Eleven O'Clock Sharp
The parking lot was nearly empty at eleven o'clock, which was how Margaret liked it. Just the row of cars belonging to the night shift, huddled together under the sodium lights like animals sheltering from weather. She pulled into her usual spot—third from the end, closest to the employee entrance, a small superstition she'd never examined—and sat for a moment with the engine off, listening to the tick of cooling metal.
Through the windshield, the hospital rose against the dark: six stories of brick and glass, most of its windows dark, a few lit from within where someone was working or someone was dying or someone was doing both. The sign above the emergency entrance glowed red—EMERGENCY—steady and patient. She had worked here for twenty-four years. She had never once come to this building without feeling the weight of it settle onto her shoulders like a coat she couldn't take off.
The October air hit her face as she stepped out of the car, sharp and smelling faintly of diesel and wet leaves. Fall had come late this year, the trees along the ridge still holding most of their color, but the nights had turned cold enough that she'd started wearing her heavier jacket. She walked past the smokers' bench—empty now, though it would have its regulars by one or two in the morning, the aides and the orderlies who braved the cold for ten minutes of nicotine and complaint—and pushed through the employee entrance into the corridor that led to the locker room.
The hospital at night smelled different than it did during the day. Days smelled like antiseptic and cafeteria food, like flowers in the gift shop and the sharp chemical bite of the lab. Nights smelled like floor wax and old coffee, like the particular staleness of air that had been breathed too many times. She had come to think of it as the smell of patience—the patience of the building itself, waiting out the dark.
The locker room was empty. She changed out of her street clothes—jeans, a gray sweater, the boots she'd bought last winter and already worn through at the heels—and into her scrubs, the same pale blue she'd worn for two decades. Her locker door hung slightly crooked on its hinges, a defect she'd been reporting to maintenance for three years. She'd stopped expecting anyone to fix it. She'd stopped expecting anyone to fix most things.
Her name tag clipped to her shirt pocket: MARGARET HALE, RN. Someone had once asked her if she'd ever considered going by Maggie. She'd said no, and hadn't explained. Margaret was her mother's name, and her grandmother's before that, a line of women who had worked and endured and not complained. It seemed important, somehow, to carry it properly.
She stopped at the nurses' station on the third floor to pick up her assignment. The night supervisor, a woman named Carol who had been doing this job since before Margaret was born, handed her the printout without looking up from her crossword puzzle.
"Ellison in 312," Carol said. "CHF. He's been asking about you."
"About me specifically?"
"Said he wanted the night nurse who reads." Carol penciled in a word, frowned at it, erased it. "I told him most of us can read."
Margaret looked at the assignment sheet. Four patients in her section, all of them elderly, all of them here because they had nowhere else to be. Two with family who would visit tomorrow and one with family who wouldn't visit at all. And Mr. Ellison, eighty-seven years old, admitted three days ago with fluid in his lungs and a heart that was slowly giving out.
"How is he?" she asked.
"Still alive. Still talking." Carol turned the crossword toward her. "Six letters, starts with E, means 'to endure.'"
"Endure," Margaret said.
Carol wrote it in. "You're wasted on night shift."
Margaret didn't answer. She took the assignment sheet and walked the long hallway toward her section, her footsteps echoing off the linoleum. The overhead lights hummed their particular frequency, a sound you stopped hearing after twenty minutes, a sound that followed you home and sang in your ears as you fell asleep.
Room 312 was at the end of the hall, past the empty rooms that had once held patients and now held only beds stripped to their mattresses, past the supply closet that had been converted to storage when the hospital downsized, past the window that looked out over the town and the hills beyond. She paused at the window, as she always did.
The town spread below her: grid of streets, houses with lights in a few windows, the dark shapes of the old factories along the river. The steel mill had closed before Margaret was born, but the town had never quite accepted it. New businesses had come and gone—a plastics plant, a distribution center, a call center that had promised two hundred jobs and delivered forty before folding. The hospital was the largest employer now. The hospital was the only employer, if you didn't count the Walmart out on the highway or the three dollar stores that had opened in the past decade and the two that had already closed.
From this window, though, in the dark, the town looked almost beautiful. You couldn't see the boarded-up storefronts or the houses with tarps on their roofs or the men gathered around burn barrels in the vacant lot behind the old post office. You could only see the lights, scattered and steady, and the sky above them, dark and patient and indifferent.
