The Vigil
The vigil was set for seven o'clock at the First Congregational Church, and by six-thirty the pews were full and the overflow stood in the narthex and the entryway and out onto the steps in the cold, and Sarah stood among them because there was nowhere else to be.
She had not wanted to come. She had said as much to Lily at supper, in the careful way she said things to Lily now, the way of a woman feeling her way across a floor she could not see. *There's a thing at the church tonight. People are going to light candles and pray. We don't have to go.* And Lily had looked up from her macaroni and said, *Is it for the kids who got lost?* and Sarah had said yes, and Lily had said, *Then we should go,* with the terrible simple certainty of an eight-year-old, and there had been nothing to say after that.
So they had gone. Lily in her good coat, the red one with the toggles, and her hair brushed wet and parted straight because she would not tolerate a crooked part; Sarah in the gray wool she wore to funerals and parent conferences and other occasions where she was expected to be a version of herself she could not quite locate. The church smelled of cold stone and candle wax and the wet wool of a hundred people who had come in from the rain. Rain, not snow — the November had been warm and wrong, the ground refusing to freeze, the Hollow breathing out its wet leaf-smell over the whole town every evening like something in a fever.
The sanctuary was narrow and old, whitewashed, with a high hard ceiling and tall windows that had once held stained glass and now held plain rippled glass, a thrift of the Depression, when the old glass had been sold to keep the church's roof on. You could see nothing through those windows at night but the church's own light thrown back at it, and the shapes of people's faces, doubled and dim, floating in the black.
Sarah found a place near the back, at the end of a pew, Lily tucked in beside her, and she watched the town come in.
She had grown up in this church. She had sat in these pews as a girl and counted the knots in the wood and mouthed the hymns without singing and stared at the back of her mother's head, which was always three rows ahead and always perfectly still. She knew these people the way you know a town you have left and come back to — by their faces, by their fathers' faces, by the shape of their hands. There was Marnie Holt from the post office with her three boys in a row like steps. There were the Pelletiers from the dairy farm, all six of them, the youngest asleep against her father's shoulder. There was the school secretary, Mrs. Boyle, who had cried in the office the day the board voted to close the school and who now sat with her hands folded and her eyes fixed on the altar as though she were afraid of what she would see if she looked away. There were the Hendersons, whose boy Danny had walked into the Hollow in October and come out three hours later on the Cold River Road with no memory of the walk and mud on his shoes that was not the Hollow's mud. There was Danny himself, twelve years old, sitting between his parents with his hands between his knees, looking at nothing.
And there was Sheriff Coats, at the back by the door, his hat in his hands.
The wind came against the windows, and everyone in the sanctuary flinched — a small collective motion, shoulders and heads, like grass going over in a gust — and then everyone in the sanctuary pretended that they had not.
---
Pastor Ellis was a soft, tired man in his sixties with a voice like a hand on a shoulder. He had been at First Congregational for thirty years and he had buried most of the people in that room's parents, and he climbed into the pulpit that evening with his reading glasses in his hand and no notes, and he stood there for a moment looking out at them, and Sarah thought: *He knows. He knows what he can't say.*
"We are gathered," he said at last, "in the shadow of a grief that has no name."
He did not say the Hollow. He did not have to. Nobody in that church had said the word aloud in weeks, not in a public room, and Sarah had begun to notice the way the word moved through the town the way a mouse moves through a kitchen — quickly, along the walls, never in the open.
"We are gathered for the children," Pastor Ellis said, "and for the ones who have gone into the woods and not come out, and for the ones who have come out and are not the same. We are gathered because we do not know what else to do. And I want to say to you — I want to say to you plainly, because I think you have heard enough soft words this autumn — that I do not know why this is happening. I do not know what is in the woods. I do not know what God intends by it, or whether God intends anything by it at all. I am an old man and a tired one and I have stood at too many graves this year to pretend to you that I understand."
The congregation was very still. Somewhere a child coughed, and the cough went through the room like a dropped plate.
