← The Weight of Small Hours

The Vanished Poet

Chapter 11 of 11 · 4043 words

By two-fifteen he had stabilized enough that she could sit. She pulled the chair from the corner to the side of his bed, where the light from the hallway fell across her clipboard but not across his face, and she sat, and she charted, and she let him talk because he wanted to talk and because the alternative was to make him stop, and she had learned in twenty years that sometimes the talking was the medicine and sometimes it was only the talking, and either way you did not take it away from a dying man who had asked for it by pressing a button in the middle of the night.

"The worst part," he said, "was the second book."

His voice had gone thin, pared down to the wire of itself, but it was steady. The oxygen hissed. The monitor ticked. Somewhere down the hall a bed alarm sounded twice and stopped, a patient shifting, a false alarm, the building murmuring in its sleep.

"Nobody tells you about the second book," he said. "They tell you about the first. The first is all anybody wants to talk about — the first is a miracle, the first is a young man's luck, the first is the one that comes out of nowhere and lands like a stone in still water. But the first book is a gift. The second book is a job."

Margaret wrote the time in the intake column and waited.

"I was twenty-nine when it came out," he said. "Nineteen seventy-two. I was teaching at a little college in Ohio by then, freshman composition, four sections, and I had a rented room with a hot plate and a window that looked at a parking lot. And then the book came out, and within a month I had a review in the Times that used the word 'unforgettable,' which I have thought about every day since, and I was — " He paused. His breath caught, and he held still, and she watched the oximeter climb back from eighty-nine to ninety-one and hold, and he went on. "I was not prepared to be a person who had been called unforgettable. Nobody is. You spend your whole young life wanting to be seen, and then you are seen, and it turns out that being seen is a kind of weather you have to stand in, and you have no coat."

She wrote his respiration rate. Twenty-six. She wrote his oxygen saturation. Ninety-one on four liters. She wrote nothing about what he had said, because there was nowhere on the form for it, and she had learned that the form was not the place, and that the place was her, her memory, the long quiet ledger she kept of the things people told her in the dark.

"They sent me on a reading tour," he said. "Six weeks. I had never been on an airplane. I went to Chicago and then to Boston and then to a place in California where the light was so bright it made me squint through the whole reading and afterward a woman came up to me and said I had looked like a man being questioned by police. She meant it kindly. I think she meant it kindly. I read the same seven poems sixty-some times and by the end of it I could not hear them anymore. They were just sounds. They were just my mouth making sounds I had made before."

"Did you write while you were traveling?" Margaret asked. She did not look up from the clipboard. That was the trick of it, she had found — the not looking up, the pretense of being busy, which gave them the room to say the true thing, because if you looked at them they would see you looking and they would remember themselves and stop.

"That's the question, isn't it," he said. "That's the only question. I didn't. Not a line. I told myself it was the traveling, the hotels, the strange beds. I told myself I would write when I got home. And then I got home and I sat at my desk with the window that looked at the parking lot and I put a piece of paper in the typewriter and I sat there for four hours and I did not write a line, and I told myself it was the noise of the parking lot, and I moved the desk to the other wall, and I did not write a line, and I told myself it was the teaching, the four sections of freshman composition, the papers to grade, and the semester ended and I did not write a line, and I began to understand that something had gone wrong in me, some small mechanism, some little gear that had been turning without my noticing it and had now stopped."

He stopped. His hand came up and pressed against his sternum, an old gesture, a man reaching for the place where the trouble was. She watched his face for the particular wince that meant pain rather than fear, and did not see it, and let him be.

"I had a friend then," he said. "A painter. His name was Walter. He had a studio over a garage and no heat and he painted in his overcoat. He was better than me. He was better than anyone I knew. And I went to him one night because I could not bear to be alone with the stopped gear, and I told him I was finished, I was dry, the well was dry, and he looked at me the way you look at a man who has told you he has a headache when you know he has a tumor, and he said — " Mr. Ellison's mouth moved, remembering, and he made a small sound that might have been a laugh. "He said, 'What makes you think the well is supposed to be full?'"