She had stood at this window on her first night shift, twenty-four years ago, a girl of eighteen who had just made the biggest mistake of her life. She remembered the weight of the uniform, the smell of the disinfectant, the terror of being responsible for lives she barely understood. She remembered thinking: I could still leave. I could still change my mind.
She had not left. She had not changed her mind.
---
Mr. Ellison was awake when she came in, propped up against his pillows, a book open on his lap. His eyes came up when she entered, bright and sharp in a face that had otherwise given in to age. The skin hung loose on his bones, gray and papery, and the oxygen cannula under his nose made a small hissing sound like a distant ocean. But his eyes—his eyes were not the eyes of a dying man. They were the eyes of someone watching, cataloging, saving up the world.
"Miss Hale," he said. "I was hoping you'd be on tonight."
"You should be sleeping, Mr. Ellison. It's after eleven."
"I'm eighty-seven years old. I'll sleep when I'm dead." He said it without self-pity, a simple statement of fact. "Besides, I was reading. I wanted to finish the chapter."
She checked his vitals while he talked, the familiar motions of her work: blood pressure cuff, thermometer, pulse oximeter on his finger. His numbers were not good, but they were what she expected. He was stable for now. Stable was a relative term, in this room.
"What are you reading?" she asked.
"Poetry. What else?" He turned the book toward her so she could see the cover. A thin volume, gray with age, the title worn nearly illegible. "You ever heard of R. S. Ellison?"
She had not. She said so.
"A poet," he said. "Published one collection, in 1972. Won a prize, got some attention. Then nothing. Disappeared."
"Like Salinger?"
"Like Salinger, but without the fame. Mine—his—book sold maybe three thousand copies. It's out of print now. You can't even find it on the internet." He said this without bitterness, as if it were an interesting fact about a stranger. "There's one used copy on that website, selling for sixty dollars. I check every few months. I like to know it's still out there."
She wondered if he was confused, if the heart failure was affecting his mind. But his eyes were too clear, his voice too steady. "Is that why you wanted me?" she asked. "Because I read?"
"I wanted someone who would understand that I'm not just a dying old man. I'm a dying old man who wrote a book." He smiled, a thin smile that didn't reach his eyes. "The nurses here are kind. They're very kind. But they talk to me like I'm already gone. Like I'm just a body that hasn't stopped moving yet."
"And I don't do that?"
"You haven't decided yet what I am." He closed the book and set it on the bedside table. "That's what I like about you. You're still making up your mind."
She finished her checks in silence, adjusted his oxygen, wrote the numbers on his chart. The monitor beeped its steady rhythm, the sound of his heart doing its work, the sound of a machine doing the work his body could no longer do alone.
"I'll be back in an hour," she said. "Try to sleep."
"I'll try." He closed his eyes, but she knew he wouldn't sleep. She had seen enough dying men to know the ones who slept and the ones who didn't. Mr. Ellison was in the second category. He had things to do before he went, things he hadn't finished, words he hadn't said. He was holding on to the world with both hands, and the world was slipping through his fingers.
---
The hours passed the way they always did: slowly and then all at once, a rhythm of checks and charts and quiet interventions. She did her rounds at midnight, at one, at two. She adjusted pillows and emptied catheter bags and wrote down numbers that meant life and numbers that meant death. She answered call lights before the second ring, because the second ring woke the patients who were sleeping, and the patients who were sleeping needed their sleep.
At 2:15, she found Mr. Ellison awake again, staring at the ceiling.
"Can't sleep?" she asked.
"I keep thinking about the book," he said. "About what happened to it. What happened to me."
She sat down in the chair beside his bed. It was not her job to sit with him. It was not her job to listen. But the night was long and the floor was quiet and there was no one else to do it.
"Tell me," she said.
He told her. He had been twenty-three years old when the book came out, living in New York, working a job in a bookstore and writing at night. The collection had been published by a small press, well-regarded, and it had received a review in the Times—a good review, a review that had called him "a poet of uncommon precision and feeling." He had thought it was the beginning of something. He had thought he would write more books, better books, books that would last.
"The second book was harder," he said. "The first one came out of nowhere. I didn't know how I'd done it. I didn't know how to do it again." He paused, his breathing raspy. "I got married. I had children. I got a job teaching, and then a job in publishing, and then another job in publishing. The years went by. I kept thinking: I'll write when things settle down. I'll write when the kids are older. I'll write when I retire."
"But you didn't."