"But I know this," Pastor Ellis said. "I know that we are here. I know that we are here together. I know that the light in this room is the light we brought in with us, and that when we carry it out again into the dark, we carry it together. And I know that we have been — " he stopped. He looked down at the pulpit, and then up again, and his face had changed, had gone careful in a way that Sarah recognized, the way a person's face goes careful when they are choosing a word in front of a room full of people who will remember it. "I know that we have been a faithful town," he said. "I know that we have kept our promises. And I believe — I believe, brothers and sisters — that we will be kept in our turn."
There it was. Sarah felt it go through the room like a draft under a door. *We have kept our promises.* Nobody said amen to that. Nobody said anything. But the whole church seemed to settle, seemed to exhale, seemed to lean back a fraction of an inch into the wood of the pews, and Sarah understood, with a cold drop in her stomach, that the pastor had not been speaking to God. Or not only to God. He had been speaking to the thing in the woods, and he had been saying: *we remember. We are still keeping it. Please.*
Lily leaned against her and whispered, "Mama, why did he say promises?"
"Shh," Sarah said. "Listen to the pastor."
"But what promises?"
"I don't know, sweetheart. Shh."
She did know. She had known since the night she found the page in her mother's Bible — a half-sheet of lined paper in Ruth Grey's small, slanting hand, folded once, with a date on it and a list of names and a single line at the bottom that Sarah had read and read again and then put back in the Bible and closed the Bible and sat with her hands flat on the kitchen table for a long time. *We give the woods their silence and they give us ours.* That was all. That was the whole of it, the whole of the thing her mother had kept, folded in the book she read every night of her life. And now the pastor was up there in his pulpit saying *we have kept our promises* and the whole town was breathing out, and Sarah sat in the back pew with her daughter against her side and thought: *They're not praying. They're feeding it.*
---
The candles were lit from a single flame that came down the center aisle, hand to hand, wick to wick, the way it always did at Christmas Eve service, and there was something obscene about it now, the ordinary beauty of it, the small gold lights blooming one by one in the dark of the sanctuary while the wind pressed against the windows. Sarah took the flame from Marnie Holt's candle and lit her own and held it, and the wax was warm on her fingers and the light made a small gold room around her and Lily, and she was aware, suddenly and sharply, of how many people in that room were not looking at their candles.
They were looking at the windows.
Not all at once. Not obviously. But she saw Marnie Holt's eyes go past her, over her shoulder, to the black glass behind the altar, and then come back. She saw old Mr. Pelletier turn his head a quarter inch toward the side windows and hold it there a moment, and then turn back. She saw Mrs. Boyle, whose hands were folded, whose lips were moving, whose eyes were fixed on the window to the left of the pulpit — fixed, not glancing, fixed, the way you fix on something you are afraid will move if you look away.
Sarah looked at the window. She could see nothing but the church's own light, the doubled shapes of the congregation floating in the dark, a dim gold smear of candle flame. And then, past the reflection, she saw the woods.
The parsonage land backed up on the Hollow. Everybody in Greythorn knew that. The church had been built on the high ground at the edge of town in 1791, and the woods had been at the edge of it then and the woods were at the edge of it now, closer, always closer, the way the Hollow was always closer. Through the rippled glass, past the reflections, she could see the black mass of the tree line, and the trees were still. The wind was pressing against the windows hard enough to rattle the old frames in their sashes, and the trees were not moving. Not a branch. Not a twig. The Hollow stood black and motionless at the edge of the church's light like something holding its breath, and every few seconds another head in the congregation would turn toward one window or another and look, and then look away.
They were checking. That was what they were doing. Sarah understood it all at once, with a clarity that made her candle shake. Every person in that room was checking that the forest was still where they had left it.
---
The hymn was "Abide with Me," which Sarah had always thought was a hymn for the dying and which the congregation sang that night in a low, careful murmur, as though they did not want to be heard. She sang the first verse because she knew it and because Lily was singing it, Lily's small clear voice going up into the high dark of the ceiling, *when other helpers fail and comforts flee,* and Sarah's throat closed around the second verse and she stopped and held her candle and listened to the town sing.