Margaret wrote the date at the top of a fresh page. Two twenty-two. She had no need of a fresh page. She had done the charting at one o'clock and would not need to do it again until four. But the pen was a thing to hold, and the page was a thing to look at, and the looking gave her the room to listen without seeming to.

"I was angry at him," Mr. Ellison said. "I was so angry I walked out without my coat. It was January. I walked home in my shirtsleeves and I was cold and I was furious and I thought, what a stupid thing to say, what a cruel and stupid thing to say to a man who is drowning. And then I got home and I sat at the desk that looked at the parking lot, and I thought about it, and I understood that he was not being cruel. He was being a painter. He was telling me that the well is not a thing that is full or empty, the well is a thing you dig. You dig it every day. You dig it whether or not there is water in it. That is the whole of it, and it took me another twenty years to understand it, and by then it was too late."

"It's not too late," Margaret said, before she had decided to say it. The words came out flat and a little officious, the way they did when she was not thinking, and she heard them land and wished she had kept them, because they were the kind of thing you said to a man who was going to get better, and he was not going to get better, and he knew it, and she knew it, and there was no use in either of them pretending.

He turned his head on the pillow and looked at her. His eyes were very clear. In the low light they were almost the color of the oxygen tubing, that pale green, and she thought, not for the first time, that whatever had gone wrong in his body had not touched his eyes, that the eyes were the part of him that was still entirely himself.

"You are kind to say so," he said. "But you are a nurse and kind is your trade, and I am a poet and I can hear the difference between a thing said because it is true and a thing said because it is the thing to say. So let us not do that. Let us not be polite. We are past the hour for polite. It is two in the morning and I am dying and you are sitting in the dark with me, and we can afford to be true."

Margaret set the pen down. She put the clipboard on the bed beside her hip and she looked at him, and she did not pretend to be busy, and she said, "All right. Then I'll tell you what I think. I think you're wrong that it's too late. I think a man who can tell a story like that at two in the morning is not a man whose well has run dry. I think the water is right there. I think you're sitting in it."

He was quiet for a long moment. The monitor ticked. The oxygen hissed. Down the hall, a cart rattled past and faded, and then the building exhaled again into its long trough, and he said, very softly, "That is the kindest thing anyone has said to me in fifty years, and I do not think you meant it kindly. I think you meant it as a diagnosis."

"I meant it as an observation," she said.

"The best diagnoses are observations," he said. "That's all a diagnosis is. Someone looks at you honestly and tells you what they see. The trouble with dying is that everyone stops looking at you honestly. They look at you kindly instead. They look at the dying man the way they look at a child's drawing — with their eyes a little softened, a little turned away from the flaws. It is very lonely, being looked at kindly. You would not think so. But it is."

She picked up her pen again. She did not write anything. She held it, and she looked at the page, and she said, "Tell me about the second book."

"There is no second book," he said. "That's the whole of it. That's the story I have been trying to tell you and I keep telling it sideways because it is not a story I have ever told straight. There is no second book. There is a first book, and then there are fifty years in which a man who was once called unforgettable fails to write a second book."

"You stopped writing entirely?"

"No." He shifted, and the monitor's rhythm stuttered, and she watched it recover. "That's the strange thing. That's the thing that took me years to understand. I did not stop writing. I wrote all the time. I wrote in the mornings before class and I wrote in the summers and I filled notebooks, hundreds of pages, and every page of it was — " He made a gesture with his hand, a small dismissive turn of the wrist, a man flicking away a fly. "It was competent. That is the worst word in the language, competent. It was well-made and it was intelligent and it had nothing in it that had not been in it before. I was writing the first book over and over. I was writing the first book in a slightly different key. And I knew it. That is the part I cannot forgive myself for, that I knew it. I would read a poem back and I would hear the competence and I would think, this is not it, and I would put it in the drawer and start another, and I did that for eleven years."