"I didn't." He turned his head to look at her. "My wife died eight years ago. My children live in California. They call on Sundays. They think I'm a nice old man who used to write poetry. They don't know that I'm the nice old man who used to write poetry and stopped because he was afraid."
"Afraid of what?"
"That the second book wouldn't be as good as the first. That the review in the Times was a fluke. That I was a fraud." He smiled again, the same thin smile. "I had one good book in me. Maybe two. But I was too scared to find out which."
Margaret didn't know what to say. She had never had one good thing in her. She had never had anything that could be taken away.
"Why are you telling me this?" she asked.
"Because you're the only one here who might understand." He held her gaze. "You have the look of someone who made a choice once and has been living with it ever since. Am I right?"
She stood up. "I need to check on my other patients."
"Of course." He closed his eyes. "I'm not going anywhere. I'll be here when you come back."
---
She walked the hallway to the other rooms, checking vitals, adjusting blankets, doing the work she knew how to do. Mrs. Patterson was asleep, her breathing steady, her heart monitor beeping its reassuring rhythm. Mr. Kowalski was awake, watching a game show on the television with the sound off, his face slack with boredom or medication. She asked if he needed anything. He said no, and she moved on.
The hallway was empty, as it always was at this hour. The fluorescent lights hummed. The linoleum gleamed. She stopped at the window again, looked out at the town.
The lights were fewer now. The houses that had been lit when she arrived were dark, and the houses that had been dark were still dark. Only the streetlights remained, a grid of orange dots stretching into the hills. Somewhere out there, in one of those dark houses, people were sleeping. They were sleeping and dreaming and not thinking about the hospital, not thinking about the dying man in room 312, not thinking about the night nurse at the window.
She had been one of them once. She had slept at night, like a normal person, before she took this job. She had gone to bed when the sun went down and woken when it came up, and she had complained about it like everyone else, not knowing that she was lucky, not knowing that sleep was a kind of grace.
Now she slept in the daytime, in the gray hours of the morning when the sun was up but the world was quiet. She had blackout curtains in her bedroom, and earplugs, and a white noise machine that played the sound of rain. She had not seen the sun rise in years, except through the window of a hospital room, except through the glass of a car windshield on her way home.
She thought about Mr. Ellison's question. What had she been afraid of? She had been afraid of the art school, of the strangers, of the city. She had been afraid of herself, of what she might become if she left. She had been afraid of the future and had chosen the past instead.
Or maybe it was simpler than that. Maybe she had just been tired. Maybe she had been eighteen years old and scared and her mother had been sick and her sister had been leaving and someone had to stay. Someone always had to stay.
She had stayed.
---
At three o'clock, she went back to Mr. Ellison's room. He was still awake, still staring at the ceiling, but he turned his head when she came in.
"I was thinking about your sister," he said.
Margaret stopped. "My sister?"
"The one on the postcards." He pointed to the bulletin board by the door, where patients sometimes pinned cards and photos. She had not noticed anything there. She looked now and saw them: three postcards, pinned in a neat row, the handwriting on the back of each one small and precise.
"I didn't put those there," she said.
"The day nurse did. She thought I might like the pictures." He paused. "They're from your sister, aren't they? The ones you carry in your bag. The ones you don't open."
"How do you know about that?"
"You told me. Last night. You don't remember, because you were tired and I was dying and we were both a little loose with our words." He smiled. "You said your sister sends you postcards from all over the world and you never open them. You said you're afraid of what they might say."
She hadn't remembered telling him that. She didn't remember telling anyone that. But the postcards were in her bag, in the inner pocket, unopened, the way they had been for years. She had stopped counting them. She had stopped keeping them in a drawer and started carrying them with her, a talisman, a reminder of everything she had refused.
"Dana," she said. "Her name is Dana."
"Where is she now?"
"I don't know." The words came out flat, without emotion. "She moves around. She lived in Paris for a while. Then Berlin. Then some place in Portugal, I think. She sends postcards. I don't read them."
"Why not?"
She could have lied. She could have said she was too busy, too tired, too angry. But the night was deep and the room was quiet and the dying man was watching her with those clear, patient eyes.
"Because if I read them, I have to know what she's doing. And if I know what she's doing, I have to think about what I'm doing. And I don't want to think about what I'm doing."
"What are you doing?"
"This." She gestured at the room, the hallway, the hospital, the town. "This is what I'm doing. This is what I've been doing for twenty-four years."
"And what did you want to do?"