Somebody in the front was crying. Not loudly. A woman's tears, quiet, and the small wet catch of her breath between the lines. Sarah could not see who it was. She did not need to. Half the women in that room had children, and half the children in that room had been told this autumn not to go past the fence line, not to go into the woods, not ever, not even in daylight, not even with a grown-up, and a good many of them had been told it in a voice that frightened them more than the woods ever had.
After the hymn there was a silence, and into the silence Pastor Ellis said, "We will now read the names."
Sarah's hands went cold.
She had not known there would be a reading of names. There had been no program, no order of service — the church had run out of printed bulletins in October and had not printed more. The pastor had a sheet of paper in his hand, a single sheet, and the paper shook a little. He put on his reading glasses. He read the names slowly, the way you read the names of the dead.
"Ethan Marsh," he said. "Nine years old. Taken in August."
"Ruth Grey," he said, and Sarah's heart turned over in her chest, and Lily's hand found hers and held it hard. "Taken in September. Though she was old, and her going was her own, and we do not count her among — " He stopped. He was quiet a moment. "We hold her," he said. "We hold her with the others."
"Anna Kowalski," he said. "Eleven years old. Taken in October."
"Tommy Boyle," he said, and Mrs. Boyle made a sound in the front of the church, a small sound, a sound like a door opening on a room nobody had entered for years, and her husband put his arm around her and she leaned into him and the sound stopped. "Seven years old. Taken in October."
He read more names. Some of them were names of people Sarah had never met, gone before she came back, the slow accumulation of a town's losses over twenty years — a boy in 2004, a girl in 2007, a man in 2011 who had gone in after his dog and never come out and whose dog had come out three days later and sat on the man's porch and would not eat. Some of them were names of people who had come out of the woods and were not the same, and the pastor read those names too, quietly, and did not say what had happened to them, and the people in the church who knew did not look at the families. Danny Henderson's name was among them. Danny Henderson sat between his parents and did not look up.
And then the pastor folded the paper and said, "And we hold the ones we do not have names for. We hold the ones the woods have kept. We do not know how many. We do not know who. We hold them."
The congregation said amen. The word went through the room like a wind through wheat, and Sarah did not say it, and Lily did not say it, and Sarah was aware of her own silence as though it were a stone in her pocket.
---
After the service they did not leave. Nobody left. The pastor said, "We will keep the vigil until dawn," and the congregation settled in, the way people settle in for a long wait — the older ones finding seats, the younger ones leaning against the walls, the mothers with small children making nests of coats in the pews. Somebody brought out a folding table from the fellowship hall with a coffee urn and a plate of cookies and a plate of sandwiches, and somebody else brought a thermos of cocoa, and the church filled with the smell of weak coffee and the small domestic sounds of a room full of people who were frightened and trying to be kind to each other. It was, Sarah thought, the most Greythorn thing she had ever seen. A town under siege, passing around a plate of cookies.
She found a corner near the back with a clear view of the room and sat down on the floor with her back against the wall, because Lily was small and the pews were hard and the floor was where Lily wanted to be anyway. Lily had her coloring book and her box of crayons and she spread them out on the floor in the lamplight and began to color with the fierce concentration of a child who has decided that the adult world is doing something she cannot help with and has decided to do her own work instead.
Sarah watched the room.
She watched the way people talked to each other — quietly, in low voices, their heads close together. She watched the way the talk would stop, now and then, all at once, like a radio going off, and everybody in the conversation would look toward the windows, and then somebody would say something ordinary, *cold out there tonight,* and the talk would start again. She watched the way nobody sat with their back to a window. She watched the way the older people, the ones who had been in Greythorn the longest, sat nearest the center of the room, and the younger ones, the ones who had moved in from away, sat nearest the walls, and she wondered whether that was deliberate or whether it was something the town did without knowing, like a herd of animals turning their young to the inside of the circle.