Eleven years. Margaret thought of eleven years the way she thought of any long span now, in shifts — eleven years of nights was more than three thousand of them, three thousand troughs, three thousand times the building exhaled and the ones who were going to die began quietly to do it. She thought of a man in a rented room putting one page after another into a drawer, and she felt something move in her chest that she did not want to feel, and she put it away.

"What happened after eleven years?" she asked.

"I stopped putting them in the drawer," he said. "That was the change. I stopped keeping them. I had a rule by then, a private rule, that I would burn anything I was not sure of, and one night in the spring of nineteen eighty-three I burned eleven years of notebooks in the barrel behind the house. I stood there and I fed them in one at a time and I watched them curl and go, and I felt — " He paused. His breath was shorter now, and she turned the oxygen up half a liter, and he nodded without being asked, a small thanks, and went on. "I felt nothing. That is what I remember. I expected to feel grief, and instead I felt a kind of cleanliness. I thought, now I am empty, and an empty man can be filled. And I went inside and I made a cup of tea and I sat down at the desk and I thought, now. Now it will come."

"And did it?"

"It came the way it always came," he said. "It came at three in the morning, the way it does, and it came as one line, one line of a poem I had been trying to write for a decade, and I got up and I found a pencil and I wrote the line on the back of an envelope and I sat there for an hour with the pencil in my hand and nothing else came. And I thought, all right. One line. I will take one line. I will build the poem around the line. And I could not. The line was a good line, it was the truest line I had written in years, and I could not build a poem around it. It was a door in a wall, and there was no house behind the wall."

He closed his eyes. For a moment she thought he had finished, thought he had worn himself out, and she reached for the call button to put it in his hand, and then he said, without opening his eyes, "Do you know what the line was?"

"No."

"It was: *the small hours have a weight you can measure.*" He opened his eyes and looked at her. "That is all I had. That is all I have. One line, and the weight of the small hours, and fifty years of knowing I could not build the house. And now I am here, in this room, in the small hours, and the weight is very great, and I have measured it every night for a week, and I still do not have the poem."

Margaret sat with it. The chair was hard under her and the room was close with the smell of antiseptic and the faint animal smell of a body that was failing, and the monitor ticked, and she looked at the man in the bed and thought about the door in the wall with no house behind it, and about her own house, the one she had not built, the art school she had not gone to, the life she had chosen at eighteen and never revisited, and she thought — she did not want to think it, and she thought it anyway — that she had been standing in front of her own wall for twenty-four years and had never once tried the door.

"Mr. Ellison," she said.

"Yes."

"Why did you tell me it was you? At the beginning. Why did you insist?"

He was quiet. The oxygen hissed. The building exhaled. And then he said, "Because a man who has been forgotten twice — once by the world and once by himself — will take any chance to be remembered. Even by a night nurse. Even at two in the morning. Especially then." He turned his head on the pillow. "You are the only person who has looked at me honestly in a very long time. I wanted you to look at me and see the poet. Not the dying man. The poet. It is a small vanity, and I am not proud of it, and I am too tired to be anything but honest about it now."

She did not say anything. There was nothing to say that would not have been kind rather than true, and he had asked her not to be kind.

After a while he said, "Will you do something for me?"

"If I can."

"When I am gone," he said, "there will be a box. In my room, in the closet, a cardboard box with a string around it. It is not the notebooks. I burned the notebooks. It is the first book, and the reviews, and a few letters, and one thing more. Will you see that it goes somewhere? I have no one. I have not had anyone in a long time. There is a college in Ohio that still has a poetry prize with my name on it, which I find obscene, but they write to me once a year and ask if I will come and read, and I never answer, and they keep writing. They will take the box. They will not know what to do with it, but they will take it."

"I'll see to it," Margaret said. "I'll make sure it gets where it needs to go."

"Thank you." His eyes closed again. His hand on the blanket relaxed, and his breath slowed, and she sat with him and watched the numbers and did not write them down, because there was nothing to write, because the numbers were the same as they had been, because the only thing that had changed in the last hour was not anything the chart could hold.