She didn't answer. She hadn't been asked that question in a long time. She had stopped asking it of herself.
"You were an artist," Mr. Ellison said. It wasn't a question. "You told me. Last night. You said you wanted to go to art school, but you didn't. You said your sister went instead."
"She went to the Rhode Island School of Design. She sent me a postcard from Providence. I didn't open that one either."
"What did you do instead?"
"I became a nurse."
"Why?"
She thought about it. She had never put it into words, not even to herself. "Because it was practical," she said finally. "Because there was a nursing program at the community college. Because I could finish in two years and get a job and start earning money. Because my mother was sick and my sister was leaving and someone had to stay."
"Someone always has to stay," Mr. Ellison said. "But it doesn't have to be you. Not forever."
She looked at him. His face was gray and tired, but his eyes were bright, too bright, the eyes of a man who had run out of time and was trying to give away what he had left.
"What are you saying?" she asked.
"I'm saying I made my choice. I chose safety over art, and I've been paying for it ever since. I'm eighty-seven years old and I'm dying in a hospital in a town I moved to because my daughter thought it would be nice to be near her, and I have one book to my name and no idea what it means. I'm saying you're forty-two. You have time. You have more time than you think."
"I can't just—"
"You can't just what? Quit your job? Move to a city? Go back to school?" He laughed, a dry, rattling laugh. "Of course you can. People do it every day. They just have to decide."
She stood up. Her hands were shaking, and she didn't know why. She had not felt this in years, this thing that was rising in her chest, this thing that might have been hope or might have been fear or might have been something else completely. She had spent so long not feeling it that she had forgotten what it was called.
"I have to check on my other patients," she said.
"Of course you do." He closed his eyes. "But think about it. That's all I'm asking. Think about it."
---
The rest of the shift passed in a blur. She did her rounds, wrote her notes, sat at the nurses' station and tried to read a magazine. The words didn't make sense. She read the same paragraph three times and still didn't know what it said. She kept thinking about Mr. Ellison, about his book, about his question. She kept thinking about the postcards in her bag, unopened, a weight she had been carrying for years without knowing it.
At five o'clock, she took her break. She went to the cafeteria, which was closed, and sat at one of the tables by the window, looking out at the dark town. The sky was beginning to lighten in the east, a thin gray line above the hills. A few more lights had come on in the houses below. People were waking up, starting their days, getting ready for work or school or whatever their lives required of them.
She took the postcards out of her bag. There were seven of them, a thick stack held together with a rubber band. She had not looked at them in months, had not opened them in years. They were a record of everything she had refused to know.
She took off the rubber band. She looked at the top postcard. It was a photograph of a bridge, arched and graceful, with a river beneath it and a city beyond. The handwriting on the back was Dana's, small and precise, the same handwriting she had seen on birthday cards and letters and notes left on the kitchen table.
She turned it over. She read:
*Dear Margaret, I'm in Prague. It's beautiful here, the kind of beautiful that makes you want to cry, or maybe that's just me. I think about you all the time. I wonder if you're happy. I wonder if you ever think about what you gave up. I know I do. I know I think about you every day. Please write. Please call. I miss you. —Dana*
She set the postcard down. She looked at the next one. Lisbon. Then Amsterdam. Then a small town in Italy she didn't know. Then Barcelona, then Copenhagen, then a place she'd never heard of, somewhere in the south of France.
Each one said the same thing. Each one said: I miss you. I love you. I'm sorry. Please write. Please call.
She had never written. She had never called. She had never even opened the envelopes.
She didn't know why. She had told herself it was because she was busy, because she was tired, because Dana had left and she had stayed and that was that. But that wasn't it. She knew now, sitting in the empty cafeteria with the postcards spread out before her, that it was something else. It was fear. It was envy. It was the terrible knowledge that Dana had done what she couldn't do, had lived the life she couldn't live, and if she opened the postcards and read the words and saw the pictures, she would have to admit that she had made a mistake.
She had made a mistake. She had known it for years. She had just never let herself say it.
---
At six-thirty, she went back to Mr. Ellison's room. He was asleep now, finally, his breathing shallow but steady, his face slack and peaceful. The book of poetry was still on his bedside table. She picked it up, turned it over in her hands.
The cover was worn, the pages yellowed, the spine cracked from years of use. She opened it to the first page and read the title: *The Weight of Small Hours*. Underneath, in a smaller font: *Poems by R. S. Ellison*.