Sheriff Coats came and sat down beside her on the floor, which surprised her.
He had his hat off and his hair was flat and gray and there was a stain on his shirt collar, and he sat down heavily, the way a man sits down when he has been on his feet for a long time and has not been sleeping. He did not say anything for a while. He looked at Lily's coloring book, which was a page of a rabbit in a waistcoat, and Lily had colored the waistcoat a deep red and the rabbit's eyes were very large and very black.
"That's good," Coats said.
"Thank you," Lily said, without looking up. "It's for Mama."
"It's Mr. McGregor's garden," Sarah said. "She's been on a Beatrix Potter kick."
"Nothing wrong with Beatrix Potter," Coats said. He was quiet a moment. "Mrs. Grey," he said, and Sarah looked at him, because nobody called her Mrs. Grey except the schoolchildren and the man at the hardware store. "I want to say something to you and I want to say it plainly and I don't want you to think I'm drunk, because I am not drunk, though I have been, and I will be again, and that is my business. But I am not drunk now."
"All right," Sarah said.
"You've been asking questions," he said. "About your mother. About the woods. About what happened to the Marsh boy and the Kowalski girl and the rest." He turned his head and looked at her, and his eyes were tired and clear and very sad. "I know you've been asking because people tell me things. This is a small town and I am the sheriff and people tell me things. Marnie Holt at the post office tells me you've been going through your mother's papers. Ed Pelletier tells me you asked him about the old boundary lines up on the ridge. Mrs. Boyle tells me — " he stopped. "Mrs. Boyle tells me you asked her what the school board said at the meeting in October, the closed one."
"I did," Sarah said.
"You're going to find things," Coats said. "You're going to find things and you're not going to like them and you're going to want to do something about them. I know that about you, Mrs. Grey. I knew your mother and I know the kind of woman she was and I know the kind of daughter she raised. You're going to want to do something."
"What should I do instead?" Sarah said. "Nothing? Like everybody else in this room?"
Coats was quiet a long time. Lily colored. The rabbit's waistcoat was very red.
"I've been the sheriff of this town for twenty-two years," Coats said at last. "In twenty-two years I have written up three hundred and forty-one incident reports. Most of them are nothing — domestic, DUIs, a stolen bicycle, a barn fire, kids setting off firecrackers in the cemetery on Halloween. But some of them are not nothing. Some of them are people who went into the woods and came out with no memory of the walk. Some of them are people who went into the woods and didn't come out. Some of them are — " he stopped. He looked at the window over their heads, the black glass, the reflections, the still black trees beyond. "Some of them are things I have never written up," he said. "Because there was no form for them. Because I did not know what to put in the box. Because I have a wife and a daughter in this town and I did not want to be the sheriff who wrote down what I saw."
"What did you see?" Sarah said. Her voice was very quiet.
Coats shook his head. "I'm not going to tell you that tonight," he said. "Not in this room. Not with her here." He nodded at Lily. "But I'll tell you this. Your mother knew. Your mother knew more than anybody in this town except Mrs. Thorne, and Mrs. Thorne is — " he made a small gesture with his hand, a gesture that meant *fading,* that meant *going.* "Your mother kept the records. She kept them for forty years. Every birth, every death, every going-into-the-woods and every coming-out. She kept them in her house somewhere and she never showed them to me and I never asked, because I did not want to know, and now she's gone and you're her daughter and you're going to find them, and I am telling you now, tonight, in this church, that when you do, you should be careful."
"Careful of what?"
"Careful of the way it gets into you," Coats said. "The knowing. Careful of the way it starts to feel like a thing you have to carry alone. Your mother carried it alone for forty years and it ate her, Mrs. Grey. It ate her from the inside out. She was the best woman I ever knew and she died in that house alone with the curtains drawn and a page of names in her Bible, and I am not going to stand by and watch the same thing happen to her daughter."
Sarah looked at him. The candlelight made his face look older than it was and the shadows under his eyes look deeper.
