didn't say it like a question. It said it like a person trying on a coat.*

The next entry was dated November 3rd. Sarah did the math. November 3rd was eleven days before her mother's stroke. Eleven days before the morning Sarah had driven up from Connecticut because the neighbor had called and said Ruth had fallen in the kitchen and was asking for her, and found her mother in the hospital in Burlington with her left side gone and her eyes open and her mouth working, trying to tell Sarah something that would not come out.

*Lily is here,* the entry said. *She came up for the weekend with S. She is eight years old. She draws pictures at the kitchen table and she does not know I am watching her. Today she drew the trees.*

Sarah turned the page.

*She drew the trees and she drew them with the spaces between them. That is how I would draw them if I could draw. She drew the trees and the spaces and in the spaces she drew little doorways, and when I asked her what the doorways were she said, that's where the people come out.*

Sarah's hands had gone cold all the way up to the wrists. She remembered that weekend. She remembered the Thanksgiving that wasn't, the long drive up from Connecticut with Lily asleep in the back, the house smelling of woodsmoke and mutton. She remembered her mother at the kitchen table, watching Lily draw, and she remembered thinking that her mother looked tired, and she remembered thinking that she would tell Lily to put the drawing away, that Grandma needed her rest.

She had not seen the drawing. She had not asked.

She turned the page.

There was one entry left. The notebook was almost full, and the last entry was written on the inside back cover, in a hand that was not her mother's careful slant but something larger and shakier, the hand of a woman who was writing at speed and perhaps in the dark.

*She is asking for Lily by name.*

Sarah sat in the cold attic with the notebook open on her knees and the bulb swinging and the wind working at the eaves and she read the line over and over, the way you press a bruise, the way you put your tongue against a broken tooth.

*She is asking for Lily by name.*

She read the line above it, which she had not read. She had jumped to the bottom the way she always did, the way she skipped to the last page of a book to make sure everyone survived it. The line above was written in the same large shaky hand, and it said:

*I went to the edge again today and it did not say my name. It said hers. It said it in her voice, the way she says it when she wants me, the way she says it from the top of the stairs. I stood there for a long time and it kept saying it and then it stopped and I came home and locked the door.*

*I do not know what to do. I am old and I am afraid and there is no one left to tell. D. is dead. The boys are gone. There is no one in this town who will say the word out loud.*

*I am going to write it here and then I am going to tear this page out and put it with the rest and I am going to burn the notebook. But I have not burned it. I have not torn it out. I am sitting here with the pen in my hand.*

*If you are reading this, S., it is because I could not make myself burn it. It is because some part of me thinks that you will need to know. I am sorry. I am so sorry. I should have taken you away from here when you were small and I did not and now it is too late and I am an old woman in an empty house and it is out there saying my granddaughter's name in her voice.*

*Do not let her go to the edge. Do not let her go past the mailbox. Do not let her draw the trees.*

*I love you. I love her. Burn the rest.*

The page ended. Sarah turned it, and the next page was blank, and the page after that was blank, and then the inside back cover, and on the inside back cover, in pencil, so faint that she almost missed it, in her mother's normal hand, small and careful and steady:

*The last page is torn out. I tore it out and I ate it. I am sorry. I could not let it be read. It said too much.*

Sarah sat very still.

The bulb swung. The pipe knocked. Below her, in the kitchen, Lily had stopped singing.

"Lily," Sarah called, and her voice came out wrong, came out too high, came out like a woman at the edge of something. "Lily, answer me."

There was a moment — a long moment, the length of a held breath, the length of the drive from Connecticut, the length of four days in the Hollow, the length of a half-mile in past the Kowalski property line — and then Lily said, in the ordinary voice of an eight-year-old who has been coloring and is a little bored and wants company:

"Mama, can I have another cup of milk?"

Sarah came down the attic stairs. She came down them too fast and she caught her hip on the corner of the doorframe and she did not feel it, and she came down the upstairs hall and down the front stairs and into the kitchen, and Lily was at the table with her coloring book and her empty cup and her crayons spread out in a fan, and she looked up at her mother and smiled.

"What's wrong?" Lily said. "You look like you saw a ghost."

Sarah looked at her daughter. Sarah looked at the coloring book, at the picture Lily had been working on, and then at the fan of crayons, and then at the window over the sink, which was black now, black and shining, and in the window she could see the reflection of the kitchen and the reflection of her daughter and the reflection of herself, and she stood there for a moment and looked at the reflections and felt the cold come up through her shoes.

"Nothing," she said. "Nothing, baby. Let me get you your milk."

She got the milk. She sat down across from Lily at the kitchen table and she watched her daughter color, and Lily chattered about school and about the coloring book and about a dream she'd had, and Sarah listened and made the sounds a mother makes, and all the while she was thinking about the box in the attic and the notebook in the box and the page her mother had torn out and eaten.