She turned to the first poem. It was short, only a few lines, and she read it slowly, the way she read everything now, as if the words might disappear if she wasn't careful.
*The night is a room we enter alone.*
*The door closes behind us, and we are*
*the only thing awake in the whole house.*
She read it again. Then she read the next one, and the next. She read for twenty minutes, standing by his bed, the fluorescent lights humming above her, the monitor beeping its steady rhythm. She read about loss and regret and the small hours of the night. She read about a man who had been afraid and had let his fear make his choices for him. She read about the life he might have lived if he had been braver.
At the end of the book, on the last page, there was an author's note. It was short, only a paragraph. She read it twice.
*These poems were written between 1968 and 1972, in a small apartment in Brooklyn, by a young man who believed he had something to say. He didn't know then that this would be his only book. He didn't know that the silence would come. But he knew the night, and he knew the weight of the small hours, and he knew that if he didn't write these poems down, they would disappear. So he wrote them. And here they are. And now they belong to you.*
She closed the book. She set it back on the table. She looked at the sleeping man in the bed, his chest rising and falling, his face peaceful in a way it hadn't been all night.
"Thank you," she said, though he couldn't hear her. "Thank you for the book."
She left the room. She walked down the hallway to the nurses' station, where the morning shift was arriving, where Carol was putting away her crossword and gathering her things. The sun was rising now, the gray light turning gold, the windows of the hospital filling with the pale light of morning.
"Anything I should know?" the day nurse asked.
Margaret shook her head. "It was a quiet night. Mr. Ellison in 312 is stable. He's been asking for his book. Make sure he gets it."
"Will do."
She walked to the locker room. She changed out of her scrubs and into her street clothes. She put the postcards back in her bag, but she didn't put them in the inner pocket. She put them in the front pocket, where she could see them, where she could touch them, where she couldn't forget them.
She pushed through the employee entrance into the parking lot. The sun was up now, the sky a pale blue, the trees along the ridge catching the light. She stood for a moment, breathing the cold air, feeling the weight of the night shift settle into her bones.
She thought about Mr. Ellison. She thought about his book, his poem, his question. She thought about Dana, somewhere in the world, sending postcards to a sister who never wrote back.
She got in her car. She started the engine. She drove home through the waking town, past the houses and the stores and the people starting their days, and she thought: I could still leave. I could still change my mind.
She had thought that before. She had thought it on her first night shift, twenty-four years ago, and she had not left. She had not changed her mind.
But this time, for the first time in twenty-four years, she wasn't sure.
---
The house was quiet when she got home. It was always quiet. She had lived alone for fifteen years, since her mother died, and she had gotten used to the silence, the way it wrapped around her like a blanket, the way it made her feel safe and also trapped.
She made coffee. She sat at the kitchen table and looked at the postcards, spread out before her. She read them all again, one by one, the words blurring as the morning light filled the room.
She took out a piece of paper. She took out a pen. She wrote:
*Dear Dana, I'm sorry I never wrote back. I'm sorry I never called. I don't have a good excuse. I was scared, and I was jealous, and I was angry, and I didn't know how to say any of that. I'm still scared. I'm still jealous. I'm still angry. But I'm writing now. I'm writing to say I miss you too. I'm writing to say I'm sorry. I'm writing to say I'm proud of you, and I love you, and I hope you're happy. I hope you're safe. I hope you're still sending postcards. I'll write again soon. —Margaret*
She folded the paper. She put it in an envelope. She addressed it to Dana, at the last address she had, the one in the south of France. She didn't know if it would reach her. She didn't know if Dana was still there. But she would send it anyway. She would send it and hope.
She lay down on her bed, still in her clothes, the blackout curtains drawn, the white noise machine playing its sound of rain. She closed her eyes. She thought about Mr. Ellison, about his book, about the weight of small hours. She thought about the night, and the darkness, and the light that always came.
She slept.
And when she woke, in the afternoon, the first thing she did was check the mail. There was nothing from Dana. But there was a bill, and a catalog, and a letter from the hospital about her upcoming performance review.
She opened the hospital letter. She read it. She set it aside.
She thought: I could still leave. I could still change my mind.
She thought it again, the next night, and the next. She thought it every night, as she drove to work, as she walked through the fluorescent corridors, as she checked on the patients who were mostly elderly, mostly dying, mostly alone.
She thought it until it became a kind of prayer, a kind of hope, a kind of promise she was making to herself.
And slowly, over the weeks and months that followed, she began to believe it.