"You said *the way it gets into you,*" she said. "You said *the knowing.* Sheriff, what do you know?"
Coats was quiet. The coffee urn burbled in the fellowship hall. Somewhere a child laughed, a small bright laugh in the middle of that room full of frightened people, and it was the worst sound Sarah had heard all night.
"I know that it's breaking," Coats said at last. "The pact. Whatever it is. Whatever your mother and Mrs. Thorne and the old ones kept. It's breaking, and I don't know why, and I don't know how to fix it, and every night I sit in my truck at the edge of the Cold River Road with the engine running and the heater on and I watch the tree line, and every night it's a little closer. That's what I know. That's all I know. And I know that the people in this room are singing hymns and lighting candles and telling themselves that if they are good and quiet and faithful it will go back to the way it was, and I know it will not, and I know that they know it, and I know that we are all going to keep on pretending until we can't anymore."
He stood up. He put his hat on. He looked down at Lily, who had stopped coloring and was looking up at him with her big dark eyes, and he said, very gently, "You keep coloring, sweetheart. You color the best rabbit in the whole state of Vermont."
"Okay," Lily said.
Coats walked away into the crowd, and Sarah watched him go, and Lily went back to her coloring.
---
The vigil went on.
At ten o'clock the children were laid down in the pews and covered with coats. At eleven the coffee ran out and somebody made more. At midnight the rain stopped and the wind stopped with it, and the silence that came down over the church was so complete that Sarah could hear the wax of her candle hissing, could hear her own breathing, could hear the small dry sound of Lily's crayon on the paper.
The silence woke her. She had been half-dozing, her head against the wall, and the silence woke her the way a sound would have. She sat up. The church was full of people and the church was silent — not the silence of people sleeping, which has breath in it, but a listening silence, a held silence, the whole room leaning toward the windows.
Sarah looked at the windows.
The trees were closer.
She knew, the way you know things in dreams, that they had not been that close before. The parsonage land was wide — she had driven past it a hundred times, the white house, the mown field, the fence at the edge of the field, the tree line beyond. The tree line should have been a hundred yards from the church windows. It was not a hundred yards now. It was thirty. It was twenty. The black trees stood in the dark beyond the glass with their branches still and their trunks black and their mass filling the windows from top to bottom, and the church's own light went out through the glass and did not reach them, did not illuminate them at all, as though the light were being refused.
And in the trees, at the edge of the trees, there were faces.
Not clearly. Not faces you could name. The suggestion of faces, the pale blur of them, the way the fog makes shapes in a field and your eye finds them and names them and then the wind moves and they are gone. Sarah looked at the window and saw them and did not look away. She was aware of her heart, of her hands, of the exact temperature of the air. Lily was asleep beside her, curled on the floor with her head on Sarah's coat, her coloring book open beside her, the rabbit in the waistcoat all done and a new page begun — a garden, Sarah saw, a garden with a fence, and beyond the fence a dark scribble of trees, and inside the trees, very small, very carefully colored, a row of small figures with round pale heads.
Sarah's throat closed.
"Lily," she whispered. "Lily, wake up."
Lily did not wake. Her breathing was slow and even and deep, the breathing of a child in the deepest part of sleep, and Sarah put her hand on her daughter's shoulder and felt the warmth of her and did not shake her. She did not want to wake her. She did not want her to see the windows.
She looked around the church. The room was full of sleeping people, and the ones who were not sleeping were sitting up in the pews with their candles and their faces turned to the windows, and nobody was screaming, nobody was running, and that was somehow the worst part. They had known. They had all known. They had come here tonight not to pray for the lost children but to sit in a lit room together and watch the woods come closer and hope that the light and the numbers and the singing would be enough to keep it at the edge of the field.
Pastor Ellis was standing at the front of the church with his hands folded and his eyes closed and his lips moving. Sarah watched him. She could not hear what he was saying. She was not sure she wanted to. She thought, with a cold clarity that felt like the first honest thought she had had in weeks: *He is not praying to God. He is negotiating.*
And then, from outside, from the trees, from the dark beyond the glass, she heard a child singing.