She was thinking about the line her mother had written and then tried to take back. *It said it in her voice, the way she says it when she wants me, the way she says it from the top of the stairs.*

She was thinking about the way Lily had said *Mama, can I have another cup of milk?* — not once, but twice, in the same voice, in the same words, from the same place, as though the first time had been a recording and the second time had been a recording of the recording.

She was thinking about how she had stood at the top of the attic stairs and called her daughter's name and there had been a moment — a long moment — before her daughter answered.

"Lily," she said. "Did you hear anything tonight? From outside?"

Lily looked up from her coloring. Her eyes were blue and ordinary and eight years old.

"There was a lady singing," Lily said.

Sarah's heart did something in her chest, a slow turn, like a key in a lock.

"A lady," she said.

"In the trees," Lily said. "She was singing the song. The one the Harlow boy sings. She knew all the words."

Sarah set down her cup. The cup made a small click against the table, and the click seemed very loud in the kitchen, and outside the window the trees stood in their dark rows, and the wind moved through them, and the window shook a little in its frame, and somewhere out past the mailbox, out past the fence, out past the edge where the silence started, something that was not a person walked the mill road like a person thinking about something else.

"Show me," Sarah said. Her voice was steady. She did not know how it was steady. "Show me what you drew. The trees. Show me the trees."

Lily turned the coloring book around.

It was not the picture she had been coloring. It was a new one, on a fresh page, in black crayon, and it was the trees. The trees, and the spaces between them, and in the spaces the little doorways, and in the doorways there were figures, small stick figures, drawn the way Lily drew everything, with round heads and straight-line arms.

There were three of them. A big one, and a middle one, and a small one.

And the small one was not in a doorway. The small one was on the near side of the trees, standing at the edge with its arms out, and next to it, in Lily's careful eight-year-old printing, there was a word.

The word was MAMA.

Sarah looked at the drawing for a long time. The bulb in the attic was still swinging, she knew, though she could not hear it from here. The pipe had stopped knocking. The wind moved through the trees outside the window, and the trees stood in their dark rows, and the silence at the edge of town was a little closer than it had been, a little closer than it had been the year before, a little closer every year, and Sarah sat in her mother's kitchen and looked at her daughter's drawing and understood, at last, in a way she could not un-understand, what her mother had known.

Her mother had known that it was patient. Her mother had known that it was curious, and that it collected, and that it did not take what it wanted all at once but gathered it a little at a time, a name here, a voice there, a song, a fear of the color yellow, a memory of roses that had never grown. Her mother had known that the pact was not a wall. It was a habit. It was a thing that had been done for so long that everyone had forgotten it was a choice, and it held only as long as everyone kept choosing it, and someone had stopped choosing it, or something had gotten tired of waiting.

And her mother had known the last thing, the thing that Sarah had not known until this moment, the thing that her mother had tried to eat rather than let be read: that it did not want the town. It wanted the children. It had always wanted the children. It had taken them one at a time for a hundred years and the town had called it a pact and gone on with its life, and now it had found one it wanted more than the others, and it had learned her name, and it was out there at the edge of the trees saying it in her mother's voice.

"Baby," Sarah said. "Put your crayons away."

Lily looked up. "But I'm not done."

"Put them away," Sarah said, and her voice was steady, and her hands were not. "We're going to go upstairs and we're going to pack a bag. We're going to go stay somewhere else tonight."

"Where?"

"Somewhere else," Sarah said. "Anywhere else."

She stood up. She went to the window over the sink and she looked out at the dark and the trees, and the reflection of the kitchen looked back at her, and in the reflection she could see her daughter at the table with her crayons and her coloring book, and she could see herself, and she could see the window, and beyond the window the reflection of the trees went on and on into a dark that was not the dark of the yard.

She reached up and pulled the curtain.

"Lily," she said. "Come here."

Lily came. She was eight years old and she was warm and she smelled of crayons and milk, and Sarah put her arms around her and held her and looked at the curtain, and the curtain hung still, and behind the curtain the window shook a little in its frame.

"Mama," Lily said, muffled against her mother's sweater. "Why are you crying?"

"I'm not," Sarah said. "I'm not crying. I'm thinking."

"About what?"

Sarah held her daughter and looked at the curtain and thought about the notebook in the box in the attic, and the page her mother had torn out and eaten, and the thing her mother had said too much of, and the way the silence had been a little closer every year.

"About what your grandma knew," she said.

Outside, past the mailbox, past the fence, past the edge, the wind moved through the trees, and the trees stood in their dark rows, and something that was not a person walked the mill road, patient as a schoolteacher, curious as a child with a jar.

And from the trees, faintly, so faintly that Sarah could not be sure she had heard it at all, a voice that was almost her own said her daughter's name.

She did not answer it. She held her daughter tighter and she did not answer it, and she stood in her mother's kitchen with the curtain drawn and the window shaking and she thought: *I am going to have to go to the edge. I am going to have to go to the edge and I am going to have to say the word out loud.*

*But not tonight.*

*Tomorrow.*

*Tomorrow I will go and see Mrs. Thorne.*