She sat until three. At three his breathing had eased, the way it sometimes did near the end of the trough, the body finding its level, and she stood and adjusted his blanket and checked the IV and turned the oxygen back down to three liters because his saturation had climbed to ninety-three and held and she did not want to dry him out. He slept. His face in sleep was the face of a much younger man, the jaw slack, the lines smoothed, and she stood over him for a moment and thought about a barrel behind a house in Ohio and eleven years of paper going up in smoke, and about the one line that had survived it, and about the weight of the small hours, which she had been weighing herself for twenty-four years without knowing it had a name.

She went back to the desk and sat and opened the chart and wrote, at three-oh-five, *Patient resting comfortably. O2 sat 93% on 3L. Respirations even. No complaints.* And then she sat with the pen in her hand and looked at the words and thought that they were true and that they were not the truth, and that the difference between the two was the whole of her job, and the whole of her life, and that she had never once in twenty-four years written down the thing that was actually happening in a room at three in the morning.

At four the aide came through with the breakfast trays and the building began to stir, the false calm giving way to the small commerce of morning, and Margaret poured herself a cup of coffee from the pot in the break room and stood at the window and watched the sky go from black to gray to the color of a bruise. Her sister's postcard was in her locker, unopened, where it had been for three weeks. She had not decided whether she would open it. She had not decided anything, really, for a long time; she had only kept going, shift after shift, and the keeping going had become a kind of answer, and she had never asked herself whether it was the right one.

She thought about the door in the wall. She thought about the well you dig every day whether or not there is water in it. She thought about a man who had been called unforgettable at twenty-nine and had spent fifty years failing to be unforgettable again, and about how the failure had not made him less; it had made him the man in 412 who could tell the truth at two in the morning, which was a thing the young man with the review in the Times had not been able to do.

At five-forty she went back to 412. Mr. Ellison was awake, and he looked at her when she came in, and he said, "Did you sleep?"

"I don't sleep on shift," she said. "I'll sleep at home. In the daylight. Like a vampire."

He smiled. It was a small smile and it cost him something, but it was there. "The small hours," he said. "You keep them. You keep them the way I kept them. You know their weight."

"I know their weight," she said.

"Then you know what I have been trying to tell you," he said. "It is not the poem that matters. I have been telling myself it is the poem, that if I could only build the house I would be saved, but that is not it. It is the line. One line, in fifty years, and it was true, and I wrote it down. That is what a life is. Not the house. The line."

She stood over him with the blood pressure cuff in her hand and did not move to put it on him, because he was not finished, and she had learned to wait.

"Whatever it is you are not doing," he said. "Whatever door you have been standing in front of. Open it. You are not too old and it is not too late and no one is going to come and tell you it is time. That is the thing no one tells you. No one comes. You have to decide it yourself, in the small hours, when the world is empty and there is no one to see you decide."

Margaret put the cuff on his arm and pressed the button and watched the numbers come up, and they were not good numbers, and she wrote them down, and she said, "I'll think about it."

"That is all anyone can do," he said. "Think about it in the small hours. The small hours are for thinking. The rest of the day is for forgetting what you thought."

She finished her rounds at six-forty and gave report at seven and walked out into the parking lot where the sky was the color of dishwater and the air smelled of diesel and wet asphalt. She sat in her car for a long time without starting it. The postcard was in her bag. She had put it there at the end of shift, without deciding to, and now she took it out and looked at it — Dana's handwriting, small and looping, the same handwriting as her own, the handwriting they had both learned from their mother — and she held it for a moment and then she opened it.

*Margaret,* it said. *I'm coming home for a visit. I don't know when. I know you won't write back. I'm coming anyway. — D.*

She read it twice. Then she put it on the passenger seat and started the car and drove home through the gray morning, and the weight of the small hours sat on her chest the whole way, and she did not try to put it down.