It was very faint. It was so faint that at first she thought it was in her own head, the way a song gets into your head and will not leave. But it was not in her head. It was out there, in the trees, thin and clear and high, a child's voice singing a hymn — *Abide with me, fast falls the eventide* — and the notes were right and the words were right and the voice was wrong, was wrong in a way Sarah could not have explained and would never be able to explain, was wrong the way a reflection is wrong, was wrong the way a familiar face is wrong when it looks at you without recognition.
The sleeping people did not wake. Sarah looked around the church and the sleeping people did not wake and the waking people did not move and the singing went on, verse after verse, *when other helpers fail and comforts flee,* and Sarah sat on the floor of the church with her hand on her sleeping daughter's shoulder and listened to the forest sing the hymn the town had just sung, and understood — with a horror that was not panic, that was worse than panic, that was as cold and quiet as the space between two heartbeats — that it had been listening. It had been listening all night. It had heard the names the pastor read and the hymn the town sang and the promise the pastor made, and now it was singing back, and the voice it was singing in was a voice that somebody in that room had lost.
It sang the whole hymn. Sarah counted the verses. It sang all of them, all five, and when it was done there was a silence in the trees, and then, faint and far and unmistakably a child's, there was a laugh.
And then nothing.
The trees were still. The faces were gone. The windows were black and empty and the church's light lay on the glass like a hand on a cold window, and the room breathed out, all at once, the held breath of a hundred people, and Pastor Ellis said, in a voice that was trying very hard to be steady, "The Lord is with us. The Lord is with us in the dark. Let us pray."
Nobody said amen. Nobody said anything. But the town got to its knees on the hard floor of the church, and Sarah got to her knees too, because she did not know what else to do, and she did not close her eyes, and she did not let go of Lily's shoulder, and she looked at the windows and thought: *It knows our names. It knows our songs. It knows our promises. And it is not going to go back into the woods.*
---
The dawn came gray and slow, and the town went home.
Sarah carried Lily to the car. Lily woke halfway there, muzzy and cross, and said, "Mama, why are we outside?" and Sarah said, "We're going home, sweetheart, go back to sleep," and Lily said, "Did the candles work?" and Sarah said, "Yes, baby. The candles worked." She did not know why she said it. It was a lie. It was the first lie she had told her daughter in a long time, and she told it the way she had told so many lies this autumn — easily, smoothly, with a mother's practiced hand — and she hated herself for it and she did it anyway, because the alternative was to tell the truth, and the truth was that the candles had not worked, that the candles had never been meant to work, that the candles and the hymns and the reading of names were not a prayer but an offering, and that the town had gone home at dawn the way it always went home, to sleep and then to work and then to sleep, and to wait for the next thing to be taken.
She buckled Lily into her car seat and got into the driver's seat and sat for a moment with her hands on the wheel. The church parking lot was emptying. The Hendersons' truck pulled out ahead of her and she watched its taillights go down the hill toward the Cold River Road, and she watched Sheriff Coats's cruiser pull out behind it and follow, and she watched the last of the town's cars go down the hill and turn toward their own houses, and she thought about the way every one of them had glanced at the windows, and the way nobody had said the word aloud, and the way the pastor had said *we have kept our promises* and the whole church had leaned back into the wood of the pews.
She thought about the page in her mother's Bible. *We give the woods their silence and they give us ours.*
She thought about her mother, alone in that house for forty years, keeping the records, keeping the silence, keeping the promises.
And she thought about Lily's coloring book, the garden page, the small figures in the trees with their round pale heads, colored so carefully, colored the way a child colors something she has seen with her own eyes and is not afraid of because she does not yet know that she is supposed to be.
Sarah started the car. She drove her daughter home through the gray dawn, and the woods were at the edge of the road the whole way, and they did not move, and she did not look at them, and she did not look away.